"Orphan Black" Governed by Sound Reason and True Religion (TV Episode 2014) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
8 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
9/10
This episode moves at a cracking pace with plenty of developments
DVD_Connoisseur2 December 2018
"Governed by Sound Reason and True Religion" must be one of the best titles for an episode of a television series. Brilliant.

And what an episode! The instalment moves at a blistering pace, there are surprises aplenty and more than a few unexpected turns.

Just what when you think you know who you can trust, the rug's pulled from under you. And then replaced. And pulled again.

9 out of 10.
8 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
The plot thickens! Warning: Spoilers
Things get increasingly complicated this episode. It turns out that what I thought was going on at the end of the first season is happening, just not in the way I expected. Mrs. S is not who she appears to be, but she's not a watcher for Dr. Leakie like I thought, either. She's got something very interesting of her own going on. This results in a very violent scene towards the end of the episode.

Meanwhile, the religious group is having its own internal revolution. Cosima is getting a lab. Alison finds out definitively that Donnie is her watcher, but is unable to do anything about it. Overall, very strong episode, although it does make me wonder if we'll ever get any answers.
6 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Each clone goes her own way
SJulien1219 May 2021
Warning: Spoilers
Allison learns that Donnie is indeed her monitor and therefore feels even worse about Aynsley's death. Cosima settles in her new laboratory and meets Rachel who will probably not become a friend. At least Art is on Sarah's side, but it's Angela who is starting to get on our nerves. Kira's kidnapping takes a strange turn when Sarah learns that it is Ms. S. who did it and everything ends badly at the house they were. Helena seems unable to escape from the Proletheans and Alison is left by her confidant who finally leaves with Sarah and Kira. In short, the different storylines of the season are set up in this episode.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
We take a look inside the Prolethian operation, as well as learn about the whereabouts of Kira.
Amari-Sali3 May 2014
Warning: Spoilers
As Orphan Black continues to slow feed the complexity of their universe, naturally each episodes leads to more questions than answers. What is project Lyda? Is Rachel truly a villain, or perhaps misunderstood? What will come of Art's investigation into the clones? And a slew of other questions are all presented as the show attempts to provide us with some answers.

Topic 1: The lives of Cosima and Allison

After Sara's break in, Dr. Leekie is naturally a bit cautious and worried about Cosima's involvement. But, being that the clones rarely keep each other completely in the loop on things, Cosima claims innocence. However, Sara's demands about Cosima getting her own lab, last episode, are heard, and seemingly provided. Albeit in an out dated lab, but with an apparent budget which may hold no bounds, and Delphine to help, Cosima can likely get all the things she can want.

One thing perhaps she didn't consider was a visit from sister Rachel. Now, despite Cosima's shade about Rachel getting her butt kicked, they have a calm conversation. Part of it deals with Cosima's health issues, especially considering Katja's. But, another part deals with the subject of Sara being able to birth a child. Something both Rachel and the Prolethians seem interested in. And while, naturally, the Dyad Institute are probably interested in it for their research, a part of me wonders if Rachel, despite this hard exterior, may wonder why Sara could have a baby because she wants one? Though maybe this is just my hope that Rachel is more interesting than she seems.

Especially since Rachel's story, even as the head of the Dyad Institute, is sort of boring to me. But, while Cosima and Rachel try to find a mutually beneficial relationship, Allison seems to be drowning. With Aynsley's funeral comes a bit of guilt, especially upon learning Donnie is her monitor. And while she has a new friend, in the very friendly Sara of the play, she seemingly needs a real friend, and that person is Felix.

Problem is, as much as Felix loves the odd suburban appeal of Allison, his loyalties lie with Sara first and foremost. And while watching Allison freak out, with Felix unable to help her, you do have to find it a bit sad that after the reveal their lives have become so lonesome. Cosima now only has Delphine, who is a double agent who I still remain unconvinced of her loyalty; Allison lost all her friends due to having sex with Aynsley's husband, and now all she has is Felix and the other Sara who she doesn't seem exactly the most fond of; and Rachel seems like she is just a functional version of Helena, though without combat training.

Topic 2: The Prolethians - Helena

Speaking of Helena, in this episode we learn much more about the organization which has raised her since she was 12. Bringing to question whether she was kidnapped from her original home in a convent, or if the convent was already ran by Prolethians? Either way, they take her from the hospital, before Angie can investigate her and dip her nose into clone business, and for a good part of the episode we learn quite a bit about the Prolethian cult.

For one, they seem split between being modernized, and being fanatics as Tomas' sect. Pastor Henry and Mark, as well as other members, present a side to the Prolethians which is a bit more forward thinking. One which embraces the religious side of the past, but also the technology of the future. But, while they do seem a bit more forward thinking, and kinder, than Tomas, they are still a bit screwed up. After all, Mark, the guy who chased Sara in the diner in the last episode, was part of a duo which had no problem killing the cook. Plus, being as cult-ish as they seem, you know that just them killing Tomas in cold blood isn't likely the only thing they have ever done which could give a person pause. But, with Helena in their possession, and an interest, like the Dyad Institute, on whether Sara maybe the only one who can have children. There is an idea of seeing if Helena can reproduce.

Topic 3: End Goal - Sara

Leaving us with Sara who, with the help of Art, is trying to find Kira. Thing is, despite Art being a decent detective, somehow he loses Sara, while investigating a motel and being distracted by Daniel, and Sara gets kidnapped. Luckily for her though, it is just Benjamin of the Bird Watchers, an organization Mrs. S worked with before to help hide Sara during her younger years, and thankfully Kira is with them.

Thing is, after Amelia's warning about Mrs. S, and talk of Project Lyda, Sara isn't fully sure if Mrs. S is on her side, a monitor, or what? It doesn't get better though as Mrs. S talks about taking Kira with her to London without Sara, setting off all types of alarms in Sara's head. But, being that seemingly Mrs. S doesn't know Sara like you'd think she would, Sara finds a way to get away from Mrs. S and the Bird Watchers, and good thing too. You see, we learn that after decades of being on the side of justice, the Bird Watchers seemingly now are under the Prolethians in order to get some money in their pockets. Something which upsets the trigger happy Mrs. S, who may have let Sara leave, but the two Bird watchers we meet, Brenda and Barry, get shot down.

The episode ends with Sara, Felix, and Kira with a truck and off to somewhere. However, with so much going on, will they be able to truly escape? Much less, can Sara really abandon the rest of the clones and leave all that drama behind?
5 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
So far, the police loosing yards
cjonesas27 July 2021
An episode with plenty of muscle action-wise. Each clone does her own gymnastics saltos with viewers watching mindlessly and heart-numbingly. A mishmash where the cops take to hardest blows.
1 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Escaped!?
ZegMaarJus28 July 2021
Warning: Spoilers
This episode begins with Helena, she lays in a bed in the hospital. Art arrested Daniel. Sarah got ubducted by Ben, Siobhan arranged this. Alison tells to Felix that she killed Aynsley. Sarah got reunited with Kira. Helena got ubducted by Mark, he took her back to Tomas. Alison caught Donnie while he followed her. Sarah and Kira try to escape out of Siobhan's place. Barry got shot down by Siobhan, he died afterwards. Alison discovered that Donnie is her Monitor. Mark shot a bullet trough Tomas his head, he died instantly. Solid Episode of Orphan Black 2, i don't like this Season so far. Not much action and a weird storyline.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Some gaffes I noticed
rick-casady17 April 2022
Dr. Leekie refers to DYAD originating in 1918 "when the keystone was set". I believe he meant "cornerstone". He later gives a tour to Cosima and mentions how his company created a "vaccine for Spanish influenza." No vaccine was ever developed for Spanish flu. In another scene, Rachel asks Paul about his experience with Taiwan and Mandarin Chinese. So far as I know, the Taiwanese don't speak Mandarin, generally. Otherwise, an enjoyable and illuminating episode, and the musical rehearsals were hilarious.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Flipping a switch
kingsx_646 February 2020
"Oh my God Oh my God I can't go to jail, I have two children" Aynsley had children also. But that didn't seem to matter to you when you watched her die, painfully. Actually, you smiled after it happened. Am I supposed to be ok with this? Am I the viewer, supposed to think it's ok because Aynsley was nosey? Am I supposed to route for Alison because the writers assume I'm supposed to? Or the fans still will? And now, only one episode later they want me to feel sympathy for Alison? Sure, cause flipping a switch to save your friends life is out of the question as long as your mad at them. Seems logical
3 out of 14 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed