The Comet Kids (2017) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
4 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
6/10
While enticing, it misses something.
onemosley18 November 2018
Warning: Spoilers
The Comet Kids is a film set in both our present day as well as the 1950s.

It's in the mid 1950s that a boy, after this father's death embarks on a journey along with his friends to find his father's discovered comet that way he could avenge the death of his father.

Along the way there's of course figured to be bad men, one of which the former colleague of the boy's father, whom tried crediting the comet to himself.

In the end, the movie does definitely work. It makes you feel good when it wants to and it makes you feel sad when it wants to. However, something for me personally in the end didn't seem right to me.

Whether or not it was the storyline itself or me as a viewer I'm not sure. However, I am sure they if you have found this film and have not yet watched it, please do yourself a favor and do so. At the end of the film you'll either street with me or you'll like the movie even more. There really isn't a whole lot to hate about this movie, honestly it's just the way I had watched the movie and the at my own mind works that made me feel as if there could have been better, more exciting ways to have ended the movie. However the film ends very realistically and all's well that ends well.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Run-of-the-mill, teens can accomplish things better on their own.
Bernie444427 February 2024
The story as a flashback told to us by grandpa Lucas. Lucas's father discovers a comet. His father's friend usurps the privilege of the find. Now Lucas and five of his friends must recover a meteor from the comet to vindicate his father.

This will involve an arduous trip in an attempt to get to the meteorite before the bad guys.

The actual comet used in the film is Comet-Haile-Bopp-29-03-1997 Image by Philipp Salzgeber

"The Comet Kids" (2017) filmed in Australia, uses the standard hero's journey formula laid out by Joseph Campbell. As the kids physically move from one location to another they are mentally moving through time and resolving outstanding problems as they mature and, in the process, acquire hero status.

Nothing is outstanding in this film to make it unique from any other hero's journey. However, you can have fun watching it unfold with a little kibitzing on the side.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
Recommended if you want to know how not to make a film!
chrish-1819810 April 2018
Warning: Spoilers
If you like picking apart movie flaws, this one will require a notebook - and diligence to sit thru.

We spent more time picking out faults in this film than we took watching it!

From the start, when it's clear the costume budget ran out before they got to the main characters (eg boy with long hair and wearing camo shirt in 1956 or another wearing a bright yellow tie and untucked shirt in 1956); to not employing someone who knew how to use a calculator (set in 1956 and the "present day" but 74 years apart... so 2030? and the 40yo daughter whose mother would therefore have been 50ish when pregnant) to a slow-mo stare off when the villain and protagonist meet; to the villain standing there and waiting to be punched; to numerous scenes that do little to advance the story; to the 16yo kids regularly saying "But we're just kids, they're adults, we can't beat them" - what movie of this genre ever has kids regularly thinking that way??; to the villain single handedly beating off an attacker in one scene, and then simply running off terrified when the same attacker returns later - despite now having his henchman at his side to help, and this at the moment he is about to reach the goal he'd give anything to achieve and was his life's quest.

And then there's the whole point of the movie - to find a piece of meteorite from a comet that will somehow prove who discovered the comet... yet it's never explained how that correlates as proof. That is, how can finding a piece of meteorite off a comet prove who discovered the comet??

This was the worst made film I've ever watched. It's a film that feels like someone with little experience in scriptwriting, editing or film construction refused to take any input or advice.

That said, the acting was mostly quite good and the overall plot idea is good too.
4 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Engaging children's adventure romp
Woodyanders12 April 2022
Warning: Spoilers
1950's Australia. Young Lucas (likeable Xavier West) and his friends go on a search to find a piece of comet that Lucas's deceased astronomer dad discovered, but no-count assistant Cliff (a solid performance by Marty Rhone) wants to take credit for instead.

Director/co-writer Glenn Triggs relates the enjoyable story at a steady pace, makes good use of beautiful Aussie outback locations, and maintains a sweet amiable tone throughout. Moreover, the kids are an affable bunch: Juliette Salom as radiant redhead Claudia, Paris Hay as the spunky Inertia, Liam Pope as rough'n'tumble behemoth Gunsworthy Bazooka Jackson, and Harrison Bradley as nerdy magician Tricks. Special kudos are also in order for Hamish as adorable doggy Archie. A nice little film.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed