"Goodnight Sweetheart" Many Happy Returns (TV Episode 2016) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
5 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
9/10
Brilliant Revival of an oldish favourite
jdhb-768-612343 September 2017
Warning: Spoilers
Goodnight Sweetheart was a clever idea and the original series was great fun. The writing was excellent, the acting likewise and the overall atmosphere created as Gary Sparrow shifted from the 1940s to the 1990s really well handled. It was a shame when it came to an end. That it was to be revisited 17 years after its end filled me with both dread and anticipation; would it be as good as the original or would it be the usual dire modern take on an old classic ?

Thankfully, and unlike most revivals, this one really works. With the original writers and cast in place, Gary's rediscovery of his time travelling abilities through an encounter with his new-born self kicks off a new adventure which is full of great humour. Gary's bemusement when he first encounters a modern day street scene is palpable and the discovery that he has a daughter suggests all manor of possible future story lines. Might his son from the past meet his daughter from the present, for instance ? Perhaps they might have inherited his time travelling powers with who knows what results.

Sadly, it seems that we are unlikely to ever see the possibilities developed as the BBC, quite unaccountably in my view, has chosen not to pursue the offer of a new series but has, instead, opted for follow ups to Porridge and Open All Hours, both of which were brilliant as originals but pretty dire in their modern incarnations.

This revival of Goodnight Sweetheart is in an altogether different league and I found myself laughing out loud at the oh-so welcome good clean humour, beautifully presented. Great stuff and truly deserving of a new series.
9 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Back in time
Prismark103 September 2016
Goodnight Sweetheart was a sitcom with an interesting concept of a time travelling adulterer. It was carried off by Nicholas Lyndhurst's appealing performance and rather derailed by the cast change of the two leading ladies leaving the series and being replaced.

When we last saw Gary Sparrow he was stuck in the past permanently. In this special one off, time has moved on from the 1940s to 1962. It looks like those 1960s Beatles songs he sang might come back to haunt him. Gary attends hospital to see his father waiting at the maternity ward for Gary to be born in 1962, when he ends up holding himself as a baby he manages to push himself forward to the present day.

Gary's last brush with the present day was 1999 and the world of 2016 is different. Smartphones, electric cars, openly gay couples in public, expensive coffee houses and his wife Yvonne is a business tycoon, television personality and Gary finds out he also has teenage daughter.

Gary now has to get to grips with the present as well as his life in the past. Writers Marks and Gran usually were always sure footed when it came to comedies and had a dab hand when it came to inserting cultural references. Just note the gag on European disharmony. They also kept this consistently funny and I managed to find myself laughing a few times and I needed it after watching the dire Young Hyacinth earlier in the evening.

Nerd Alert: As Gary Sparrow walks in the present day with the strains of The Beatles, Love Me Do, he encounters the security guard played by Ted Robbins. Robbins is the real life cousin of Paul McCartney.
10 out of 13 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Welcome back to the future Mr Sparrow
studioAT6 September 2016
'Goodnight Sweetheart' was an odd choice of sitcom to be revived by the BBC for their 'sitcom season'. After all, the 1999 final episode wrapped everything up quite nicely, and gave Garry Sparrow the ending he deserved after six years of having his cake and eating it.

However, with the original writers and Nicholas Lyndhurst (who doesn't tend to sign up for any old rubbish)involved I decided to give it ago.

Yes, there were some weaker moments, and not all the jokes were funny, but this was by far one of the better of the sitcom revivals. It not only reintroduced his to the characters but you could genuinely see where the series could go from here.

I enjoyed 'Goodnight Sweetheart mark 2' and would welcome the chance to see where Garry goes next.
11 out of 17 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Watch it out of nostalgia.
Sleepin_Dragon2 September 2016
Warning: Spoilers
Goodnight Sweetheart seemed a rather odd choice to be celebrated in the recent sitcom season. A comedy that started off brilliantly, so original and funny, but turned a bit flat when members of the cast started leaving and the ideas tired. Now set in the sixties, World War II a thing of the past, the new setting didn't do a great deal to save us from the recycled jokes. Nice as a one off for nostalgia's sake, nice to see Emma Amos (Yvonne) is still as attractive as ever, and now a Dragon (slightly less believable then the time travelling!) Gary's astonishment at 2016 life was probably the best bit, the mobile world, the coffee nation, gay men kissing in public etc.

So Gary's once again lost in the mists of time, and it pains me to say so but that's where Goodnight Sweetheart belongs. 5/10
7 out of 19 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
2/10
Awful and cringey!
teachermarkthailand10 March 2021
Terrible return to the past of an average 1990s British sitcom. The laughter track is distracting and unnecessary. Good only knows why this was cobbled together. It's dreadful.
1 out of 18 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed