The Gullspång Miracle (2023) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
3 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
9/10
Miracles and Lies
david_jinkins23 December 2023
Someone is lying. Or maybe everyone is. The Gullspång Miracle, a documentary, begins with an incredible story, and keeps delivering twists and turns, even after the credits start. I give the filmmaker Maria Frederiksson credit for not trying to manipulate the odd-shaped facts which are uncovered to fit a clear narrative. The audience, like Frederiksson, never finds out exactly who is trustworthy and who is hiding something. But everyone cannot be telling us the whole truth.

This is documentary film making at its finest. The cinematography, editing, and especially the score work together to make each twist hit hard. Each person in the film understands the world in their own way, and none of their stories are consistent with all of the facts. Each of them must decide what they believe about the past and who they really are. They must also decide what they tell the others. And what they don't.

In addition to its craft, it is refreshing to watch a film primarily featuring people older than sixty, and mostly women. This may be the only film I have ever seen that fails the reverse Bechdel test. Two men never once speak to each other in the film.

This first-class documentary deserves far more acclaim than it has won already. It is a tragedy it is not yet on wider release, or streaming anywhere. If it is playing near you, don't miss seeing it while you can.
29 out of 32 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Masterful, unbelievable mix of genres
martinpersson9731 October 2023
Warning: Spoilers
This stellar documentary is unlike most you will have seen, by a great director nontheless, whom I actually had the pleasure to meet for the film's premiere.

It is a very far fetched, unbelievable and ever evolving web of twists and turns that is somehow true - and it is all tremendously well put together. The cutting and editing is top notch, to say the least. Despite it being a documentary, it goes far beyond that - and even invokes a sense of being a drama, or a dark comedy, akin to those of, for say, the Cohen brothers.

All around, ever exciting, engaging and very beautifully put together. You definitely have to give this crazy and unbeliavably true documentary a watch. Something like this has perhaps only been done by Herzog in the past.

The Swedish Fargo is a documentary! Highly recommended.
7 out of 14 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
Don't waste your time
teodor-nilson2 April 2024
Pointless story told in an overly dramatic way by a filmmaker who can't handle when their project takes a disappointing turn. It feels like the cast are used as puppets and in the end nothing gets resolved. Don't waste your time watching this. There's no mystery in the filmmaking, only cheap tricks to build some suspense to keep you watching. But it never gets truly interesting because the story lacks substance. It only exists in the head of the main characters and the filmmaker. The problem of this documentary is that it's constructed in a way that emphasises excitement of the story when there is none. Why not slow down and let people interact on their own?
14 out of 23 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed