Generic Black Shirt Group travels to Monroe, NY in this first part, of a two part, investigation of McGarrah's Inn. The inn was built approximately 1799 by John McGarrah, and in its day was known as a "4 Candle inn" (equivalent to today's 5-star hotel). Heaped in rich history, McGarrah's Inn is best known for its status as the oldest existing Mason Lodge room in the state of New York. The team is joined by special guest investigator, Chris DiCesare, known for his book "Surviving Evidence," and the subject of the film "Please Talk with Me," when he learned he had a gift for connecting to otherworldly entities. In this episode the team starts by exploring the attic where strange cold spots, several physical confrontations and numerous EVPs are caught. Next a second group tries their luck in the basement where reports of a shadow man, affectionately referred to as 'Steve,' has been known to linger.
—Wendy Curtis