Not With My Daughter (TV Movie 2014) Poster

(2014 TV Movie)

User Reviews

Review this title
5 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
4/10
Another poor movie with little qualities underneath
Rodrigo_Amaro7 October 2015
Body count: 2. One was the victim killed in the movie; the other one was me while was watching this thing. OK, that's not fair, I actually managed to survive this attempt of movie, it's quite excusable. But one more step of absurdity and I might as well be dead from watching it. This is lame TV movie at its clunkiest and I was only watching it because...of reasons unknown, guess you can say I'm fan of someone who has a role in it.

In terms of idea borough to the table it does not sound all that ridiculous: tired of defending guilty rich clients who always get away with murder because her defense is the best ever, attorney Melissa Eco (Ally Sheedy) decides to take her time and invest with poor innocent clients who never stand a chance in court. Pro-bono work, obviously, love it when those happen in the movies. Her big chance comes with Greg (Rhys Ward), a young man who is accused of a girl's murder along with his buddy (Erik Knudsen). Greg has it all: he's poor, lived under awful circumstances and to make things even better for the attorney, he's incredibly good-looking, a great image to sell to the jury. But the movie breaks all the suspense by presenting the guy doing the crime, so it's never really a plot twist - only to Melissa - when the angel turns out to be a devil and starts blackmailing his own lawyer. Whoa, you must think. Why? In what world this would benefit him? Well, when the lawyer's daughter is a rebellious teen that resents her mom for all the past wrong-doings and fate or poor writer's decisions but somehow that girl will meet this guy, whose plan is to claim innocence until the end and frame his friend for the crime. I guess you get the general picture from here.

Why "Client Seduction" fails? Not just because it's a passable film that doesn't create anything so brilliant. Above all, it's pure sloppy screen writing creating one cringe-worthy scene after another, everything is so hard to believe. My "favorite" unbelievable moments involve the mom's reaction whenever her daughter talks back at her. I know we live in some politically correct times but for the life of me, I just couldn't understand how come she never slapped that ungrateful girl. Not once. All she does is cry and cry, twist her face in a painful manner. Sure, some countries there's laws preventing parents of doing what I proposed but c'mon, that girl needed a wake up call instead of acting rebellious for nothing. She was right in judging the mom for what she did before while defending rich abusers, but the way she conflicts it's just wrong.

If the screenplay can afford to be garbage, then there's nothing in the world that can't prevent the actors of doing more wrong...but they do! One disastrous acting after another, it's a weird assembling of actors put together (Sheedy is just cry and scream while Ward doesn't scare with the bad boy vibe cause he's too pleasing for the eyes). But wait, there's one decent performance in the whole movie and it's the real reason why it wasn't so difficult to watch this thing. Kudos to Erik Knudsen. You know, Crash and the Boys in "Scott Pilgrim". I mean, I won't say he stole the show because there wasn't any show to be stolen from anyone here but his tormented, troubled and almost innocent character was engaging in every possible way. It's the only character in the movie that deserves some support from the audience. He was really good. He might be the reason why I'm not so critical of this thing. 4/10
1 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
For Vegetarians only.... because it is sooooooo CORNY!
Ed-Shullivan11 May 2018
I shouldn't have expected much from this film after realizing that the director Penelope Buitenhuis body of work has been concentrated mainly on Lifetime TV movies and TV series. When a film company like Lifetime continually uses the same director there is a reason for it and that reason is that their chosen director Penelope Buitenhuis, can churn out one TV movie after another as I seemingly chew on one corn on the cob after another and they all look, smell and taste exactly the same.

There are a few scenes that take place between former Brat Pack star Ally Sheedy who plays a high class lawyer and a single mom named Melissa Eco and her daughter Abby played by Annie Clark who are in the middle of some heated conversations at home that the sound recording is similar to the effect of the echo that you frequently hear on daytime soap operas.

Don't waste your time. Boiling a cob of corn takes only two minutes and it tastes a lot better than this corny soap opera film made for a bored TV audience.
6 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
bad characterization
SnoopyStyle16 July 2019
High-profile defense attorney Melissa Eco (Ally Sheedy) wants to change her image after her rich client gets away with rape. Her rebellious teen daughter Abby (Annie Clark) does not approve. Melissa takes on the case for homeless Greg Milles (Rhys Ward). He's accused of killing a girl during a home robbery. He blames the killing on his drug addicted partner Dennis Brunner (Erik Knudsen). As Melissa's investigating raises more questions, she finds Abby has fallen in with Greg's gang.

Ally Sheedy plays it way too innocent in the beginning. She's a harden lawyer and she shouldn't be so easily convinced by the guy. Rhys Ward looks way too guilty which adds to the unreality of Melissa's belief in her client. Erik Knudsen would work much better in that role. Everybody is so sketchy that it's unbelievable that Melissa doesn't notice. This needs to be a mystery where the audience gets shocked by Greg's guilt. Instead, none of this is realistic especially Melissa. An experienced defense lawyer wouldn't be like that unless she's the type who only defends the innocent which she is not. It's a lot of disbelief.
4 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Yep, With Your Daughter...
P3n-E-W1s330 December 2016
This was not as bad as I thought it was going to be, after reading the review. If it didn't have Ally Sheedy's name on it then I would've given it a miss. I'm glad I didn't.

As with ALL movies, there are good and bad points; in this movie, the good outweigh the bad.

On the whole, the acting was pretty good. I thought Ally Sheedy did a passable job in the lead role. The scene where she argues with her daughter and breaks down crying, while the teenage Abby (portrayed by Annie Clark) just stares at her with disdain was grating, as Sheedy does get a little bit high pitched. However, I liked the fact that Sheedy's character, Melissa, is a blowhard in court but is not so strong in other situations. This makes for a more realistic development through the film.

It was also nice to see Erik Knudsen as a strung out druggie accused of murder. I first saw him in Jericho and thought he would be a talent to watch for.

There are times when the writing and direction slips but generally both are sound. I did see the twists coming, but after reading and watching so many thrillers, I'd be upset if I didn't.

This is worth a watch if you see it on telly, though I wouldn't recommend spending any money on it.
0 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
A Charity Case? Or, a Career Move?
lavatch21 September 2020
Warning: Spoilers
Was the intent of hotshot attorney Melissa Eco a charity case for the poor waif Greg Milles? Or, was Ms. Eco using his downtrodden image to advance her high-profile pedigree in the legal community of Cleveland?

The previous question is at the heart of "Not With My Daughter" (a.k.a., "Client Seduction"). Greg Milles is a smooth-talking operator who has learned to play the "system." A career criminal and murderer, Greg is skillful at assigning blame to others and failing to take responsibility for the life choices that disenfranchised him from society.

A major conflict arises when Ms. Eco's young daughter Abigail (Abby) becomes the sweetheart of her client Greg. While he is under house arrest, Abby pays visits to the house where Greg is staying with his "aunt" Lynette. The character of Lynette was the strangest in the film. It was suggestive that Lynette was much more than an auntie to the rascal Greg.

While the filmmakers attempted to develop tension in the mother-daughter relationship, it never seemed credible that Abby would be such a brat and so inconsiderate of her mom. Another relationship that seemed a stretch was that of Ms. Eco and Greg's dope-sick friend Dennis, who was sitting in prison after being framed by Greg. The frequent visits and conversations between Ms. Eco and Dennis would have all been highly unethical from the legal standpoint.

The environments devised by the filmmakers were at least successful in evoking the tawdry world of Greg and his cohorts. First, there was the disgusting, needle-infested warehouse where Greg did his art works under the pseudonym of Valentine. A starry-eyed Abby at first compares him to the English street artist Banksy. But nothing can compare to the lower depths of Aunt Lynette's hovel, a smelly and sordid world where Ms. Echo and her nasty teenager of a daughter seem out of place in their fashionable designer clothes.

By the end, young Abby has had more than her fill of the young rebel, especially when she realizes that Greg sketched the face of Brittany Hollingworth, whom he likely murdered after a joy ride. Abby now eagerly returns to the warm embrace of her mother. The final close-up of Ms. Eco and Abby in which they are relaxing in the courtroom together during Dennis's murder trial certainly underscored the deep ties of a mother and her daughter.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed