Songbird (2018) Poster

(I) (2018)

User Reviews

Review this title
12 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
5/10
not good enough
SnoopyStyle26 February 2020
JoAnne Skye (Cobie Smulders) is a 90's rock star. The "Filthy Dukes" is her band. Her stardom is now faded and she's struggling to keep going. When her band finally quits, she reconnects with an old friend Sara Ramsey (Jessica Hynes) living in a caravan and decides to be an university student. She has a fling with administrator Pete (Richard Elis).

Firstly, I adore Cobie Smulders, and Jessica Hynes for Spaced. The 4 rating concerned me but also intrigued me. I can see the problems but it's not quite that bad. This was apparently much improvised, and shot in five days. It looks and feels it. It needs a few more written scenes and to extend it to a full week. It tries to cover with some montage sequences. Smulders could do a little singing but the opening music video is too inferior. I would suggest lip sync. There are a few good songs in the movie. It's fine to pick one of them and have her lip sync it. As for the characters, I like the destructiveness of Smulders, the buried jealousy of Hynes, and Elis' innate niceness. There is a lot to like here but it is still not good enough.
5 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
That was a tough slog to watch
debra-923215 November 2020
Story was trite and cringey, going for obvious characters, no depth, no chemistry, not even a good soundtrack....
0 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
Don't waste your time
AMZCali13 September 2018
I could watch Cobie read poetry for hours but this film is a mess that looks like it was made by a first month film student. There is no charm, no really funny moments, just a really, really, really, really bad film. When I say that there's no chemistry between the leads, don't assume that there's some kind of plot. There is no plot. Literally, throughout the entire film, Cobie acts as if she high or drunk in EVERY scene. I mean drunk like when your friend gets drunk and thinks she's really funny until she sees video the next day of just how stupid she really was the night before. I have to assume that Cobie made this film because the director is a family member or someone she owed a really big favor to.
14 out of 20 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
2/10
Laziest movie of 2018?
Omar-Khalfi12 September 2018
Warning: Spoilers
This movie is so bad and cringy its painfully hard to watch, where to even begin, the plot, the non existant logic behind the character motivations and how they are supposed to act,or the annoying in your face try hard gender role reversal this movie is constantly banging you in head with. so the lady from "how i met your mother" the main character in this is a 90s Britpop band singer, after her band breaks up while on tour in the uk for some reason they never tells us she meets with her lesbian friend that lives in the same town and drunkenly apply to go back into university in that same city and basically things just forcefully happen from there. the guy she meets the night of the breakup at some bar is the same guy responsible for college applications or something and the barbecue party in the beach where she makes the stupid bet with her friend where they bet on who has sex first so the guy can find about it and be mad that he is just a part of a bet, oh and i almost forgot about the long painful scene where they invite the university guy to this party where they tell him to bring only "sexually active male friends". basically everything in this movie is just is just a plot device the movie doesn't even care about making you sympathize with these characters its just boom this happens so that this other thing can happen. these people obviously just rolled the cameras and started improvising it feels like it was slapped together in two days in literally 4 locations the dorm, next to the big tree, the beach and the cafeteria this movie might be the laziest film i've ever seen and it shows, if only it was a bit serious it could actually became a little bit funny bad and not annoying condescending tone bad.
9 out of 15 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
2/10
Hoped for the best... but no...
crazymanmichael6 November 2019
I do try my best to approach films with an open mind, even if I happen to see bad reviews, low ratings, etc. here on IMDB or on, say, Rotten Tomatoes. That said, the many scathingly bad reviews posted for this film did make it hard to watch with an unbiased mind, and I suppose I was on the lookout for the usual "bad movie" red flags. Sadly, there were many. That said, given the subject matter (and given that I am a musician with a lot of experiences over the years, both good and bad, in bands), I really do think I went into it wanting to like this movie. Unfortunately, those bad reviews were well justified. This movie was embarrassingly bad. I am not familiar with the actors playing the leads, but I would not be surprised if this film alone torpedoed their careers. The acting is so stupefyingly bad that I was forced to look away at some points, as if averting my eyes from someone picking their nose or scratching their back. The editing appeared to have been done in-camera, and the random, utterly nonsensical jump cuts reminded me of a home movie videographer trying to keep their clips short because they were worried they may run out of tape. As to the plot... what plot? If there was one, if there was anything, anything at all, that resembled some sort of coherent narrative, well, I missed it, sorry.

I can only say I am glad I borrowed this from the local library, so no money changed hands.

My totally unsolicited advice to the actors, writer, director, editor, producer, cinematographer, exec producer, composer(s), vfx team... don't quit your day jobs.
5 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
2/10
Just a dumb movie
srjcochrane12 September 2018
So hard to relate and therefore unable to say I actually enjoyed the movie. 2 minutes in I thought what the heck go and have a beer and a steak and enjoy the evening, but no I last the 95 minutes. Damn
8 out of 18 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Have To Love Indie Indie Cinema
snowgeorge-9436819 September 2020
I was expecting very little from this movie. From the Blu-ray cover, I thought I'd make it through 10 minutes before turning it off. The first few "documentary" style minutes were not very good. But, once it got down to the narrative, this was a thoroughly entertaining love story.

To appreciate this, you need to be able to watch very low budget, almost home made quality movies. The acting and characters made up for the unpleasing visual aesthetic. This is from the UK, so it's character driven, not standard 3-Act-Structure.

For what it is, it's damn entertaining. I know I'll watch again, actually quite a few more times.

It's a keeper.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
An accident of a film
amaduu19 September 2022
What happens when you mix a mediocre script with a bad director? Actors will suffer for life. Coby will have to cover this shameful tattoo of a film all her career. I don't know much about the editor who will be another innocent casualty of sorry filmmaking. Above and beyond the script lacks enough dialogue to fill up a commercial or a 4 minutes trailer. Jesus, Paul and all the prophets tricks couldn't have saved the day. Oh and the music section : what up with that. I am now very curious to watch more by the same director to see how he has managed to get this monstrosity financed. I should have known better when I saw the 4.1 rating which is uber generous.
0 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
A manic pixie who smashes guitars and kicks guys in the nuts. This ya gotta see.
rooprect3 November 2020
You're probably familiar with the manic pixie romcom formula which is basically: take 1 hyper quirky happy girl with short hair and pair her with a straight-faced, straight-laced, lovable loser of a guy, shake vigorously and hilarity ensues. Fine examples include "500 Days of Summer" (Zooey Deschanel), "Yes Man" (Zooey Deschanel), or anything else that has (Zooey Deschanel). Here we have an interesting twist on the manic pixie romcom formula. Our manic pixie is a real a-hole. And it's the straight-laced loser guy who is the breath of fresh air in her otherwise decaying life.

"Alright Now" is the story of a washed up 30-something, one-hit-wonder singer from the 90s "Jo" (Cobie Smulders) as she struggles with the denial that she can't play the guitar and that that her hip 90s wardrobe is now "ironic vintage" attire. She herself has become a joke to the young kids. So what does she do? She enrolls in college. It's a great premise, like a blend of Riann Wilson's "The Rocker" and Rodney Dangerfield's "Back to School" in the context of a manic pixie romcom.

The presentation is very realistic with a lot of improvised scenes that carry a natural awkward brand of humor. Jo trades subtle gags and not-so-subtle sexual innuendo with our lovable loser "Peter" (Richard Elis) who plays the admissions officer at the college but mostly stumbles around like a Welsh rarebit in the headlights. You'll enjoy this if you like awkward humor and imperfect dialogue (people talking over each other, often mumbling nonsense but with the occasional under-the-breath punchline like in films with Michael Cera "Juno", "Superbad", etc). But if you prefer a more traditional type of comedy with scripted jokes and planned gags, you might not get into this flick.

The tagline on the DVD reads "an unconventional romantic comedy" and that's one of the most accurate taglines I've ever seen. This movie presents itself as a romcom, but it deliberately avoids the romcom clichés. There are no emotional airport chase scenes or perfectly planned climactic monologues ending in "You had me at hello". Those movies are a lot of fun, but this is not one of them. This is a romcom at the speed of real life. Like the tagline says, this movie is unconventional. But if you're ready for anything, even a kick in the nuts or two, then this movie will be a fun watch. (In all fairness, guys, you should never sneak up on a woman who is deep in the transcendental serenity of meditation. Not without wearing a jockstrap.)
5 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Real
kblack-4028710 February 2020
I don't know what people expected but I really don't understand why there is so much hate towards this movie. It was exactly what I wanted it to be. The lead character Joanne is an extraverted, outspoken person who says and does whatever she wants. She makes people uncomfortable trom time to time and that's what makes her real. She doesn't have her life even remotely figured out. The movie shows life exactly as it is. Improvisation is the point of the whole thing. There are no great lines, suprising twists or love at first sight. It's everyday events that lead to people forming bonds with each other . I think the movie is great and you should give it a try.
10 out of 14 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Alright now, go see it
borislaman13 September 2018
This is an improvisational piece filmed in five days by Jamie Adams. Cobie Smulders plays Joanne, a 90's rock musician who enrolls in college after her band breaks up.Then fate brings her together with super sexy Peter (Richard Elis). This is a story about a girl who thinks she is everything and a man who lacks confidence coming together and finding love. Don't watch and expect a big production, this movie is like reality; stumbling people, clumsy, awkward and chaotic. All the things people criticized this movie for are actually the things that make this movie stand out and make it real. Cobie did a great job playing the rock musician. If you think she was loud and over the top, that was probably what she was aiming for, but all credits for making this movie great go to Richard for bringing sweetness and sensitivity.
17 out of 30 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Don't get why folks hated it
saffi-barham4 July 2020
Easy going, fun cast, take it all with a pinch of salt kind of humour, bit of ridiculousness, great depiction of friendship and cute. I liked it.
1 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed