Elizabeth's fiancé, Ryan, returns from a military assignment, and they struggle to return to the life they once had which begs the audience to ask themselves, how well do they truly know those they love?
Unrecognizable opens with a doorbell ring, Ryan has finally returned after a year long military assignment. Elizabeth is excited for his return but Ryan does not seem to share the same enthusiasm. They struggle to adjust and finally the next evening at dinner Elizabeth confronts Ryan and admits to not recognizing him. He reveals that he found the letters and accuses Elizabeth of lying to him. They argue and confess their fears to each other before reconciling and as an act of starting new, burn the wedding binder together.