The look of the 2007 Critic is based upon his appearance in the review of the Cloverfield trailer, when Doug Walker was still experimenting with his character's look and wardrobe.
While filming an outdoor scene for this review, Doug and Rob, who was dressed as Santa Christ, were approached by a couple, asking if they represented Toys for Tots, because they thought Rob was dressed as Santa Claus. As a result, Toys for Tots became a charity they annually seek donations for, with Doug relaying this story in subsequent Christmas videos.