Oliver's team is divided how to handle a lost letter written by Melissa on what proved her hospital death bed to husband Michael Wheeler, the assistant district attorney and aspiring politician, who left her after finding out his blood type proves he can't be 'their' daughter Abby's father's. The letter claims she had been raped and scared into silence just before their wedding. Michael has never remarried and raised Abby alone, she now helps run his political campaign. The alleged father is serving a life sentence for another rape, and is the only possible kidney donor to save Abby's life. Valerie Bertinelli continues her role as Rebecca Starkwell, from the USPS in Washington, D.C. and a good friend of Shane's.
—KGF Vissers