User Reviews

Outside of Dwight throwing the hat at Gabe and Darryl saying "he hates himself", I didn't laugh at all this episode and kinda reminded me of the banker episode, except that episode made me laugh with old clips even though that episode is just as boring/terrible. There's truly no point for this episode to exist, I would recommend skipping this👍.

I think Gabe actually shines in this episode. I liked seeing the characters out of the usual setting.

The Office is going downhill. I used to follow it religiously, looking forward to 20 minutes of pure comedy in its best form. All the amazing interactions; Michael and Dwight, Dwight and Jim, Michael with the rest of the cast, etc. Ever since Mr Scott left the building, it has been painful to watch, and this episode was a new low. Andy is not Michael. He simply does not get away with all the absurd remarks and situations he gets himself into. Furthermore, the characters are stuck. Jim and Pam used to be fun to follow, but after the wedding and Michael's departure they started getting boring. Dwight is all by himself, and all though he is brilliant, he is being put in a difficult spot without Michael by his side. Andy is being given a pivotal role and it does not do anyone any justice. Robert California was a good addition, but he does not quite feel like what The Office was all about throughout seasons 1 to 7 (when the show was at its prime). Although it hurts to admit it, the show should have ended with Michael's departure.

The idea of attempting to turn Andy Bernard into Michael Scott within the context of The Office Series is, at its core, a misguided and futile endeavor. Andy and Michael are distinct characters, both in terms of their personalities and the roles they play within the show. Such a transformation would not only undermine the authenticity of the characters but also diminish the overall narrative and comedic dynamics of the series.

Firstly, Andy Bernard possesses a unique set of qualities that define his character. From his love for a cappella music to his ambitious and sometimes overconfident nature, Andy brings a particular charm and quirkiness to the series. His journey from a salesperson seeking acceptance to the regional manager showcases his growth and development as an individual. Attempting to morph him into Michael would not only erase these defining characteristics but also strip away the personal growth and story arc that Andy undergoes throughout the show.

Secondly, Michael Scott, portrayed by Steve Carell, is an iconic character in his own right. His well-intentioned yet often cringe-inducing behavior is what makes him memorable. Michael's inappropriate jokes, lack of self-awareness, and desperate desire for approval create a unique comedic dynamic within the series. His interactions with other characters, such as his awkward attempts at bonding with Jim or his misguided leadership style, are integral to the show's humor. Trying to convert Andy into a carbon copy of Michael would eliminate the contrast and comedic tension that arises from their distinct personalities.

Moreover, The Office Series thrives on its ensemble cast and the diverse range of personalities that populate the office environment. Each character brings something unique to the table, contributing to the show's comedic and narrative richness. The interactions and relationships between characters, including Andy and Michael, are built upon their individuality. Forcing a transformation that erases these differences undermines the authenticity and depth of the relationships and dynamics that drive the series.

In essence, the concept of turning Andy Bernard into Michael Scott within the context of The Office Series is not only illogical but also detrimental to the show's essence. The distinctiveness and growth of characters like Andy and Michael are what make the series captivating and enduring. Embracing their individuality and appreciating the nuanced performances of the actors involved is crucial to understanding and enjoying the brilliance of The Office.

I find season 8 bearable and there are some standouts but this episode is truly the worst episode of the entire series.