"Saturday Night Live" Shane Gillis/21 Savage (TV Episode 2024) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
9 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
5/10
If you take off the ideological blinders, another just okay episode.
Solaris00126 February 2024
I came to give a lackluster rating for a lackluster episode of Saturday Night Live, only to find a great number of ratings either 10/10 or 1/10. So clearly another bit of entertainment that has succumbed to the political culture wars. Whatever this episode was, it wasn't the greatest moment in comedy ever, nor the worst. Those extreme ratings are dissociated from reality.

I knew when the host made a point about being fired and that 'you shouldn't google him', that the episode was likely to involve more un-pc insult humor than normal. I don't know who Shane Gillis is, but from how dull the humor was, I'm not likely to bother finding out more. The monologue just wasn't very funny. You can change the targets of the jokes to whoever you want, politically okay or not, but they still aren't very sharp.

As for the episode, as usual, some brief moments were decent. But a lot of filler. What let me down the most was Weekend Update, which felt formulaic, and also suffered from weak random character interviews. I.e., the Truman Capote shtick did nothing for me.

So, for folks who haven't been ideologically blinded to what is actually in front of their eyes, all in all perhaps just slightly lower than the usual SNL quality. Meaning not that great. But hope lives on.
10 out of 36 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Great episode
misfitkaye25 February 2024
Shane's opening monologue was great.

He was himself, didn't hold back and addressed his being fired from SNL with humour and head held high. While jokingly saying to not google him, he clearly knows that people will.

Retuning to host after being fired because people who have no send of humour and can't live life without crapping on things that just aren't for them was a bold move and a testament to what a solid guy he is.

His skits were great, he demonstrated to the cast what they missed out on and could have had on the team.

Despite SNL he has created a lane of his own and been killing it. This was the first time I watched SNL in realtime in years. Shane was the reason I set a reminder, I'm glad that I did.
32 out of 50 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
Unfunny
dsddjfwmn25 February 2024
Shane wasn't only offensive but he was straight up not funny. His jokes are true bottom of the barrel jokes that were unfunny even 10 years ago. This humor might be good enough for teenage boys who idolize Andrew Tate but for the rest of us it needs to be better quality. Reminds me of late 90's South Park. The cast was great though. Maybe they knew they had to be on their game to compensate for such a weak host who only does jokes at the cost of the disabled and minorities. I'm glad NBC fired this guy before he could be on the show because he would have just stank it up with his "comedy". Glad he is going back into his hole at loser mountain.
24 out of 148 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Snl vs shane gillis
cheesetwistie26 February 2024
Felt like snl got him in because they know how popular he is rising and they look silly for firing him before giving him a shot. Yeah may have said something offensive a couple of years ago but at the end of the day who hasn't said or even thought of something offensive before? Get over it! Yes Snl has gone downhill and the reason for that? YOU!

People are so precious today there is only so much they can work around without offending to many people.

As for shane, I'm a huge fan and think his naturally funny.

A bloke who you could have a beer with.

He looked nervous first time. But did great!
16 out of 24 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Much Needed Episode, Even With Controversy
PrawnReviews26 February 2024
Warning: Spoilers
I think it was an incredibly necessary episode for Saturday Night Live.

This may be an early thing to say, but I think it brought a ton more viewers than normal, or to the very least had a lot more people go out of their way to tune in for it. Whether for good or for bad, this will do nothing more than give the show a ton more attention, that's why they bring in people like Dave Chappelle to come on to host as well. I think this will easily have helped the show as a whole.

Whether certain people like it or not, Shane Gillis is undoubtedly one of the most popular comedians in the world right now, and by a good margin. He has comedy that pushes the boundaries more than certain others, and in today's state of the world that also comes with divisiveness on him.

That being said, for those who are a fan of Shane Gillis, expect to potentially have a mixed bag about the episode as well. He has an online sketch comedy show right now, Gilly and Keeves, which has had an intense amount of praise due to that. The main other writer for said show, John McKeever, did not do any help with writing of the sketches as people had anticipated or hoped. However, front to back they were all funny and well written, with some harder hitters than others. The only sketch I did not understand was the cold open about Trump. It was essentially just 4 minutes of cast members saying how the Republican politicians for this election season are a bunch of shills who have been repeatedly disrespected by him but still look around and say they love Trump so much. It just didn't work because of course they are, they're politicians, and it just dragged out long without really feeling like there is a punchline outside of that. That being said, all of the other sketches were very funny, and with Gillis being friends with most of the cast, like Bowen Yang, Michael Che and Marcello Hernandez really showed at times as well.

Now the monologue, that was the main amount of controversy from it all. He is a comedian who likes to toe the line on what's acceptable, just look at his Netflix special alone. If that is not your style of comedy, then you will not like his monologue. That being said, the fact that he fully stuck to his guns on his brand of comedy was remarkable, I do not feel like you should change what makes you famous as a comedian on one of the biggest stages of comedy.

Certainly not a 21 Savage fan, but I believe that he did do a great job performing. I thought his set was great with the ballet dancers in the back and smoke rolling through. Even as a person who is not a fan, I thought he did a great job and made the most of his two songs.

All around, I'm mainly rating it as a 10 due multiple different aspects. First and foremost, to the viewership it received from an audience who are not, quite frankly, all too interested in Saturday Night Live. Secondly, the sketches were very funny and saw no issue with them. His monologue is going to be more of a controversial one, that should be left up to the viewer alone. I believe this was a great choice for Saturday Night Live.
17 out of 27 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
Hard. Pass.
lonnierathie26 February 2024
Warning: Spoilers
Everything about this episode was offensive. The host, the musical guest... so disappointing. Why on earth would they hire such a terrible host? They fired him once for being inappropriate and offensive. Doesn't look like anything has changed. He was boring and trite and just bad. This was one of the worst shows ever. It makes me not want to watch anymore. I find it so weird that they would bring him back as a host after he was fired as a cast menmber for his offensive material on a podcast. 21 Savage was boring. The episode was a 1/10 at best. Also I felt bad for Bowen Yang that he has to appear on screen with Shane.
9 out of 92 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Best of the Season
dmanmotherf25 February 2024
Shane Gillis as a host helped the show get back some of the fire its been missing. The political sketches besides the cold open didn't feel one sided or like the jokes are for people who constantly watch MSNBC. The normal sketches had darker premises and didn't care about being offensive to play that into the joke against the individual. Weekend update was solid as always. 21 Savages performance was okay. The monologue was better than the actors but wasn't the best out of recent comedians. I appreciated it matched his stand up by not steering away from uncomfortable topics to give a different perspective to land a difficult premise in an unoffensive way, I just felt that having a cleaner set didn't help him. This was the most memorable episode I seen in a while. Best of the season.
26 out of 46 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Best episode in a very long time!
mindlessmoviemaster25 February 2024
Warning: Spoilers
Dang that was a great episode from the cold open to the monologue to the rest of the skits this had the old school feel more like 2013ish SNL brought back some good nostalgia feels that the show has been lacking for like 7 years. Some of the more annoying cast members didn't appear in this episode which made the show waaay more enjoyable. So idk what really else to say but they want you to write a novel now days. I wonder if some the guys that have been there a little longer like Mikey Day was happy to work with someone that is actually funny. Lady with the mullet actually was kind of funny in the sex bot skit maybe she is finally coming into her own, unlike Cecily Strong who has never made me laugh once anyways. Good episode. Noticed the bots are moving in and down voting this episode. They don't even have in prior reviews.. bots..
36 out of 70 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Easily The Best Episode This Season
julian-9350829 February 2024
The one thing I've learned after watching this episode is this: Unfunny people like to review-bomb too. This episode is a 10/10. From a great monologue, funny sketches, and hilarious bits that didn't even make it to the show (Limu Emu), Shane Gillis carried this entire series in his first episode since his firing. He made SNL and Michaels & Co. Really regret their decision. This felt like SNL in the 90s. It was funny, it was silly, it was everything you hoped for and looked forward while the weekdays moved closer to Saturday night. Controversies aside, whether they were even valid or not for the punishment, this episode was a win for comedy.
5 out of 17 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed