"Law & Order: Criminal Intent" The Consoler (TV Episode 2011) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
6 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
Thou shalt not kill
Mrpalli7715 October 2017
A devoted catholic girl committed suicide in her apartment with a gun, leaving a suicide note in her Ipad. Shortly before, she scrubbed with strength her body to clean it from something happened (she was ashamed about a sexual intercourse). Goren doesn't believe from the beginning she shot herself, because in the note there are no sign of religion issue and there's nothing related to her beloved parents. The victim worked in a bank, she had a coworker (former ballplayer) who dated a couple of times, a female friend who is working as tennis coach (former pro in tennis tournaments) and, worst of all, she had an affair with a priest. A huge amount of money was distracted from the church account to an offshore bank and that's the motive, but who is the real perp?

Goren's boss compelled him to see the police's shrink. They really believe he's crazy and should leave the job. Anyway his ability, even in this episode, is out of the question. Another episode that involves church abuse over children, so widespread in movie business; furthermore, it shows the hardship all priests have to face to respect their celibacy vows
12 out of 12 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Law & Order: Criminal Intent- The Consoler
Scarecrow-8828 May 2011
Warning: Spoilers
Nothing saddens me more than the news that Law & Order: Criminal Intent will be over after its 10th season, particularly because of how damn good the first few episodes are. "The Consoler" is such an example as it takes some surprising turns with devastating revelations regarding those supposedly devout within the Catholic Church. Sexual abuse from the past, embezzled millions from an abuse victim, probable sex between the murdered banker and a priest she befriends (Neal McDonough), and a female tennis pal (Lauren Hodges) of the victim who seems to be caught in one lie after another all play a major role in this episode's unveiling of facts which produce the details and eventual confessions which will help detectives Eames and Goren catch a killer. There's also a "suicide confession" found on the victim's iPad that could've been fabricated by someone else who wanted her death to be considered a suicide. Also included in this episode involving the psychologically tormented Robert Goren is his required visits to a therapist (Julia Ormond) where she will attempt to help this troubled man alleviate the problems which haunt him, as he must consult the horrors of the past so that he can actually have closure. I personally think these brief but important scenes (normally each episode, although I've only seen this one and the next episode with the therapy sessions so far) allow someone to address the discomforts and trauma Goren is uneasy about sharing or confessing. Jay O. Sanders is the new Captain (the Major Case Squad seem to have trouble keeping this position filled), Joseph Hannah, who is loyal to Goren, but will expect his detective to keep himself in line because the superiors are not sure he isn't crazy. I like this one scene where Goren, convinced the victim was murdered, questions Hannah, and the Captain has to bring him down to size. You also see how Eames gets uncomfortable with how her partner, at times, almost loses his cool, knowing that Goren needs this job and a lot has been done to give the detective another chance. Vincent D'Onofrio is nothing short of astounding, showing the difficulties of applying his skills and tactics to draw confessions from those who are able to hold information from him, and, especially in his therapy session with Ormond, who wants him to confide in her, to allow a connection so that he can somehow escape what has remained a thorn embedded in the psyche for so long. Erbe is the unsung hero of the team and has a strong female character in Eames, her strength and patience with a partner most would give up on (she turns down the Captain job because of this man, a decision which I will always consider valiant) worthy of a metal. She is the one person who can look Bobby in the eye and stand at his level, her own intelligence and understanding of human nature assets which have made Eames and Goren a superb detective team. "The Consoler" really confronts abuse as its main topic within the story, not only in regards to sexual misconduct but the manipulation of a vulnerable young woman still wrought with the lingering scars from a tragic childhood.
16 out of 19 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
D'onofrio lost a step
mgl-920372 October 2021
I've been rewatching a lot of Criminal intent episodes recently. I'm a big fan of the series overall. This episode was good, but not up to the standard of earlier years. D'onofrio just isn't as convincing. The writing is not so tight, either. It seems to me the episodes in season 10 have less going on than previously.

I'm also not a fan of Jay Sanders as police captain. He's much better as a criminal. The episode where he played a contract killer is one of the best of the entire series.
6 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
SHAME ON "dick" Wolf
hiltonsmithjr11 October 2020
Vincent D'Onofrio was BRILLIANT in this episode. PERIOD. Top 10 for Certain. MASSIVE FAILURE that wolf Would Deprive US of D'Onofrio's Incredible Talent for ANY Reason!! THIS Episode Proves it!! L&O goes 20 and CI ONLY 10? WHAT are you Smoking??!! What a WASTE. THE BEST Character the L&O franchise EVER produced and you just have a BRAIN FART!!!
21 out of 25 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Sin
TheLittleSongbird3 November 2021
Did watch all the episodes of Season 10 with moderate expectations. It was so great to see Goren and Eames back and was really hoping that the show would come back strong after a mixed bag of a previous season. Found myself not disappointed at all by one of the show's best seasons that was criminally far too short. "The Consolor" did intrigue me on paper, though did worry as to whether Goren's character development would dominate too much and how the religious element of the story would be handled.

Because the 'Law and Order' franchise to me has a fairly hit and miss track record when it comes to bringing religion into their cases, sometimes it is intriguing and gives one the creeps but at others it comes over as heavy handed and too judgemental. Luckily, "The Consolor" does better than most episodes of the franchise at not doing any of the latter traps. And Goren's development doesn't take over the case too much. "The Consolor" is another great episode, which was a relief having been so impressed by "Rispetto".

"The Consolor" is at its weakest with everything to do with the therapy, which does intrigues and furthers Goren as a character but slows the momentum at points.

However, everything else is brilliantly done. It is as ever shot with the right amount of intimacy without feeling too up close, even with a reliance of close up camerawork. That the editing has become increasingly tighter over-time is great too. The music isn't over-scored, manipulative or used too much. There is intimacy and tautness in the direction.

Writing is tight and thoughtful, with nothing being laid on too heavily. It didn't feel like some statement was being made or that the writers were making too much of a judgement, both of which have happened with some episodes in the franchise that have religion playing a big role in the story. The story on the most part is absorbing and definitely packs a punch emotionally, with a sad and anger inducing case and also what is said in the therapy. A difficult and sadly still relevant issue is raised in this episode's case, which is done uncompromisingly where you really hate the responsible but also tactfully.

Goren once again is a great character as is his playful yet with degrees of tension chemistry with Eames. The climax is not quite as great as the one in "Rispetto", but again closer to the thought probing and tense ones of the earlier seasons rather than the rushed, melodramatic and ridiculous ones of some of the later episodes that didn't have Goren and Eames. Vincent D'Onofrio is terrific as can be expected. Can't fault the rest of the cast as well (Neal McDonaugh taking top honours in support), though Jay O Sanders never got the chance for his character to grow (not a bad replacement at all, but eight episodes is not enough for a regular cast member with a not massive role to stand out properly).

In conclusion, great. 9/10.
9 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
What makes him tick?
bkoganbing19 January 2016
Celibacy is a tough road to hoe even especially for those priests that are straight. That's what Neal McDonough finds out. Actually it's even for me somewhat refreshing that not all the Catholic priests are gay.

McDonough who's something of a star in the Catholic hierarchy is a monsignor whose good works are legendary. Among other things he's in charge of reparations to victims of abuse. The murder victim is Elle Monte-Brown who was a faithful Catholic who was in charge of an escrow account for proved cases of abuse.

The problem is that the murder really does look like suicide and Vincent D'Onofrio is having one hard time convincing his new boss Jay O. Sanders that it was murder. Monte-Brown was a strict Catholic and the fact that on her first glance it looks like suicide and there's a suicide note on her computer is giving Sanders thoughts that something overcame the religion and she abandoned that strict anti-suicide tenet of the church.

Detective Goren finally gets to see a shrink in this one and the D'Onofrio episodes in the final season will contain a lot of scenes with the psychiatrist. I disagree however that everyone was shying away from him as a patient. I would think they'd be lining up to see what makes him tick.
14 out of 14 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed