"Humans" Episode 8 (TV Episode 2015) Poster

(TV Series)

(2015)

User Reviews

Review this title
5 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
Season One
zkonedog3 July 2019
In today's world of ever-charging technology, a show like "Humans" can serve as an interesting treatise on the ultimate endgame of such technology. Though "Humans" doesn't stray too far from the "careful so that the machines don't take over the humans" theme, it is able to put such a human touch on things that you won't even realize how simple the themes actually are.

For a basic plot summary (minor spoilers), the show is split up into a number of plot angles (at least at first)...

-There's the Hawkins family, consisting of Mom (Katherine Parkinson), Dad (Tom Goodman-Hill), and siblings Mattie (Lucy Carless), Toby (Theo Stevenson), & little Sophie (Pixie Davies). They have just made the decision to buy a Synth, or a mechanical marvel that can interact with humans like nothing before. Anita (Gemma Chan), as they name her, begins to display troubling characteristics that a Synth is not supposed to possess. -Niska (Emily Berrington) is another Synth. Instead of the homemaker status of the above family, Niska is in the sex trade, prostituting her mechanical body for a price. Again, though, there seems to be more behind her eyes than just gears turning. -Leo (Colin Morgan) and Synth Max (Ivanno Jeremiah), a team looking to meet up with both Anita and Niska, hinting that there is indeed something special going on with them conscience-wise. -Dr. George Millican (William Hurt) is having trouble parting with his loyal mechanical buddy, beginning a process that will draw him into the center of a plot involving synths. -Investigators Drummond (Neil Maskell) & Voss (Ruth Bradley) are heading a new task force that involves sniffing around the scenes of strange Synth activities, of which there seems to be plenty happening. -Finally, there is Hobb (Danny Webb), a private investigator who just seems to be putting all these strange Synth-related goings-on into some kind of a context.

The primary reason that "Humans" works as well as it does is because it tells so many different stories all related to the Synths (at least in the early goings). Each story on its own could not have carried the entire torch of this show, but altogether they manage to come at the relevant material from a number of interesting angles. It's science fiction in its purest form, with just enough of a human touch to give it some real emotional depth.

One word of warning: This show aired on AMC, but it is a joint production with a British company. If you are not used to listening to British accents, it may take you a bit to adapt. If that kind of thing bothers you or you have trouble hearing, you may want to watch on a device that enables subtitles. It isn't horrible, just not something I was used to.

The only reason I can't give this the full five-star compliment? I felt like the endgame was set up more to precipitate further episodes than it was to produce a great ending to this current season. I'm a little worried that this seems like a show that was begging to be an "event series", and continuing will be a shaky proposition. I liken it to a show aired in the recent past called "Extant", which had an intriguing first season but immediately became procedural and rote in it's second go-round. Fortunately, "Humans" was better than "Extant" to begin with, and the fact that it airs on cable gives me at least a bit more hope.

Overall, I very much enjoyed watching this show. Despite a glut of shows currently airing that feature technology all over the place, there is surprisingly very little of what I would call "true science fiction" (almost completely idea-based storytelling) in those shows. It was refreshing to see "Humans" take a more traditional approach to the genre, as I'm always looking for new and intriguing ways to ingest a story.
3 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
S1: Solid, with some good aspects, but not more than this
bob the moo6 March 2016
This show passed me by initially; I knew it was on and had heard some positive things, but generally nobody was talking about it and there was nobody breathlessly saying "you gotta watch this" in the way often happens with other shows (rightly and wrongly). However the basic sci-fi plot offers familiar and hopefully fertile ground and the success of the show in ratings and in other regions made me decide to catchup on it. The plot sees a near future where robotics have advanced to the point where robots are not only common in the household, but are also convincingly humanoid in their look and basic actions. We join a family stretched by the demands of life, who decided to buy a synth; although unbeknownst to them, Anita is part of a group of synths who had somehow been programmed as conscious beings, not disposable robots. While the family process their new houseguest, the rest of the group, and other forces, are also looking for her.

In some ways the narrative is overly familiar, with the idea of AI becoming conscious and posing a threat of some form to the idea of humanity – indeed this very familiar plot is probably what hurts the show the most, because we really do know where all this goes. As such the show relies heavily on the detail to make it work, and it doesn't. There are a lot of moving parts here, with different characters, groups, motivations, and events; all of them are solidly interesting but no one part really grips – and nor does the drama as a whole. There are interesting elements here and there (the impact on a teenager of a world where skills can be manufactured, the use of a synth as a sex toy, the devaluing of human endeavors by this particular human endeavor etc) however none of them really snap into place or are done better than the many other places you'll have seen them. It is slow paced too, and doesn't really justify it, and the conclusion is in step with the majority of the season by being a bit wishy-washy and unsatisfying.

The cast are solid throughout, and contains a lot of well-known faces doing decent work, but ultimately the material is not there to the point where they consistently get to do great stuff. As a whole it is a solid season of television, with some good ideas and threads; however mostly it is never more than 'solid' and doesn't shake off the feeling that we have seen a lot of this before, often better, and that Humans doesn't add a huge amount to it. The final episode credits had the legend 'Humans will return', and I guess it had to tell us this because otherwise I would not have seen any other reason to think it would.
8 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
weak ending to an otherwise breakthrough series
A_Different_Drummer9 September 2015
Warning: Spoilers
It happens even with the best of production companies.

Sometimes, strange as it sounds, even the writers themselves don't understand what they have created, and take a serious wrong turn while developing the story.

This is a case in point.

My prior comments on this series were (to recap) that HUMANS had succeeded where America's POI has failed -- it had cut to the bone of the AI issue while remaining totally entertaining.

The human brain -- my brain -- can only hold so much data. Nonetheless I believe that I will retain the memory of the early episodes of this series -- the ones where Parkinson's character is playing cat-and-mouse with Chan's character, believing something is odd -- for a very long time.

I cannot make the same claim about the finale. Ugh. With the single exception of a very sweet resolution for Ruth Bradley's character (acting so subtle you could under-appreciate her contribution to the story as a whole) this episode suffers from every known dramatic problem -- weak writing, implausible events; pregnant and awkward pauses; loss of viewer interest; characters acting out of character; etc.

As I said before: ugh.

Overall series considerably above average, especially the early episodes. For that reason alone, highly recommended.
9 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Implausible plot holes
Jim-Eadon13 August 2015
Warning: Spoilers
Humans was intriguing for a while but then I stopped caring much about it at around episode 4, but it's a fascinating failure. I was happy to suspend disbelief of the premise - sentient robots and the clichéd green-on-black screens showing source code (which didn't look like real source code): a weird conflation of 1988 with 2050 tech! I don't mind that clunky stuff as it's Sci Fi for the average Joe. Much more awkwardly, I didn't buy the motivations of the family wanting to keep a creepy, disobedient and dangerous robot in their house. One rationale was that it "saved" the lad's life, but it was only because of the robot that the kid's life was in put in danger. Another motivation was that the mother suddenly wants to keep this scary thing around to find out the mystery about it. I absolutely did not buy that. The mother would, in reality, be absolutely freaked out and would never let this extremely creepy droid tender her kids. Especially as she figured out it had taken her toddler out at night. And screwed her other half... And, of course, they knew that dangerous people would come after the droid. Get rid of it, and fast! There were several chapters where characters were trusting one another when in reality they would be insane to. There was no chemistry between the parents or between the kids and the parents. There was also no chemistry between the family and the droid. I didn't feel any tension, even after the hubby had bonked the bot! Nor did I sense any bonds of love, possibly due to mis-casting. Perhaps the producers sensed this, because they had people/robots constantly explaining the characters' supposed motivations to us. That was annoying, we're smart enough to know that the Missus is upset about things like Hubby bonking the bot without having it orally explained to us. Oddly enough, the relationship between the Detectives was really sweet and touching and one of them was an android (albeit a sensitive, compassionate, smart android). And the irony that a robot-specialist Detective couldn't detect that his colleague and later lover was a robot was fun but obviously implausible. And could a young robot really get into the police force as a detective when a dumb NHS bot could spot them as non-human immediately? But OK, that's a premise needed for the plot. If the actors playing the detectives had played the husband / wife or husband / android then Humans could have been great, it's failings were, oddly enough, lack of chemistry between the humans. There's no way that, in episode 8, that dangerous, invaluable, sentient robots, responsible for the deaths of at least two people and injuring many others, would be set free to run amok. In particular, the mother's blackmail attempt would have failed, not least because how could a family really be trusted to keep such a massive, important secret? And there's no way the detective fella could nick a laptop from the van and so on (but on the other hand, extreme incompetence does happen). Humans was trying to be too feel-good, (aren't these androids and this dysfunctional family so lovable?) when it should have played up the horror (dysfunctional killer robots endanger a family). Perhaps it also suffered from the lack of a strong villain. Last but not least, the series was so busy preaching politically correct themes to us (an unnecessary disease that ruins so many shows) that it maimed what should have been great drama.
7 out of 17 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
What About Fred????
wandernn1-81-68327416 September 2020
Warning: Spoilers
This one starts with Leo being examined By HOBB, and then a conversation between Voss and Hobb about what Voss wants Hobb to do with these synths. But LEO, really...Voss/ Beatrice was programmed basically to be Leo's mother. What will happen with this 'connection'. ??

At the Hawkins residence, the Police including Pete, tell the Hawkinses that they need to keep quiet and go on with their lives. But Laura comes up wiht a scheme that they will threaten Hobb to go public with hte story about the conscious synths unless Hobb releases them? Yeah that will work out I'm sure.

In confinement, the synths try to figure out a way to brreak out, since they are all linked together conveniently. What is Hobb trying to do here?? The synths determine someone is missing. Hobb is telling the Powers that be that he can expand on David's work. That he can program these synths both to FEEL and to be CONTROLLED. And Hobb, now that he has downloaded David's program that was hidden in the synths, he doesn't need any of them anymore.

PETE, HAS a change of heart and he decides he's going to try to HELP now. And takes Matie and Toby off. And Laura demands to talk to Hobb, right away.

Voss has a talk with LEO in which LEO tells her that she is 'one of us'. Voss is obviously affected by this.

Laura makes a deal wiht Hobb. She negotiates the release of Leo and the others. Voss is suspicious and is told by Hobbs goon that hobb has a 'failsafe' and that the synths will be back to the LAb.

So as soon as the deal is down, Hobb is moving to recover the laptop he wanted. And also Fred transmits the location of the synths to Hobb, so he's going to get them back also. Leo's group runs off, of course a group of like 10 people thats not conspicuous at all. It's a doublecross all the way around. Hobb doesn't have the complete Code wihtout Voss. And Fred is the hacked betrayer of the synths.

Laura finally tells Joe who Tom is. And Voss shows up where Leo and them are all hiding. Leo and Voss have the conversation that the world will never be the same if Leo gives consciousness to all / other synths. Okay so when all the synths hook up together, Voss initially intends to destroy all of them. But Leo pleads with Voss to spare their 'family' and Voss changes her mind. The code, it repairs itself. Niska deletes this program from the laptop onto an external drive, and then gives it to 'someone they trust' , Laura.

Max says they have to take Fred with them, even tho Fred is corrupted. But they end up leaving Fred behind, as they should. Niska says she wants to go on her own way, and make her own choices. Mia says goodbye to Sophie. Oh dear all these goodbyes ......

Voss is found by Pete wallking down the street. Pete, he seems to have had a real change of heart since discovering Voss was a synth after sleeping with her.

And then the Hawkins family is back at home. A synth free home. And Laura laments as this is life, returned to normal???

And then the final scene of the sesason, Niska on a train, looking out the window, looking forward to a unforseeable future for herself. Free at Last????

For a season ending ep., this one had no umph at all.

5/10
2 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed