Jessie goes to a Central Park Masquerade Ball and she meets a mystery man who has a strong desire to win her heart. Emma, Zuri, Luke, and Ravi reluctantly take Stuart out trick-or-treating. Jessie soon discovers the mysterious disappearances that have occurred, after Stuart has told them a story regarding a unusual girl named Abigail. Stuart soon comes clean about the prank and he reveals that he invited everyone to a Halloween party. Jessie goes back to the Masquerade Ball to meet her mystery man, she soon discovers her mystery man is Tony and he finally admits his feelings to Jessie again. Tony and Jessie finally get back together. Meanwhile, Bertram tries to figure out who's been stealing all of the Halloween candy.
—dawsonpersi