Ranked #30 on Billboard's list of the Best Music Videos Since 2000.
"Stacy's Mom" reached number 21 on the Billboard Hot 100, becoming the band's highest-charting hit in the United States.
The song ranks No. 350 on Blender's 500 Greatest Songs Since You Were Born.
Ben Greenman, writing for The New Yorker, considered it the "second-catchiest song ever written about a girlfriend's parent," after "Mrs. Robinson".
The song peaked within the top 10 in Ireland, and the top 20 in the United Kingdom, Canada, and Australia.