Mystery Box Challenge: This week's Mystery Box contains ingredients that get better with age. The top three dishes are Jack's, Riley's, and Andrew's. Andrew is declared as the winner of the Mystery Box. Challenge Winner/Immune: Andrew Zappley. Elimination Challenge: Andrew is immune from elimination. The theme for the elimination test is "scary reptiles". Andrew chooses alligator. Jenna's, Cory's, and Nathan's are deemed to be the best three dishes. Winners: Cory Nieves, Jenna Kloner and Nathan Odom. Bottom three: Jimmy Warshawsky, Kyler Bock and Mia Wurster. The judges save Jimmy, eliminating Kyler and Mia. Eliminated: Kyler Bock and Mia Wurster.