User Reviews

Must be the season for watching Charisma Carpenter as this is the second film of hers I have seen on UK's Channel 5. The other being Obsession. Any ways did n't set out to watch this and I guess I persevered with it. Patrick Muldoon the accountant, arrives to sort out a farm whose owners have come into debt via poor financial management. Romance develops between our accountant and Charisma one of the farm owners. Obviously there are some baddies involved, who want a horse called Holly for some reason. The film goes along so-so. For once I thought the child acting was actually pretty good, not cringable which I find in US dramas. The acting I thought with all the major characters I found pretty good, I thought it was the writing or maybe direction which let it down in some way. At times I thought Muldoon/Carpenter/Swain were rescuing it. Well the film ended with a tiny surprise in one way. I could n't see me watching it again. It is a family film I guess and I suppose if I had children would watch it with them, but could nt see them rush to watch it again either.

This film is called A Christmas Promise in UK and a Horse Tail in US. Think perhaps Holly's Christmas Tail might have been better.

PS, Charisma Carpenter definitely needs to be on TV more.

I have to admit the reason I watched this little film was for Charisma Carpenter - I've been a fan since she was in Buffy and especially when her character was allowed to grow in Angel. I thought that we may have seen more of her than we have. So every time I see she's in a movie I give a look see... and I wasn't disappointed here.

It's Christmastime and the stables are suffering. Less and less people are coming for riding lessons and the ones that do who are too poor to pay get them free. The riders who stable their horses are being tempted away. Things are looking bleak, so they bring in an accountant to try and help them out of the hole, which has started to grow after the death of the mother and wife. Enter Michael (Muldoon) and his troubled daughter Chloe (Carlson). Michael is the accountant come to help the family out, however, he is soon butting heads with Samantha (Carpenter) who is a strong single minded woman who has stepped in to run the stables while her father gets better after his fall.

Though you know where the relationship is going it's nice to have a little friction between them to spice up the story and add conflicts. This romance is on bumpy ground right from the start... and that is a nice thing as it's more realistic.

One thing that lets the story down is the ending; I really do dislike coincidental happenings that make everything okay - this is not too realistic or believable. As for the acting, Samantha is supposed to be hard-nosed though I thought she wasn't powerful enough in getting her messages across, she was meant to be a fearsome woman but it just didn't quite come across right. As for Muldoon, I've never been too much of a fan of his. For me he's a little two dimensional at times, which weakens the characters he's portraying. The strongest actors and actresses in the cast are Carlson who plays Chloe, Lewison who plays Jackson, Swain who plays Sydney, and though he's not on screen that often, Tilk who plays Ben. It's because they portray the family so well that it adds to the strength and enjoyability of the film.

This is worth a watch, though it may be a few years before I look at it again... if at all.

This is a good family movie that promotes working together as a family. It also speaks to accepting help to save what is most important. The film also shows how hard it is sometimes to let our children grow up without being too over-protective. Fun for all ages. James Welch Henderson, Arkansas 1/15/2021

Eleven years after Angel and sixteen years after Buffy: The Vampire Slayer, Charisma Carpenter continues to be actively involved in movies and in A Horse Tale, as lead star, she finds herself in this Christmas holiday romance movie that while very typical of all the mass produced, holiday-hyped movies, this one is a bit different and refreshing for a change. It's not that its really a dramatic, independent movie, not by a long shot, but the scriptwriter, Lori Twichell, in her apparently only screenplay, has developed a plot and dialogue that refuses to fall into the stereotypical, mundane performances that copy each other year after year. While the overall plot flows like the rest of the holiday film turnout, the dialogue and acting never quite fits the same mold of those other movies. The drama is muted just a bit so that the story actually reflects much more genuine if not overly dramatic outcomes but instead reveals thoughtful and more resonating emotional substance. By doing so, this movie provides the audience a more realistic and observant point of view that is even more captivating for its willingness to provide a more authentic, naturalistic look into real relationships and conflicts. Except for the more typical black and white evil bankers like have been portrayed since It's A Wonderful Life (1946), all the characters do well by the script. And the script and plot also take time to reveal a bit more reflection and plot development even towards the end, when it would have much easier and cheaper to just end production, save some money, and go home with fewer traditional ending sequences. It appears that Charisma Carpenter is very comfortable in her career and her performances, who seemingly has not aged (maybe having hung around Angel, the vampire too long) developing her own persona on screen and working well together with the staple of the Christmas male star of many holiday movies, Patrick Muldoon, who is among the most prolific of holiday stars. Somehow he continues to portray the same character over and over again in all these movies without actually coming off boring or mundane being seen again and again and again. He's kind of like the male Christmas character version of Kevin Costner's action, adventure male character that we have seen again and again in many of his movies. Together, Carpenter and Muldoon are given a solid refreshing script along with possibly some discretion to improvise some of their scenes to make an enjoyable, if not classic, holiday movie experience. Finally, there is a fascinating use of roughly two different photographic, camera presentations in this movie, one the polished, expensive film technique and the second, hand-held video camera with its more jerky, raw authentic look which is somewhat rare to see in movies. A well-deserved seven out of ten, not more but only because this movie remains confined in its rigid holiday movie formula and doesn't break dramatically outside of the box with daring, risky, startlingly original, ground-breaking theater. However, A Horse Tale could likely be an

Known as 'A Christmas Promise' in the UK. Pretty average plot and storyline, but OK although predictable outcome.

Pretty horses and cute kids, the family loved it! Would watch this one again!