Paige and Winter go to the local comic book store on Free Comic Book Day where they run into three close friends. After discussing the injustice of the mean cashier in the comic book store, the five unite and teach the cashier a lesson.
Paige talks about the KGB comic book she worked on and the dealings of the artistic differences with her Russian boss. To spite her boss, Veruka creates an American nemesis that will rival the comic book's Russian hero.
Paige and Winter are watching horror movies while house sitting for Travis. They invite Marcy over to indulge in their macabre viewing, which evolves into confessions of their most nightmarish fears.
Travis shows up unannounced to Paige and Winter's apartment with a puppy. The adorable pup is to be auctioned off for a fund-raiser, but is accidentally left behind and it's up to Paige and Winter to return it.
Paige takes Winter, and Marcy go to Anaheim Comic Con so she can have a portfolio review with a Dynamic Imagery Comics. After leaving Marcy to watch Paige's portfolio, Marcy gets lost, making Paige and Winter to search the convention for her.
Paige and her friends are on their way to the club when they stop by Nicoli's condo to drop off her comic book panels. In a heated dispute between Paige and Tatyana, the two go toe to toe in a drink off.