"Murdoch Mysteries" Murdoch in Toyland (TV Episode 2012) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
3 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
9/10
A race against crime
miles-3310811 November 2016
Warning: Spoilers
This episode starts with a kidnapping, where the criminal abducts a girl, replacing her with a speaking doll. When Detective Murdoch tests the doll's speech, he discovers a message intended for him. This is the first of a series of challenges for Murdoch to solve.

As each puzzle is dealt with, so the successive puzzles become harder, requiring all of Murdoch's ingenuity and even requiring the help of Alexander Graham Bell with his specialist audio equipment. Several innocent victims become caught up in the dastardly scheme, and even when Murdoch catches up with the criminal, there is still one victim whom Murdoch must race to save.

This is a satisfying episode with a series of problems to be solved, and justice seen to be done. There is, however, a twisty tail with more than one matter left outstanding.

Roll on the next episode!
5 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Talking Dolls
wjspears5 November 2020
Warning: Spoilers
It seems like every detective or mystery show has to introduce a serial killer at some point--the clever and devious psychopath who is obsessed with the hero. This villain directly taunts our hero, attempting to prove his superiority to our hero.

Up until the last 10 minutes the villain is always successful in fooling and "stumping" our hero. Then, though, the hero figures out the clues and foils the last and final dastardly deed of the villain. The psychopathic villain though somehow always manages to escape capture-- setting up future "confrontations" the villain and the hero.

I am not particularly fond of the "serial killer" plot, as you can probably tell. But this episode does have some nice touches to it. The talking dolls are genuinely creepy. And the reveal of who the villain is--from a previous episode--is an interesting surprise.

I would agree with the previous reviewer and his specific criticisms over some of the plot elements. My own general criticism with the serial killer plotline, is that, I think, it makes the hero less interesting, while making the villain into a sort of lone omnipotent genius.

I don't care for omnipotent heroes in the shows that I watch. I care even less for omnipotent villains.
3 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Someone is trying to challenge Murdoch's abilities.
ctyankee118 April 2015
This episode is interesting but unbelievable.

Veronica a young girl is kidnapped from her bed and no one knows why. A doll with a recording is left in her bed that leaves a message for Murdoch. He finds her in a hotel by tracking down the person that bought the doll because it is a woman that bought several dolls.

Murdoch fears people will get hurt because of him and he gets nervous. He can't figure out why but in the process he exams the doll that was in Veronica's bed and also a headless doll that Veronica was told to give him in the hotel. He gets the help of Alexander Graham Bell and uses science to change the voice to find out who it is.

Brackenreid suggest Murdoch go to his medical doctor to help him remember the name of the man. This part is really another cult practice and if Murdoch knew what a Catholic would do he would not allow the doctor to hypnotize him which allows another person to gain control of your will. Murdoch remembers the person name of the voice he recognized on the recording.

Dr Ogden goes to visit him because she knows how the circumstances of this case made him feel bad.

At any rate what I find unbelievable is 1. Veronica left in a hotel and does not leave the room to contact her parents even though she is by herself with a headless doll she is to give to Murdoch 2. The recording in the talking dolls are just to far fetched. 3. A man that works in a prison takes the place of a prisoner to be killed because her has a head tumor but he is going to be a father and trades his life for money for his wife. According to the cemetery stone the year was 1899 for a recent burial.

There is more mystery and more suspense. The acting is good the characters are likable in this series but this episode was such a farce.
6 out of 20 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed