No Fathers in Kashmir (2019) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
5 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
Loss, love and hopes in the Valley of Tears,, Kashmir.
Tejas_Vinda_AITS5 April 2019
A teenage girl from Britain, Noor visits Kashmir with her mother only to stumble upon the real story behind her missing father. She befriends a local Kashmiri boy, Majid who has suffered a similar fate and he agrees to help her unravel more truths. But their pursuit ends up taking a different turn.

The filmmaker brings a brutal and harsh reality of the Kashmir Valley.

Noor (Zara Webb) and Majid (Shivam Raina).

When Noor finds out that both their fathers were 'picked up' (the meaning of which Noor eventually understands) by the Indian army years ago, with no news of them since, she wants to find out more,, about extremely conservative Muslims who dream of an Islamic state and double-agents who pretend to work for militants as well as for the army.

Her probing unravels more than what she bargained for including the double dealings of an idolized, radical local leader, Arshid (Ashvin Kumar).

Thee good moments between Noor and Majid,..which bring a smile to your face.,that eventually develops into a tender love story even though their present realities and circumstances are so different.

The story is heart-wrenching and mostly gripping.

The innocent charm of the lead pair Zara Webb and Shivam Raina that shines through - especially Raina who touches a chord as Majid.

This film is not a light watch - it's a poignant tale that leaves you thinking about the half-widows and half-orphans, and many such untold stories.
8 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Excellent performances
beevenkat14 April 2019
Two kids are probing their dads disappearance in #NoFathersInKashmir. The girl is from britain and the boy is from kashmir. Just like many other muslim men, their dads too have suddenly gone missing. Their families wait endlessly, but it is not clear if the men are dead or alive. There is a scene where the girl wants a picture with a terrorist because it is "so cool" to be clicked with one. Excellent performances by zara webb, shivam raina, soni razdan n kulbhushan kharbanda. This film needs your love n support, do watch it in theaters. Rating 3.5/5.
3 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
A film that becomes the voice of the oppressed
sampowa29 January 2020
Ashvin Kumar's No Fathers in Kashmir elegantly reminds of the power of film as it takes us on a journey through which the dark secrets and hidden realities of life in Indian Occupied Kashmir are explored. A film becomes the voice of an oppressed population at a time when the oppressor has cut them off from the world. The lockdown is happening right now but the suffering began decades ago.

It is very rare in India for a filmmaker to work on a film that upsets the authorities. At a time when the biggest names of Bollywood line up to produce films unconditionally praising the nation, particularly its military, someone has rebelled against norms. Films in India present army men as noble and ready to sacrifice themselves fighting for just causes - selfless men who can do no wrong.

This is why a film like No Fathers in Kashmir goes against the tides. It's like the one son who grows up to question his father. Governments and armies have over the years justified illegal and unjust actions against innocent civilians by manipulating public opinion. Hitler made people believe that he was the one in the right and he did so through propaganda. Bollywood has for years been showing one side of the story when it comes to Kashmir and it's too obvious why this has been the case. Films that support the agenda have unlimited access to funding whereas a film like No Fathers in Kashmir not only scares investors but attracts legal battles as well as threats.

Ashvin could have given up the thought of making such a film and gone for a much safer option. Investors would shy away from his choice of subject. Industry giants would not want any association with a film that questions the brutality of the Indian forces. However, not only did he make the film - he relentlessly fought legal battles to get it released in India. Having followed his updates on social media, I witnessed Ashvin's abundance of will power and determination in getting his film released.

It's not a conventional Bollywood film. There are no movie stars playing lead roles. The protagonist is a teenage school girl who comes to Kashmir with questions surrounding her father's disappearance. Just like most people, she doesn't know the harsh realities of life in Indian Occupied Kashmir. A selfie obsessed, social media loving, young person discovers the problems faced by ordinary people; making the film perfect for youngsters who must be told the story of Kashmir. This is exactly the kind of awareness the issue needs. Young people are being bombarded with propaganda films and biased media reporting. The hero is normally an Indian soldier and the bad guys are Kashmiris who are presented as enemies of peace loving Indians. The reality is somewhat different - these so called bad guys have no choice but to fight back against oppression. True patriotism as shown by Ashvin is acknowledging and condemning the wrongdoing of authorities rather than denying and concealing.

Ashvin has done a great service to humanity. He has not only heard the screams of the helpless mothers, fathers, daughters, sons, brothers, sisters and wives in Kashmir but he has become their voice. Nowadays the vast majority of films are made purely for entertainment and to fill the pockets of investors and producers. Rarely do we find a film taking on such an important role in society.

Indian authorities have locked down the people of Kashmir and without internet access, it is very difficult for those people to share their torment with the rest of the world. Ashvin has reminded the world that those Kashmiris who have suffered over the years should not be forgotten. There are some extremely powerful scenes in the film which expose the brutality of the Indian army and the helplessness of those they oppress in every way possible. One scene also highlights the hypocritical manner in which the Indian media covers Kashmir. It reminds us how and why so many are completely unaware of the truth.

Ashvin deserves more than just awards for No Fathers in Kashmir. He has demonstrated the power of film in highlighting and raising awareness of social injustices. A man has stepped forward out of a population of a billion and spoken the truth. It takes an immense amount of courage to do so. Ashvin has given hope to the people of Kashmir - at least there is someone in India who is willing to discuss their plight. He has set an example for others to follow. Most importantly, he has understood the Kashmir issue and portrayed it through his story and characters. People will now ask questions rather than blindly accepting the Indian Government's explanation. This is the kind of social change that film has the power to initiate.

Sameer Hussain
3 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Essence of kashmir
vaishavjoge22 July 2021
Beautifully written and well narrated movie...kashmiri songs beautifully sung..shown reality of kashmir...loved this movie..i wish more of scenic beauty from valley could be shot...wonderfully acted ...yeah again loved it❤❤❤
1 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
Excellent everything but the character of Noor was so insufferably selfish, spoiled, entitled, hypocritical and illogical thatbit ruined the movie
infinitegodinfinity11 February 2022
Warning: Spoilers
This movie would be a 9/10 if it weren't for the atrocious character of Noor. Her entitlement couldn't be stood by any sane mind, interwoven here is her oblivious classism which is not as much of her fault anyway.

She is a British citizen, if she stays in captivity in another country this will result in an international conflict where a less powerful country wouldn't like to take their chances against the mighty British Empire. Everyone in the movie knows this, yet she still decides to not use this to her advantage and get both her and Majid out by simply REFUSING TO LEAVE WITHOUT MAJID. AND IF SHE REFUSES TO LEAVE SHE WILL SPARK THE AFORE MENTIONED INTERNATIONAL INCIDENT, AND EVERYONE WANTS TO AVOID THAT SO THEY WILL HAVE NO CHOICE BUT TO RELEASE BOTH HER AND MAJID IN PAIR.

Now that is the clear solution, but she acted not only so idioticaly, but so immorally, unethically and illegally too. She betrayes Majid; she trespasses in other people's properties and infringes their privacy; she has the audacity to judge people on NOT TOLERATING INHUMANE TORTURE FOR ONE MORE DAY AFTER DAYS OF CONTINUOUS TORTURE while she herself couldn't withstand staying in harmless (for her) captivity where her basic needs were met and she wasn't touched (unlike Majid who was severely beaten); She gives out Majid by shouting his name when she is caught by the soldiers in the mountain, not only bringing him down with her but expecting a rescue from him and she constantly nags Majid throughout their mountain journey about him being the one responsible for the collective wellbeing of the pair or just her own wellbeing (telling him she is hungry as if it is his responsibility to feed her, asking him annoying questions about why the bears wouldn't come to them, etc.), risks his entire life by hiding the phone after he told them she was taking pics; Is not supportive in the slightest when they bring Majid the guy who sacrificed his life to save her from the soldier beaten in front of her, she just cares about her own state of shock and ignores him.

I could go on listing for several pages... but yeah... TL;DR: Great movie ruined by a terrible character, none of this was needed, she could have been better in every way and the olot would have been more emotional and richer, but the way it is you just feel anger at this stupid character.
0 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed