The Clearing (TV Mini Series 2023) Poster

(2023)

User Reviews

Review this title
23 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
Superb acting
gallagherkellie16 July 2023
I've never even used the word superb before but it's just so fitting here! The acting was incredible, especially by the girl playing young Amy, Theresa Palmer and the actor playing Saad.

The fact that this is based on a real cult is what got me to watch it, as I've read a lot about that cult over the years. It shocks me to no end that that woman was never brought to justice, but anyway back to the show...yes it was a slow burn but it was still gripping and entertaining enough for me to keep watching. I watched it over 2 days. If you don't like slow dramas then don't watch this. If you're ok with setting the scene, slow paced mysteries then this is for you. Some twists and turns and enough different from the 'true' story to create suspense.
12 out of 16 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Extremely well-acted, but Story Unfolded Unevnly
bnlundell6 September 2023
Just an absolutely phenomenal job from the cast, especially Teresa Palmer and Miranda Otto. Otto is especially chilling in her portrayal of her character at every level of the character's development. She's a marvelous actress who deserves more acclaim. Palmer also shines in a difficult role as a person who has been extremely damaged from her youth in the Kindred cult. Guy Pearce (superb in everything he does) does a great job in a secondary role that is key to the story. Only downside for me is that the story unfolds in multiple timelines and it can be difficult to detect when the timelines change Multiple themes are at play throughout the story and most of them come through without being heavy-handed.
6 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Interesting premise
acostamarian28 May 2023
Warning: Spoilers
I am only two episodes in, since that is all that is available so far, but I like it. I find some aspects a bit predictable, but it doesn't take away from the entertainment. The idea of children being kidnapped and brainwashed, not to mention the abuse they endure at the hands of their "caretakers", is quite horrifying. Sarah in particular portrays that horror better than anyone.

I like the alternating timelines. I think it's cool to see what happened in the past and how the events impact them in the present. (Abigail keeping her name as opposed to Freya is very interesting to me). Can't wait to see what happens next!
12 out of 22 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
"I suspect The Clearing is only going to ramp up with each episode."
watchitwombat29 May 2023
I question the wisdom of watching this when I'm about to have a baby, but if there's one thing I can't resist it's a creepy cult thriller. It was unnerving to watch the events of this story unfold, particularly without having read the book beforehand. Given that the tale is based on real life Aussie cult group The Family, there's already a sense of foreboding as you start the first episode. This sense increases going into the second episode, and you can't help but feel concerned at what might happen next. Theresa Palmer does an excellent job of showcasing the past and present trauma of her character, and Miranda Otto and Guy Pearce play equally disturbed characters. But the true heroes of this series are Julia Savage and Lily LaTorre, who sent chills down my spine with their respective performances. With an 8 episode first season, I suspect The Clearing is only going to ramp up with each episode. Fans of this genre should give this show a watch, it's cast well, has an ominous soundtrack, perturbing visual effects and I'm already itching to see where the story takes us and what secrets it will reveal along the way.

-by Jayne @WatchItWombat.
31 out of 42 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
Gets boring real fast
1nH3ll21 June 2023
I just watched the 6 episode and I'm question myself why I keep watching this series.

The first episode were intriguing and i was curious what happend but my questions were answered a few episodes later. After this no new curiosity sparked, no new mystery to solve and the back and forth between -- now three -- timelines really bore me with details i'm not interested in and the flow is lost everytime they make a timejump.

The characters are also really boring specially the main character who is really unlikable.

There are many shows which are slow but they keep sparking interest but this series fails hard in that regard. The timejumps on top of this just destroy the series. Nothing meaningful is happening.

I can just give this series 4 stars. I would give Yellowjackets 6-7 and one can compare them. Both play in multiple timelines and include the 'cult' theme.

If the purpose of the series is to show the trauma after such events than I would compare it with Rectify which I would rate 8-9.

The best series which included time jumps the best is Damages.

There are other slow and low budget series like The killing or even Top of The Lake which are thousand times better then this one.

I'm happy for You if you enjoy this one. Be reminded that there are many better series out there.
55 out of 82 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
Time jumps are unpleasant
bjvom12 August 2023
I really wanted to like this. I love Theresa Palmer and Miranda Otto is a superstar. There is not a weak spot in the cast at all. I dont usually mind flashbacks and flashforwards, but there are too many and they are too frequent and they are too short. I guess if you set out to deliberately confuse your viewers, you would consider this a success. But when you take the incredibly great performances by the cast (and some of them are truly wonderful) and put them into a confusing and disjointed mess like this you are failing. Still young and active Joe is easy enough to distinguish from old, beat down reprobate Joe, but it is nearly impossible to tell which period Amy/Freya is supposed to be in.
13 out of 19 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Brilliant stuff
There is a very special, very excruciating place reserved in hell for those that run abusive cults, they are the utmost repulsive nadir of human weakness in the collective consciousness. The Clearing is a mostly fictitious, brilliantly complex dramatic thriller with a narrative backbone that is based on the real life Australian cult dubbed 'The Family', raided and disbanded decades ago. This utterly compelling eight episode journey examines several characters revolving around the operation and takedown of a nasty cult called The Kindred, owned, operated and presided over with treacly malevolence by false prophet guru Adrienne 'Maitreya' Beaufort, played with career best intensity by Miranda Otto. We see in non linear form how she came to power using dime-store psychological manipulation, unconventional metaphysical gibberish and thinly veiled psychosis masquerading as pied piper charisma. Woven in is the present day story of Freya (Teresa Palmer, also giving career best work), a girl who was rescued during the eventual raid and who now lives in constant fear and traumatic paranoia as she tries to shield her own children from the cult's temporarily dormant yet still permeating influence. The story is a multi timeline narrative told deliberately out of order, no doubt to emulate for a viewer how disorienting it must feel to find one's life embroiled in such a long, punishing, cruel ordeal. This may not look like much from the outside or be getting the rave reviews it should be but it's some of the best television I've seen this year, a structurally complex, emotionally intelligent, consistently unpredictable piece of work with terrific performances, eerie music and a mature, creepy, empathetic script. Streaming now on Disney Plus.
35 out of 45 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
2/10
Slow and tiring.
monicamora-1248811 September 2023
"The Clearing" began with the promise of an intriguing premise and an air of mystery that piqued my interest. However, as the series unfolded, it became increasingly apparent that it was trapped in a dense thicket of plot holes and absurd situations, leaving me bewildered and unsatisfied.

One of the most glaring issues with "The Clearing" was its pacing-or rather, its lack thereof. Each episode felt like a tedious journey through a murky forest of suspense, with very little actual progress in the story. While suspense can be a valuable element in storytelling, it should serve to enhance the narrative, not drown it in stagnation. Sadly, "The Clearing" leaned heavily on suspense to the detriment of meaningful plot advancement.

Adding to the frustration were the numerous plot holes that riddled the storyline. The narrative appeared to be built on a foundation of loose threads and unresolved questions, leading to confusion rather than curiosity. As the series meandered along, these holes in the plot only seemed to grow wider, leaving viewers with more questions than answers by the end.
10 out of 15 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
2/10
Plodding, slow, ridiculous
l_keith_donovan12 July 2023
This "psychological thriller" is absolutely one of the most ridiculous pieces of garbage ever committed to celluloid (the anachronism isn't lost on me).

The characters are unappealing and none of them has any redeeming qualities. The plotline tries to elicit mystery but only portrays a weird paranoia which only makes the characters and the story more bleak and stark.

It's like a bad V. C. Andrews book but without the charm and comedy, or Jim Jones but not as sane.

The story moves so slowly that it's actually painful to watch. It's a story that didn't need to be told brought to you by people who don't know how to write.

Do yourself a favor and just...no.
21 out of 45 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Intriguing and suspenseful
MissFlozmos3 August 2023
Being familiar with the subject The Clearing is loosely based on, I found this to be a captivating series. The slow pace adds to the suspense and each episode reveals more about the characters and how they got there and how they fit into the story. The acting is superb, especially the young actors playing "Amy" and "Sara/Asha". Miranda Otto is sublime as "Matreiya" and perfectly captures the quiet insanity and unhinged mental state of the mother figure. The supporting cast are equally unhinged, including Freya, Joe, Tamsyn, Hannah, Bryce and Henrik. It is a story of how the sin of one becomes the sin of all.
15 out of 18 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
Very slow and boring show
sportspc1 June 2023
I find this to be very hard to watch. Story is boring and slow. Will skip this one. I have watched 2 episodes and the show is very slow. I don't like the way it goes back and forth; I can't stand these kind of shows. Plus, if the show is canceled, you will never find out why you just wasted your time watching this show in the first place. When I saw who the main character's were, I was excited to check it out. I'm sorry to say but the actors really screwed up by choosing to participate in this show. I don't know how many episodes it will take to actually get an idea what it is about and I really don't care.
36 out of 112 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Haunting tale inspired by reality
njmvandenboomen2 June 2023
Warning: Spoilers
The most unbelievable parts of the series - the following of bleach-blond children, a cult leader walking away scot-free, manipulating people with LSD - have actually all happened. The Family cult led by Annie Hamilton-Byrne during the 1960s to 1980s preyed on the most vulnerable people in society: children, controlling every aspect of their lives and force-feeding them a nauseating mix of Hinduism, yoga and Christianity. It's a haunting tale how people can never escape the trauma caused by a cult, especially when they have spent their formative years living with a malicious cult leader. Even when they keep on telling themselves they have moved on, to do right by their own children. I cannot wait to see how the story unfolds.
29 out of 39 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
Exhausting 8 chapters
dochito30 July 2023
Warning: Spoilers
Exhausting 8 chapters....everything takes so long...characters do not act rationally....the bads are too bads, the innocents too traumatized to even think straight, so many questions...how Amy managed to get married? Why did she still had a relationship with "Mommy"?

Amy's house so full of glasses, she would never lock doors...she left the baby girl to die....she left the boy while she was under water....she had no brains at all.

Mommy said in the final minutes of the show' "you never knew how to take care of your children", and she was right! Why Amy despised Christine who took her and rised her with love as a daughter? And Joe, poor Joe, always there for her....but why? He lost everything because Amy was a compulsive liar after all.

All that story could had been told in a couple of hour, not eight.
6 out of 17 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
So: Edit to add
Headturner1126 May 2023
Warning: Spoilers
Far. Maybe spoilers.... So you have this kidnapping in the beginning and then you see it's about children of a cult of some sort! So far what we've seen is ridiculous! Why do they die all the children's hair bleach blonde? Like children of the damned but these children don't seem to possess any exquisite qualities and it doesn't really show what this nonsense is all about? And it seems like she's looking for investors but for what?!? They don't show any reasoning for it! Doris Younane is wasted in this ( and she's one of my favorite Aussie actors) ! I'll continue with it since Teressa uses her real accent( she's awful in anything with an American accent) and see where it goes! Editing after watching another episode. So again what do we learn? Nothing! I'm guessing this happened years ago and Amy is Palmer? But why don't they say? Also why is she with that leader Adrien who still loks the same?!? Anyone saying this convoluted mess of a story :"is so great" can you explain it?!?
19 out of 100 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Fascinating Storyline
bmack-9457128 May 2023
Psychological horror movies not usually my cup of tea but this one is really different. The horror of the kidnapping is bad enough, but the level of manipulation that is employed, including the use of drugs, is quite intriguing. There is a lot of inspiring and challenging stuff in there. Difficult to imagine just how children faced with this reality, might react. I really enjoyed the first two episodes. Looking forward to the next. Found the performances of the young children exceptional, especially Sarah (Lily La Torre) whose plight is gripping and horrendous. A parents worst nightmare. 10/10 from me.
49 out of 70 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Immediately Intriguing Pilot Episode
lark9177326 May 2023
I randomly came across this own Hulu. I've always been drawn to the subject of cults. Here we have a unique premised as the leader is a woman. She has bleach blond hair and expect all her "children" to appear in her image.

The opening starts with a kidnapping. We see how the cult tries to indoctrinate her but she's not having it. This causes all sorts of issues. Another thread of the series is a single mother, who after hearing about the kidnapping is terrified for her son, named Bilbo*. It's clear there must be a connection between her and the cult. I look forward to finding out more.

*I love the Bilbo name, which I assume is from "The Hobbit". Miranda Otto from The Lord of the Rings has a major role here adding another Tolkien connection.
34 out of 49 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
A month old fish stinks less than this ... whatever this is
edblogr8 September 2023
It started well, but the first episode seems to be the only episode where even minimal effort was put into it. After that, a group of idiots do the most stupid things for the most imbecile reasons all the while trying to keep serious faces. No one is capable of understanding even the simplest things, like, this is bad, this is good, this is allowed, this is not ....Being so painful to watch, one can only imagine what it was like for the poor actors.

And sure enough, all that nonsense is wrapped and rooted in the latest reaches of bro psychology. Cutting edge bro psychology one might say.

I mean, really? A month old fish stinks less than this ... whatever this is.
3 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
Potentially great series ruined
zureal-7767128 February 2024
There's a lot to appreciate about this series - the scenery, music, art direction, and child actors. However, it's all for naught because of the insane idea to have three different timelines running in each episode. It subtracts incredibly from the pacing, coherence, tension, overall impact, and, sadly, its watchability.

I just could not get through each episode without being bored or confused. Did the director not have the confidence to tell the story linearly? It feels like a cheap way to build intrigue, but it just doesn't work. Should not each timeline have the impetus to be its own story without being intercut with bits from the past? I could almost forgive the two timelines, but when a third one started, I was out.

The story feels grim and hopeless, and it's not really pleasant to watch. Sorry.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Can be tough to watch but should be rated higher than it is.
buzz-music-492448 January 2024
It is obvious where this story has been taken from in recent Aussie history and it throws down a real challenge when bringing it to a streaming series, but in the steady hands of Grace Otto it becomes compelling viewing.

There is a stellar cast involved but it must be said that if this was a standalone movie, Miranda Otto as Adrienne Beaufort, gives an Oscar worthy performance and seems to inhabit her character as it evolves with each episode. Teresa Palmer is exceptional as the now grown Amy and her character embodies all that you would expect from someone who had been raised in such a cult until the age of thirteen and still maintain such an odd connection with its' leader as an adult. Julia Savage as the young Amy is mesmerizing and someone to watch as is Lily LaTrobe playing Asha.

For me, Guy Pearce is not stretched particularly in his role but Kate Mulvany is a powerhouse in her character whilst Anna Lise Phillips and Erroll Shand both reveal the behaviour that is so commonly observed in people caught under the spell of a cult leader.

I was initially hesitant to watch this when it was first advertised as the thought of watching, however potentially fictitious, a variation of what had been revealed on investigative programmes years ago was not all that appealing, but it deals with a subject that we should be made aware of and is exceptional viewing.
4 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Intriguing show!
mrjgordon12 June 2023
The first episode had me within minutes. The 'Mother' is so creepy and Theresa Palmer is perfectly cast (as usual). Also the child actors blew me away! I can't wait to see what happens next.

The fact that it is based on real events is terrifying to me. How could anyone do this to innocent children/their families? I will never understand their motives for doing something so awful. Some people are just absolutely warped.

All in all, this is such an interesting show, and I have never seen anything like it. If you don't give it a chance, you're missing out on a brilliant time.

Streaming on Disney+!
22 out of 37 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Very intriguing and captivating
finlayargyle21 January 2024
Warning: Spoilers
I started watching this series just on a whim, having never read about it. Immediately I was drawn in by the story and the parallels with the true story of The Family cult in Australia.

But I stayed for the absolutely brilliant performance of Miranda Otto. Honestly, by ep 5, I would have joined her cult!

The story is dark at times with themes of child abuse and neglect. But the story, acting and pace is all great. It is a series that keeps you on your toes. The time slips add to the drama of the series and keep the story on a cliff edge at times.

The characters are believable and portrayed by such a strong cast.

I would definitely recommend.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Gripping series
fionahiggins-1895811 March 2024
I found this series to be gripping, intriguing and definitely kept my attention so much so that I binge the whole series on one sitting couldn't stop watching. I'm a massive true crime/cults nerd which made this all the more interesting given that it is losely based on the really Australian Cult 'The Family'.

I thought the series was very well cast.

The story line was well written.

My only issue hence not a 10/10 is the time jumps, they are not dated or anything apart from one time. So at first it takes a while to figure out what is going on, especially at the beginning. If it wasn't for this would have been full marks.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Exceptionally Intriguing
JoshuaMercott27 April 2024
Warning: Spoilers
A secret cult, missing children, and one woman's attempts to connect the dots before it was too late. These and other intriguing elements defined "The Clearing", which was adapted from J. P. Pomare's novel "In The Clearing" (published, 2019).

Set in the 80s (and spanning the 60s-70s), the story was inspired by true events surrounding a cult known simply as The Family, which operated in secret somewhere in Victoria, Australia.

Their life involved dispensing spiritual practices, a touch of drugs on the side, and an unhealthy manipulation of children's innocence. Suffice to say, none of their decisions aligned with morality and had more to do with profit and influence.

One of the main reasons I wanted to watch this mini-series was because it had three artists whose work I've greatly admired over the years.

Teresa Palmer (as Freya Heywood), Miranda Otto (as Adrienne "Maitreya" Beaufort), and Guy Pearce (as Dr. Bryce Latham) were every bit as amazing as I'd expected them to be. They gave their characters a brilliant blend of intensity and empathy that I thoroughly enjoyed.

The younger talents all did great work in "The Clearing". They brought some old-school nostalgia with a touch of sadness, both of which worked wonderfully for this story.

Set in Australia, and defined by a simple yet unpredictable mystery, "The Clearing" contained a good deal of shock-n-awe value, especially around the children who were either abducted or adopted.

No sexual harm was visited upon them, but the kids did experience something...different. As the story progressed, I learned just how different. The plot twists were captivating and made me want to read Pomare's book.

The children were apparently being handpicked based on how less they'd be missed. Strange hair dyeing and oddly casual activities as part of The Kindred added to the mystery value in the story.

The presence of enablers, couples, and trainers made it all seem like a normal kids' camp or school retreat, but it was anything but. The roots of the cult ran deep and included people in high places.

I kept wondering whether the kids were being trafficked in some capacity. But the truth was not as simple or straightforward. This, more than anything else, kept me glued to the screen.

Some of the beliefs being peddled had ties to Indian spirituality and yogic practices. From life being illusory to the potential of soul transcendence, these and other inherently pure ideas were twisted out of context by some of the cultists. Moreover, the LSD connection added to the intrigue.

The drug was not only used as a potent curative during that era of medicine, it was also grossly misused by those who lost themselves to its ravages and those who used the hallucinogen to convince and control others with the promise of consciousness expansion.

Adrienne Beaufort was one such woman. She wrapped herself in charm and deception, lending the character a beautiful yet sinister presence on screen. As her story unravelled, I appreciated Miranda Otto's performance even more than when I'd hit play on episode one.

The plot shifted between the older versions of some of the characters and what precisely happened to them when they were part of The Kindred. Teresa Palmer's Freya, for instance, was Amy who suffered under the cultists' yoke before the police busted the whole operation years down the line.

Then there was Ada Smith who remade her image and became Adrienne "Maitreya" Beaufort, the leader of said cult. Her origin story was especially interesting.

The final episode brought it all together and delivered some unexpected twists. It was an engaging plotline from beginning to end.

Because it's a mini-series, expecting a second season would be wishful thinking. Be that as it may, "The Clearing" put up a noteworthy show, one based on true events.

There was much worth appreciating and deriding about this story. It was a stark reminder of how easily our delusions can drown us, only for us to call it faith as we relinquish the last bubbles of our existence.

"The Clearing" was as much about crimes that escaped justice as it was about a broken family, most of whom lived in denial about just how badly their souls were damaged.

......... Some riveting work by Kate Mulvany (as Tamsin Latham), Anna Lise Phillips (as Hannah Wilczek), and Erroll Shand as (Henrik Wilczek), each of whom amplified the creep factor.

Some of the kids gave compelling performances. Great work Lily LaTorre (as Sara/Asha), Flynn Wandin (as Billy Heywood), Julia Savage as (Amy Beaufort), and Jeremy Blewitt (as Anton Beaufort).

Remarkable performance from Hazem Shammas (as Yusuf Joe Saad), Harry Greenwood (as older Anton Beaufort), Mark Coles Smith (as Wayne Dhurrkay), Miah Madden (as Max Dhurrkay), Xavier Samuel (as Colin Garrison), Ewen Leslie (as Tom Atkins), Anni Finsterer (as Evelyn Smith), Claudia Karvan (as Mariam Herzog), Kristof Kaczmarek (as Ari Herzog), and Jamie Timony as (older Adam).
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed