Pictures of Ghosts (2023) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
4 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
Good nostalgic presentation about old cinema and the history of film
chenp-547085 May 2024
Brazilian filmmaker Kleber Mendonça Filho once again strikes with another good joint as this being a documentary, it's concept about the nostalgia of old cinema, especially Brazilian cinema, and from an personal lens, provides a strong sense of realism and nostalgic vibe throughout the setting.

It is a beautiful movie. Using archival footages and modern footage of today's time, the direction and concepts explored were well-explored and provides some unique facts, information, and feels about old cinema and how it resonate with Filho. While not everything worked for me, I found myself continuing to enjoy more works from Filho.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
A Portrait of Recife's Transformations
francisco-lima-cavalcant31 August 2023
"Ghost Portraits" masterfully captures the essence of Recife, delving into the realm of nostalgia and melancholy induced by the inevitable tide of change that the city is going through. Through the lens of an autobiographical perspective, filmmaker Kleber Mendonça Filho becomes a true poet, weaving a tapestry of emotions that resonate deeply. With his skill as a director, Kleber creates a narration about the transformation that cities undergo, leaving behind much history of the past. "Ghost Portraits" is a testament to Kleber's multifaceted artistry, a stunning cinematic achievement that leaves an indelible mark. Beautiful movie.
16 out of 21 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
An outstanding and nostalgic look back at old cinemas
Rodrigo_Amaro13 October 2023
Kleber Mendonça Filho strikes again with another impressive film to his resume that is already perfect with the amazing ones "O Som ao Redor" ("Neighbouring Sounds"), "Aquarius" and "Bacurau". This time, he invests on a documentary about the classic cinema palaces from downtown Recife, showing through a magnificent archive of pictures and clips during their glory days as a scenery of important cultural influence and later on the closure of such spaces becoming either evangelical churches or just empty spaces waiting to get new proprietors.

The documentary is divided in three segments and for a brief moment audiences might feel that they don't fully have a connection with each other, specially the first one where he dwell about the apartment he grew up with his mother where he started to make his first films. They connect with each other pretty well, since it revolves about memories, nostalgia and how our view of the world around us change through the optic of films and the spaces in which they are made and the spaces of which they can be seen. As evidenced by his first two features, he used many locations from his childhood and teenage years to be important parts of the stories he wanted to tell.

The film main chorus comes at the second part and that's where we are most invested because there he remembers the theaters, their importance and the countless films exhibited there and the ones he saw growing before he became a filmmaker. He visited those places not just as a film watcher but also he made several registers through the years, interviewing people who worked there - brief scenes from his very first short "Homem de Projeção" are shown where he interviewed a veteran projectionist talking about his work.

Third act was a curious one and it closes with a small fictional moment that proves many points of everything that was said about those pictures of ghosts of the title (previously it was related with ghost-like imagery he captured on camera, or the unusual and spooky way he found out his film "O Som ao Redor" was being broadcast on regular TV). It revolves on the cinemas that were turned into churches, and I just loved the way he made the comparison of different places that have a certain thing in common which are the rituals, each place has its own and cinemas in a way are a religious experience to viewers, rooted in tradition, dogmas and beliefs.

To any film lover out there "Retratos Fantasmas" is a highly special film that talks to us an intimate way about the importance of film memory and also about the memory of such cinemas since there was a dramatic change in the way we consume films and theaters had died over the decades, specially the street ones and all of what's left were the cinema chains which are quite selective in what they show because they just want to get the business done instead of being a democratic place where there's actually movies for all audiences. Nope, it's mostly blockbusters. To the director, he tells us that the decadence of the old cinemas came because the money left town, that particular region kept losing its businesses. He never mentioned about the flowing of cinema chains, this is all me, and I'm not sure if it actually happened there (it usually does) abut he gives us a glimpse of hope that one old theater still remains there and it's still a hot spot for film buffs.

And all those memories were destined to fade in time...but not all that much because Kléber made sure to register that long period of time where cinema was one of the most special places to go, to escape a little from reality or maybe it find different alternatives to it, to deal with life in a better way. As proven here, it was those places and the films he watched that made him become the great director that he is, a masterful storyteller with many relevant topics to address and great stories to tell. I'm really proud of this film, an excellent proof of what great Brazilian cinema is and can be. 10/10.
6 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
Pésima
figueroafernando19 March 2024
Warning: Spoilers
. ah! How nostalgic, the Boa Viagem Hotel, I am sure there must be hundreds of master's and doctoral projects with that object of anthropological study; DW Deutsche Welle, the BBC, have been doing this type of life story work for decades. "Over time I have learned how time changes places" wow, what a deep script Gosh. All places have history, and everywhere you go, there are legends about the place, if it is very old or has changed too much, the work then moves on from the life story (which I could well have rated as 2, 5 stars) to the Blair Witch project looking for ghosts in buildings?; No, seriously? A ghost for photography with a sweeping effect? Any photo student knows that all you need is a tripod or stable backrest for the camera and you have to slow down the shutter speed, increasing the exposure time to 3 or 5, or 10 seconds on a manual camera, and voila, a presence says the director hahaha and everything that happens through the focal angle will be blurry, oh, a ghost. So, let's add: an ancient or old place + the sayings and legends of the site, the right hemisphere of the relatives (of Maeve and the girls) + the genius of the visual chronicler Mendonça Filho to capture the paranormal of Setúbal and rethink whether to go to a spiritualist center, wow! I seriously don't believe it, that a work like this, so university in its organic incongruity, as if it had no script, so weak in its script and motive if there is any, and so heteroclite in its visual construction (VHS videos, Beta , super8, 35mm, etc). Although the ideas of the film are not at all original, they engage the uncritical mass of the audience from the right hemisphere, that of self-complacency, imagination, morbidity and curiosity, (after all it works with before and after, memory, nostalgia) but Mendonca Filho is so mediocre, he captivates himself with this work that he considers an avant-garde entelechy, he becomes enthralled and falls in love with his work - like narcissu- that it is also endorsed with awards by Cannes and another group of crazy people who try found the "habitus" to which Pierre Bordieu referred, and which imagine that they propose a peculiar and intelligent work but only invent warm water by allowing their alchemist at their festivals, who in reality is just a reporter collecting photos and videos relatives.
0 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed