Maltese - Il Romanzo del Commissario (TV Mini Series 2017– ) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
8 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
9/10
Killing them softly
paul2001sw-120 February 2018
'Gomorra' is the Italian equivalent to 'The Wire', a drama that explores the entire basis of a crimilaised society from top to bottom. 'Maltese: The Mafia Detective' was conceived by some of the same people, but it's a different sort of story, focused on a single heroic protagonist, featuring a mystery to be unravelled, and set in beautiful Sicily (it's true, 'Gomorra' is set in beautiful Naples, but that show offers a very unattractive view of its host city). But if you were to think that 'Maltese' might be, say, a clone of 'Inspector Montalbano' (a fun but essentially lightweight series), you'd be mistaken. It's well-acted, immaculately shot and scored, and has a historical setting (the 1970s) while still feeling of contemporary relevance; while the mafia-themed plot is sufficiently complex to carry eight episodes, yet without descending into ridiculouslness. The ending is both surprising and appropriate. If 'Gomorra' has an operatic feel at times, 'Maltese' is more softly poetic; but still very good
23 out of 25 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
excellent series !
vasilis-papageorgiou15 February 2018
One of the best Italian series ! nice atmosphere and good actors.
20 out of 22 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Maltese: The Mafia Detective
Tweekums15 March 2018
This Italian drama is set in the mid '70s and follows Dario Maltese, a police commissioner who returns to his hometown on Sicily to attend the marriage of his childhood friend who is now the commissioner of the local police. Maltese hasn't been there long when his friend and his fiancée are gunned down. He requests a transfer to he can investigate his friend's murder. It isn't long before authorities are linking the death to an unknown woman he was seen with; Maltese is convinced that it was no crime of passion though... he is sure it has all the hallmarks of a mafia hit. He, and a few trusted police officers started digging deeper and soon believe that there are links between the local political authorities and organised crime. It won't be easy to prove though; these are incredibly dangerous people willing to kill anybody who betrays them and anybody trying to expose them.

When I saw the trailer for this, featuring our protagonist driving a motorboat with his suit and '70s moustache I thought it might be a pastiche but it quickly became apparent that this was going to be a fairly gritty drama. It doesn't do anything to glamorise the mafia; they are depicted as thugs who have corrupted those in power through a combination of bribery and fear. There is a real sense of danger as the investigation progresses; this escalates exponentially as Maltese closes in on the evidence he so desperately seeks. The makers nicely captured the '70s feel; at no time did I feel that details were obviously wrong as is often the case with dramas sent in the not too distant past. The acting is impressive; most notably from Kim Rossi Stuart, who plays Maltese and is rarely off screen; and Rike Schmid who play Elisa Ripstein, a photographer at the local paper who gets involved with Maltese. Overall I'd certainly recommend this to fans of European crime drama; especially those who enjoyed 'Inspector Montalbano' and want to see something else set on Sicily, even though this is much gritter.

These comments are based on watching the series in Italian with English subtitles.
13 out of 14 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Maltese
roylfinch6 March 2018
A bit slow but atmospheric and believable. Fairly gritty. I watched 8 episodes, whilst each actor appears to only have 4 in their biography. Am assuming that there are plenty of loose ends to tie up for another series!
9 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Al Pacino isnt in this Mafia film?
aprilmike-5199114 April 2020
The style and atmosphere of the mid seventies along with the hippies and mo's is just amazing. I feel like I've missed out somewhere! Yes long smoking shots and Fiat/Alfa porn. The town looks a reck but you have to hand it to the Italians, they do it in style!!! Well worth a see.
2 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
There exists no such thing as "mafia" in Sicily...
Coventry25 October 2019
It's been several long years since I've seen a gritty realistic and genuinely good Sicilian mafia epos, hence I was really enthusiast when finding out about the "Maltese" mini-series! Also, the series is set in the year 1976, which incidentally means that it features all the trademarks of my beloved and utmost favorite Poliziotesschi genre, namely: rough macho cop-protagonists with mustaches, savage car chases with fragile Alfa Romeo Giulias and exaggeratedly heavy smoking in concealed spaces! Add to this a fantastic contemporary soundtrack, a compelling plot, strong performances and per episode a few bits of harsh violence, and you've got yourself an absolute must of a euro-crime series.

Roman police commissioner Dario Maltese travels back to his hometown Trapani, in Sicily, to attend the wedding of his oldest friend who's the head of local police. Dario left Trapani when he was sixteen, following the suicide of his father (again, a police commissioner) who got involved in a sex-scandal with a minor. Barely arrived in Trapani, Dario's friend and his fiance are brutally executed in their car. Maltese discovers that his friend was attempting to clean up the mafia practices in Trapani and began to make good progress. Fed up trying to run from his past, Maltese promptly arranges his permanent transfer to Trapani to continue his friend's work and capture his assailants. Needless to say, Maltese rapidly runs into typical mafia obstructions, like utterly corrupt authority figures, key-witnesses getting murdered, money laundering and cover-ups. His persistence as well as his unorthodox methods are nevertheless successful, as he manages to revitalize the team of fatigue inspectors and even uncover some dark secrets surrounding the death of his own father.

The first episode of "Maltese" is extremely powerful and immediately establishes that we are dealing with an intelligent and qualitative series here. Admittedly, the next 3-4 episodes are slightly less absorbing and memorable, but for comprehensible reasons. The plot is thickening, Commissioner Maltese faces dead ends or useless leads in his investigation and there naturally also are the mandatory sub plots, like the romance with the beautiful press photographer. The last three episodes, however, are so suspenseful and fast-paced that I bench-watched them without interruptions. The coastal filming locations are astounding, and likewise are the performances of the entire cast. Throughout the series, there's quite a lot violent content, like stone-cold executions, but evidently several eminent characters in Trapani continue claiming that the Sicilian Mafia is nothing but a fable. Great stuff, highly recommended if you are into Italian exploitation cinema of the 70s (Umberto Lenzi, Stelvio Massi, Fernando Di Leo, ...)
8 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Excellent
robinkowhite23 August 2023
The acting and the plot development are really good as mentioned in other reviews. However, what really sets this apart from other shows is the settings they have used, the filters that bring out a wide Mediterranean palette and the overall gorgeous cinematography. It's a TV show, but it's been shot as if it was being put on a cinema screen. The opening credits (superbly soundtracked by a sub-house theme tune from Ralf Hildenbeutel) are a good collection of the quality of the cinematography on play. The Sicilian landscape and architecture become practically the main character of the show.

The plot gets quite complex over the first several episodes before straightening out, but it also works somewhat as a mood piece, where you can just soak into the setting.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Decent series
vanhee197027 October 2019
Lots of Alfa Romeoporn lol Some loose ends in the plot. Good acting.
1 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed