Killing for Love (2016) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
18 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
6/10
Compelling documentary about a possible miscarriage of justice
This has just been shown on BBC4 in the UK as "Killing for Love." The BBC gave no indication that this is a German production. But it explains why Jens, who speaks excellent English in court, speaks German here. The original title also may have been too partisan for the BBC. The corporation is perhaps not as convinced as the film makers of Jens's innocence. Whatever the case, the film will fascinate those unfamiliar with the 1990 trial, allegedly the first in the US to be televised, which resulted in long jail terms for Jens and his accomplice Elizabeth. Both were found guilty of the murder of Elizabeth's parents. But Jens claimed that Elizabeth was the killer and he took the blame. It is an unusual murder mystery in that both are intelligent and articulate. He's a diplomat's son, she's the child of wealthy Canadian parents, who affects an English accent. From the beginning the film makers feature participants who are on Jens's side. One says that he could tell Elizabeth was an accomplished liar. But their investigation brings in private detectives who uncover a third suspect (who denies culpability) and unknown DNA at the crime scene. This is surely sufficient to re-open the case. But the authorities in Virginia, where the crimes were committed, will not consider this. Nor will they allow Jens to complete his sentence in Germany or for him to be interviewed again. Much of the footage is of the trial, which was shot on videotape that is now showing its age. But the story is extraordinary, horrible, romantic and shocking and will enthrall all lovers of true crime mysteries.The BBC's iPlayer VOD service features another hour of material.
17 out of 20 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Hard to judge
blumdeluxe10 February 2019
Warning: Spoilers
"Das Versprechen" is a documentary centered around the murder of husband and wife, that was allegedly either commited by the daughter or her foreign boyfriend. The case gathered a lot of media attention and the film tries to collect evidence that the conviction of the boyfriend could possibly be a big mistake.

I find this movie somewhat hard to deal with. The problem is that we all don't really know the truth until today and in my opinion this documentary also only gives arguments rather than creating a waterproof case. You can clearly see that producers are quite subjective about the topic, which doesn't necessarily say they're wrong, I just find it a rather difficult background for exactly this documentary because ideally it would be more a neutral approach towards what might have happened than kind of a plea.

All in all this is surely a nice overview over a very interesting yet complicated murder case but it is lacking the objectivity that I would expect from it.
4 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Riveting
billcr1225 April 2018
Here is a real life murder mystery of the Haysom's in Virginia back in the 80's. Elizabeth was a troubled college student with a drug problem.She met a German student named Jens Soring and her parents ended up hacked to death. They escaped to England but were brought back to the U.S. for trial. She pled guilty and through Jens under the bus. The courtroom footage is riveting, as the two tell very different stories of what happened that night. We all see things through our own personal viewpoints. As a true crime reader for over 30 years(The Stranger Beside Me), I was absorbed by this documentary. The only drawback is the missing Elizabeth, as she refused to be interviewed, but Jens loves to talk, and he makes for a great subject.
5 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Compelling and confusing, lurid and tragic.
JohnDeSando30 December 2017
"It was like stepping inside a slaughterhouse."

So one observer in the documentary Killing for Love reports about the brutal murders of Nancy and Derek Haysom in 1985. More lurid than the photos is the court conclusion that lovers Elizabeth Haysom and Jens Soring murdered them, she being their daughter.

What makes this an audience pleaser is the archival footage that shows her to be a cunning beauty and him an almost innocent lamb to her romantic slaughter. This, the intrigue is that after confessing to the murder, Jens tries to recant saying he lied to mitigate the sentence of his love. The court wouldn't accept the confession of the confession.

Directors Karin Steinberger and Marcus Vetter cut between time and testimonials to create a dynamic if confusing, disjointed set of circumstances filled with lies and ambiguity. Both conditions would ordinarily fulfill the needs of soap opera, but here, as truth is the end game, energy for sympathy is sapped by conflicting facts and sentiments.

Yet, the salacious elements endure for audience interest such as the fact that Elizabeth's mom photographed her nude and allegedly abused her. Additionally, Jens adds a sardonic attitude toward the proceedings that hypnotizes those who would like to think this not a laughing matter.

Filled with striking moments - such as the courtroom revelation that Elizabeth's mother took nude photographs of her and may have abused her sexually, and a tour of the house in which the murders took place, conducted by its current owner who doesn't seem at all fazed by its horrific past

For history buffs, the archival footage is nectar. For those of us who find the DNA evidence now compelling, it looks as if a part II may be in order for Jens Soring's future.
2 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
The eternal strangeness of human behaviour
paul2001sw-128 July 2021
In Virginia in the mid 1980s, a young woman's parents were murdered. She went on the run with her boyfriend: they were subsequently caught and separately tried. She pleaded guilty, he innocent; she gace evidence against him. But they were a very unusualy couple, both unusually intelligent. In the film of their trials, she comes across as extremely calculating; he does a good job of protesting his innocence (claiming he first volunteered to take the rap to protect her), although this whole film is constructed as a presentation of his case. When it was made, both were still in prison, although an update indicates they have finally both been released. I think that 30 years in prison is enough, even for murder in most cases, and I'm glad Jens is finally free. But we might never know the true story: Jens comes across as extremely sympathetic, yet the case for a straightforward miscarriage of justice isn't quite there; it all comes down to who you believe.
0 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Ah, Yes! The Things One Will Do For Love
StrictlyConfidential18 June 2020
(*Memorable quote*) - "I'm innocent!"

If you like watching "true-crime" documentaries - Then - "Killing For Love" is certainly quite an engrossing production that's sure to hold your rapt attention from start to finish.

Impressively directed by German film-maker, Marcus Vetter - "Killing For Love" takes you right into the courtroom where, for the first time, testimony from the accused murderers was publicly televised.

Believe me - When it comes around to the matter of who is guilty and who is innocent - The reality that eventually comes to light (behind the gruesome double-murder of Derek and Nancy Haysom) is certainly quite a twisted little triangle-of-a-tale. Indeed.
0 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Needed better structuring
Leofwine_draca30 July 2021
Warning: Spoilers
An interesting true crime documentary, similar to the ones put out by Netflix. Not quite as gripping as those, particularly at the outset; I felt I was a bit lost at the beginning as to what I was watching and what it all meant, perhaps some narration would have helped. There's also an endless amount of courtroom footage which I felt could have been edited down a bit as at two hours this feels overlong. However, it does all come together in the second half and as usual it shines a light into the murky workings of American state law, so by the end it becomes engrossing.
0 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Intense and poignant - highly reccomended true crime documentary
darnsian3 January 2018
This is a great documentary about a horrible crime, spanning decades as the filmmakers slowly peel back public appearance to reveal new information and the emotional lives of the people involved. It reminded me yet again how complicated true life is, and that we must always stay open, must always resist the rush to judgement. I grew up in the Virginia area and remember well when these murders were committed. This doc painstakingly presents alternate versions of the event itself, and allows us to exist in the contradictory space created between two people, a swirl of deception and self-deception, loyalty and guilt - the human ecology. An intense, engrossing, deeply emotional film - I so enjoyed being invited into Mr. Soering's mind over the years. The filmmakers cannot deliver us a pat ending - it doesn't exist and probably never will - but I appreciate their intention to be fair, and to investigate. A great crime doc that turns the tables on a prevailing narrative. There are always other sides of the story.
7 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Compelling Criminal Justice Documentary
RMoest28 December 2017
Warning: Spoilers
I was deeply affected by the documentary "Killing for Love," and strongly recommend it . Elizabeth Haysom's and her lover, Jens Soering, were ultimately convicted of the murder of her parents. Haysom pleaded guilty to planning the murder in exchange for her testimony against Soering. He had confessed to the killing but later recanted. The trial was televised, the first to be broadcast beginning-to-end on cable TV. The TV footage, an extensive interview of Mr. Soering, and interviews with those who participated in the original investigation are major parts of the movie. The film shows that original investigation was really directed at substantiating Soering's guilt. Other explanations are at least as compelling, but there was a systematic failure to follow any leads that did not point to Mr. Soering's culpability. The film undercuts the prosecution evidence, and builds a persuasive argument for reasonable doubt. Mr. Soering's interview is riveting. Not only does he explain his confession and show a sincerity that does not fit with the charge, but he has a remarkable lack of bitterness after having been imprisoned for thirty years. The movie does not claim to prove Soering's innocence, which makes it a better movie. "Killing for Love" asks us to reflect on the flaws in the criminal justice system and the question of how long a man should be imprisoned for something he allegedly did before he was 21. A story that deserves all the attention it can get, well told.
5 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
A persuasive argument for reasonable doubt
whitneylifex31 December 2017
If you're a fan of true-crime documentaries like "Making A Murder," the "Paradise Lost" films, and "The Thin Blue Line," this film is for you. Like those films, this one allows you to sit watching as judge & jury, looking at a case through the prism of time, to see if the verdict was just. I believe, like those films, that this one lays out a persuasive argument for reasonable doubt which is no small thing. After all, it is a fact that innocent people end up in prison. Luckily, on occasion, the system corrects itself, as we read every few months when someone is exonerated by DNA. For that to happen, though, people need to care and that is why I recommend watching this film. Every voice counts.
5 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Just add water.
ulf-635-52336717 February 2017
Extremely extended and a diffuse drama. A square narrated history that has enormous potential. A lot of non-verbal and marginal persons occur and give us their opinions. But what about those who could interpret Jens and Elizabeth's story from a different perspective? However the trial shows that the US is a very legally unsafe part of the world, where gnomes like this may engage in law. Just add water.
6 out of 29 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
True Crime at its best
dominicjohn5 January 2018
Gripping and suspenseful doc turned thriller that stays with you for a long, long time. The film challenges everything you know about love and the dark side of its influence. Prepare to get the chills.
3 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
A wonderful film about the failures of our justice system
katebust4 January 2018
Warning: Spoilers
KILLING FOR LOVE tells the story of Jens, a young man who's unfortunate love for murderous Elisabeth has landed him in prison for the majority of his life for a crime he did not commit. This film is one part fascinating murder mystery, which will engage any true crime lover and one part advocacy film, demanding Jens' release with the mounting evidence that the investigation and trial of this crime were clearly mishandled. I found this film illuminating in so many ways and hope that it helps Jens and the many others like him who are facing jail time, even life sentences for crimes they did not commit.
3 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Excellent wrongful conviction film
neil-233076 January 2018
The film is a very entertaining and moving documentary in the mode of past films about wrongful convictions that have wrenching consequences. I didn't know about the case or the media coverage that it generated back in the day, so appreciated the patient narrative build up towards the heartbreaking conclusion along with updates about how Jens Söring is inexplicably still in jail because of mystifying motivations or past and present politicians in Virginia. I saw a Los Angeles screening of the film that featured a rousing affirmation of the need for justice for Jens Söring. I feel the same way and hope that others can come to the same conclusion and lend their support to his cause before it is too late.
3 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
An Riveting True-Crime Documentary
stanleyjdavid30 December 2017
Warning: Spoilers
Killing For Love is an excellent film -- one well worth watching. It's a riveting true-crime documentary about the Haysom murders in Virginia in the 1980s and Jens Soering's wrongful conviction and ongoing fight for freedom. Akin to Making a Murderer and Serial, the film chronicles how terribly wrong things can go in our criminal justice system. In this case, the film's subject (Jens Soering) is a German-born student who is attending the University of Virginia. He falls in love with Elizabeth Haysom, the daughter of Virginia socialites, whose allure masks her deep psychological and family troubles. When her parents are murdered, Elizabeth and Jens become the prime suspects, and a high-profile trial and media maelstrom ensue. The film includes great footage from the trial itself -- the first of its kind, pre-dating the OJ Simpson case, to be captured in the international media spotlight. Watch and expect to be drawn into this story of love, youth, betrayal, murder, and a criminal justice system incapable of separating fact from fiction.
1 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Riveting and tragic true crime documentary - a must-see
looseseal-159134 January 2018
Warning: Spoilers
A love story, a murder, a man in prison for 32 years for a crime he never committed.

In the vein of Making a Murderer, Killing For Love takes us through the heartbreaking story of a man fighting desperately against the criminal justice system. Jens Soering meets Elizabeth Haysom in his first year of college in the United States. He is from Germany, an outsider, very smart. She is also terribly smart, manipulative, charming. Jens is enchanted with her right away and their love affair begins.

They write each other love letters when they are apart--which are narrated perfectly by Imogen Poots and Daniel Bruhl--long, poetic confessions of love and fantasy and twisted desire. Elizabeth writes again and again of her hatred toward her parents; their drinking; her desire to have them dead. When her parents are brutally murdered, Elizabeth and Jens flee to Europe, but are eventually captured and there's talk of the death penalty. Jens, wrapped up in his obsession and desperate to save his girlfriend, confesses to the crime.

The story twists and turns, each person adding more and sometimes contradictory but of the tale--from folks who were investigating the crime when it happened to those still rallying and fighting on behalf of Jens. I found myself both captivated by the twists and turns of the narrative, and heartbroken for Jens. This film is engrossing, crushing, and a story well-told.
1 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Timely and fascinating!
PaulPony21 January 2018
Talk about timely! Killing for Love is one of those rare and engrossing films that not only moves deeper and deeper into the inner workings of an unjust conviction and term of imprisonment, 30 years and running. What separates this from the pack are new and critical pieces of the on-going story unfolding before the world's eyes via the international press. The only other example I can think of is Robert Durst in The Jinx (2015), although with this carefully crafted new film, there are surprises due to a variety of factors, not simply a confession as with Durst. From IMDb: "This beautifully crafted film reveals a mismanaged, or perhaps completely corrupted, judicial process. This was the first criminal trial held in front of TV cameras - the first high-profile, international case tried in a small town. Investigations over the past 3 years have turned up stunning evidence that was previously suppressed or deemed inadmissible. New forensic techniques have disproven evidence that was key to Soering's original conviction. Denied parole 12 times, his next hearing in 2017 may have a different outcome, at the same time the film is in release." See it as soon as you can and get up to speed on this intriguing and bizarre true crime story.
1 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
A compelling and thrilling court room drama which shocks with its human tradegy
info-2637115 January 2018
This film is "stranger than fiction" - a real true crime story which gets under your skin. From the really first beginning you are shackled by the gruesome real crime szene footage, the touching romantic love letters with voice work from Daniel Brühl reading Jens Söring's letters and Imogen Poots reading Elizabeth Haysom's letters and the thrilling court room footage. This is one of the best documentaries I have seen and left me blown away about the injustice of the US justice system.
1 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed