"Better Call Saul" Winner (TV Episode 2018) Poster

(TV Series)

(2018)

User Reviews

Review this title
70 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
10/10
A spin-off no longer, a show that stands on its own.
fredschaefer-406-6232049 October 2018
Warning: Spoilers
I know a lot of us BREAKING BAD fans were a little dubious when it was announced that there would be a spin off series built around "criminal" lawyer, Saul Goodman. There was no way Vince Gilligan and company could duplicate the awesomeness of BREAKING BAD again, and we feared that they were diminishing the legacy by building a show around a supporting character that probably should remain a supporting character. But now, after four seasons of BETTER CALL SAUL, I am very happy to say that we were totally wrong. While I am not ready to say SAUL surpasses BB, I will say that this new series certainly equals the original in many ways, and at times, is even more engrossing. For the latter show builds on the universe created by the former, digging way deeper into the lives of Jimmy McGill (Saul Goodman), Mike Ehrmantrout, Gus Fring, and Nacho Varga, and the scams and cons, and crimes they perpetrate, as they believe they are coming out on top, all the while sinking deeper into a darkness they have become so acclimated to that they no longer notice it.

Season 4 began with the suicide of Jimmy's brother Chuck, and followed in the aftermath, as Jimmy had his license to practice law suspended and was forced to support himself with other gainful employment, which ultimately led him to manage a cellular phone store (this is the mid 2000's), where he drummed up quite a trade with the Albuquerque street criminal element. Jimmy's story this season was one con after another and a parade of utterly shameless insincerity, including a plot to steal a Hummel figure from a prospective employer that took an unexpected turn. My favorite had to be elaborate effort to win a reduced sentence for Huel Babineaux, a BB character who was not about to go back to jail; this was great writing every time, we often didn't see where things were going and we had to keep watching to find out. The long shadow of Chuck McGill's death hung over this season, as all who were touched by him, especially Howard Hamlin, were frequently reduced to tears by his memory. But not his brother Jimmy, and in episode after episode, we keep expecting him to break down at some point and acknowledge his loss and pain honestly, but thank God the writers never went for the easy way out. And right by Jimmy's side throughout all of it, is Kim Wexler, wonderfully played by Rhea Seahorn, we keep waiting for something fatal and final to end this relationship, but as the season wore on, we learn that Kim has something of a dark side of her own, that she likes the excitement of the con, the bending of rules, and the taking of big risks. Throughout this series, whenever I saw Jimmy and Kim together, I would think, "What's wrong with this picture, she could do way better than him." Thanks to Season 4, I now know why, but we also know that Kim does have her limits, she is not a criminal at heart, and will not do whatever it takes, no matter what. That seems to be the ticking time bomb in their relationship.

Season 4 was also about the journeys of Mike Ehrmantrout and Nacho Varga, the latter finding himself firmly in the clutches of Gus Fring after Gus figures out that it was Nacho who tried to kill Hector Salamanca. Poor Nacho is not a hard core gangster, he just wants to make some money and protect his father, but it is increasingly clear that if he wants to survive in this world, he will have to as bad as the worst. The most compelling story line of the season has to be that of Mike Ehrmantrout, who is clearly a Lee Marvin/Charles Bronson level bad ass, as he becomes increasingly more valuable to Gus and the cartel, the go to guy who gets things done. His bogus safety auditor scenes were priceless, but it was the back story of how Gus's underground meth lab came to be was where Mike has his best moments, as he has to ride herd on a group of German engineers brought in to secretly construct it under the laundry. Give it to the writers of BETTER CALL SAUL, to take minor detail from BB and make riveting story arc out of it. All praise to Jonathan Banks, who plays a man who may have regrets or doubts, but never, ever, lets them show.

Everything came to a head in the Season 4 finale, titled "Winner," where we get a flashback showing a rare moment of camaraderie by the McGill brothers before the episode focuses on Jimmy's quest to get reinstated before the bar, and Mike's efforts to track down the AWOL Werner, who is in danger of drawing unwanted attention to Gus's little illegal construction project. Further complicating matters is that Lalo Salamanca is nosing into Gus's business and on Mike's trail; while Jimmy has to show (or fake) real grief and contrition over Chuck's death if he wants to practice law again. This episode was one great scene after another, as Mike eluded Lalo (the parking lot scene was a series best), with both of them conning and harassing a ginger headed travel agent (who didn't come out the better for the experience), along with Mike's final confrontation with Werner, where he does what he has to do whether he likes it or not. Throughout this episode, we see Jimmy maneuvering and faking to get on the good side of the right people to ensure that his license is reinstated. We finally get a moment of honest emotion from Jimmy, but it is not tears of grief, but an honest speech to the poor girl who came in last in the competition for the Charles McGill scholarship, where we learn the true depth of Jimmy resentment is made plain. It is the bile of a man who has been looked down by this "betters" and knows it, hates it, and lives to get even. And we understand that Jimmy McGill is a man so broken that he can never imagine being whole. All praise to Bob Odenkirk for his awesome acting. By the end of this finale we know that Mike and Jimmy are now the characters we first met in BREAKING BAD. And all Kim can do is stand there and look shocked as the newly restored lawyer Jimmy makes known he wants to practice law in the future under a name not his own. "It's all good, man."

Right now, BETTER CALL SAUL is so good that it makes most of the shows on the networks and other cable channels look like high school production; a masterpiece of writing and plotting. It's a great show free of the shallow agenda driven writing of most ever shows on TV, and their diversity checked casting. And it left us wanting more in Season 5: what will happen to Nacho, we hardly noticed that he was not in the Season 4 finale; what will happen when Lalo catches on to Gus and Mike, no matter what it will not be pretty and will certainly threaten peace in the ranks of the Mexican cartel; will we ever see a true flash forward with "Gene" at Cinnebon, I increasingly think there is a big shoe waiting to drop there; most of all, what will happen with Kim and Jimmy, most of us were certain their relationship would be a casualty of Season 4, but they are still together, but we wonder how she will share Jimmy with Saul Goodman.

Back when BETTER CALL SAUL first premiered, we all wondered and hoped that maybe we would see Walter White and Jesse Pinkman again. But after four seasons, it is clear that this show does not need the presence of Bryan Cranston or Aaron Paul in their iconic parts; SAUL firmly and proudly stands on its own two feet.
484 out of 504 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
A heartbreakingly beautiful end to season 4
jackkemp-3061210 October 2018
'The winner takes it all' has never been so devastating. From the opening scene to the end, this episode played out as as inconceivably masterful episode which saw the beginning of the end of Better Call Saul. the the very beginnings of Breaking Bad established.

You will never ever see such beautiful cinematography from a show like you do in Better Call saul. I won't spoil it, however I can assure you that certain shots of this episode are beyond comprehension in how incredible they are.

An action-filled, heart-crunching episode is the best way to summarize Better Call Saul's best episode to date, and it's only going to get better.

Breaking bad had its 'never make the same mistake twice'. Better Call Saul has its 'the winner takes it all'

All I can say is thank you to the crew for everything they offered in this 60 minutes of revolutionary television
172 out of 179 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
A Heartbreakingly Perfect Ending
zenrgreen9 October 2018
NON-SPOILER REVIEW

This season concludes on a perfect note. The finale embodies everything that is great about 'Better Call Saul'. I cannot comprehend the Writing Team's ability to meticulously weave together a realistic and gritty yet beautiful and emotional story. The cinematography has evolved over the course of the show and is interstellar in this episode, especially with the 'final death scene' which was one of the most beautiful shots I have ever scene in television and film. The final scene is shocking with how decieving and cold it is, although we always knew it would happen at some point, it doesn't make it any less impactful. The Cast's acting is amazing as always with no faults, especially Odenkirk's and Banks'. In conclusion, I loved this season which was as story driven and beautiful as always along with it's terrific acting, great cinematography and natural story progression. I will miss this show for the next year. Thanks Vince, Peter and the BCS Team for creating a phenomenal experience, I cannot wait for the stories you will bring us next year.

It's all good man. 10/10
212 out of 229 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
It's all good, man...
choudhurys6819 October 2018
Perfect season finale for this series... The moment we've all been waiting for since episode 1 of season 1 has finally been shown in episode 10 of season 4, just a glimpse though but at least it'll give us all the good vibes and hopes and eagerness for the next season... Almost like Breaking Bad season 5 was all about Heisenberg and not Walter White, I'm guessing season 5 of better call Saul would be all about Saul Goodman and not Jimmy McGill... This episode, it's "All good, man"...
138 out of 150 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Can you think of a better season finale? I can't.
SeventhirtyseveN_73710 October 2018
Warning: Spoilers
What a phenomenal season finale. brings the series full circle and now Saul Goodman is officialy born. Better Call Saul has given Breaking Bad another layer of depth I didn't know was possible. This episode shows Mike in what probably was one of the worst moments in his life, having to make a decision that would change him forever, and it was absolutely tragic. Lives were ruined in this episode, more than we see happening on screen.
94 out of 102 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Brought The Season Full Circle
CajunGentleman9 October 2018
Warning: Spoilers
Ray Akapotasana... you are a troll. You rate every BCS episode you watch with 1 star, with the same exact reviews... yet you still watch it? It appears you don't have the slightest level of depth in your life if you're only topic of interest is "exciting crime". I don't know what world you live in... but life is bigger than that. I may not face a DEA bust everyday, but I battle inner demons, I struggle in close relationships, I fail my family members, I screw up my jobs, I have millions of obstacles (STILL) in my way to establish my career, and I get trapped in dumb situations that appear hopeless - and this show depicts all this (in this single episode). I mean, how is it foreign to you to see characters face REAL issues? You need depth.

This is exactly why this show measures up to Breaking Bad. BB is more entertaining (and Jesse honestly has the biggest contribution to this, just by his energy and personality). But BCS is a much deeper show. And the only people who drown in boredom haven't lived a real life. Cause this show is layered with life. All the characters are people I've known, and I root for them even more because of their realism.

I thought this finale was very compelling, and is a great setup for a break to digest the season. The Arc went full-circle better than I could have ever predicted. And Peter Gould nailed it with the final scene. Great work to the BCS team.
161 out of 178 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Saul Goodman Is Born
dougmacdonaldburr10 October 2018
This is the best episode the show has ever done. I do not want to give spoilers, all I will say is that it wraps the season up perfectly, and sets things up very well for the final season.
58 out of 62 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Probably The Best Episode Until That Point
fabrcsakai11 January 2021
Warning: Spoilers
The intro scene between Jimmy and Chuck ('Winner takes it all') was so great and heartwarming, but - unfortunately - the rest of the episode showed how this was in a distant past.

Werner Ziegler's story came to a ending in this episode. His whole character had a lot of innocence about who he was dealing with, and ended up paying the price. Obviously he'd never imagine they could think of killing him, because he was planning a few days trip and holidays with his wife before coming back to work. And the scene where Mike put a bullet in his head was so sad and tragic: the acting between these two characters was truly amazing and the highest point of the episode for me.
20 out of 20 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
The Winner loses it all
ilovemoney-1871410 October 2018
Man, we finally see the real Saul Goodman. I mean his lying is so good that he even fooled Kim (and me). He showed his real colors for the first time. There is 0 sympathy left for Chuck. I think we are going to find out why that really is in the next season. Great episode and a great ending for season 4. Now we need to wait another year for this fantastic show.
60 out of 65 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Jimmy the Jerk
Hitchcoc18 March 2020
Warning: Spoilers
We know from Breaking Bad that Jimmy McGill eventually becomes an amoral, self centered ambulance chaser. When he leaves Kim at the conclusion, we see the worst side of this man. He gives what appears to be a heartfelt speech to the selection board. It seems to be utterly sincere, but after being successful in convincing those judging by giving homage to his late brother, he starts walking around like a proud rooster. In other issues, Gus moves in on the German led engineering guys and a fatal mistake is made.
43 out of 46 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
S4: Continued great writing and characters
bob the moo9 March 2019
Season 4 picks up just after the fire at Chuck's house and follows Jimmy in his time barred from practicing law; a period in which he becomes a phone salesman officially and on the side. Meanwhile Nacho finds himself in continued danger as powerful players moved around him, and Mike takes the lead on Gus' project to build an underground facility to run cooks from. These threads all have strengths and weaknesses to them, but mostly the weaknesses are well compensated for and feel like non-issues in the main.

The thrust of the season is driven by the characters. The most obvious one of course is the titular Saul, who is more evident than ever in this season. I don't think it is about Saul Goodman being created, but more about that part of Jimmy becoming more evident to us, those around him, and to himself. The journey is delicate and very well played by Odenkirk; his performance is great, with endless understanding of his character. The delivery of the show around him only helps this with the way it is written, and the way in which flashbacks are structured to show past and future. Related to this, I felt a lot more for Kim this season, and really enjoyed how much Seehorn's performance added to the understanding of the character of Jimmy. Nacho's thread seemed much more functional than I would have liked, although it keeps the violence and drug-life in the frame. Similarly, I'm not sure Mike as a character moved too much, although our experience of him thus far maybe did; again the excavation etc project did feel much more functional than the main threads with Jimmy.

Functional or not, all the threads work very well, and as before the season is incredibly strong in the writing and performances. The technical delivery remains smart and sharp, and the whole thing has emotional weight and insight that only makes the action and style mean that much more.
25 out of 26 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Now this is tv
matthew_ditto23 February 2020
Warning: Spoilers
Better call saul is so good that it makes it hard to watch almost any other show on air. It is shot amazingly, directed amazingly, and written amazingly. Any other show would have banked on the death of chuck by having Jimmy have a melt down over it. Not this show, this show knows what they want to do with their characters and never do any cheap shots. The moment we get Jimmy having a breakdown actually made sense and fit his character. this scene might be my favorite scene in better call saul period. I cried
24 out of 25 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Two Stories. Great Story For Jimmy To Become Saul Goodman. Horrible One For Lala.
jasonbourneagain11 October 2018
Better Call Saul tries hard to not become what the fans want in Breaking Bad, but it's making its storytelling too unwieldy. First, the story of Jimmy further becoming Saul Goodman and Breaking Bad may have reached the point of no return. What Jimmy says at the end of the season 4 finale "Winner" may have foreshadowed the foregone conclusion. Is it? We still do not know for sure, but this was the farthest Jimmy has gone as Saul Goodman, lawyer. He's getting his license back with his girl friend Kim Wexler's help. Kim was really moved due to Jimmy's testimony in front of the appeals board and she was moved to tears. However, we say her shock when she hears what Jimmy had to say afterward. She was speechless. This puts their already rocky relationship back on the rocks again. Will it finally go kaput in Season 5? It sure looks that they are heading for a breakup. I can't see Kim staying with Saul Goodman.

The second story was about Lalo. Lalo's story made me think there is too much clever storytelling going on in Better Call Saul and it's stopping it from becoming another Breaking Bad series. What was incredulous is how Lalo was able to do the things that he did and not be pursued by the police. How does Lalo not end up being wanted by the police for his actions? What he did and got away with was hard to believe. First, he plows into a car and leaves it severely damaged in the street in order to not lose Mike. The victim must have called the police to give them a description of Lalo and his car. Not only that he goes into ninja mode to climb up into the ceiling, find an air duct and climb into the secure TravelWire room and kill the employee in broad daylight in mere seconds. They could not show how he did it because he would have to fly up into the ceiling and come down the other side in seconds while the employee's back was turned.

Prior to this, how does Lalo decide to follow Mike when the rest of Gus' men left in other cars? He gets extremely lucky and ends up seeing Mike talk with Gus. All this on his first day of surveillance. No wonder Saul was scared in the one Breaking Bad scene where Lalo is mentioned. Lalo is a ninja assassin who goes into stealth mode when necessary to do whatever damage and killings in order to promote his agenda.

Better Call Saul gives way to subdued action in order to promote its story telling and it is getting in the way of becoming an all-time great tv series like Breaking Bad. The shows have been up and down this season and you can put me down for this show being a enigmatic in-betweener. Season 4 turned out the same way with its up and down episodes and it may be the worst season we have had. Too much "cute" story telling is getting in the way of showing off its action.
16 out of 34 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
Nothing special. There is something really fishy about these 10 star reviews
perlshop13 October 2018
Warning: Spoilers
First of all the things happening in this episode are totally unbelievable. I mean they are so far away from reality that it really makes me want to scream at my TV. Can you really believe security at a financial institutions to be this lax? Not to mention people giving away information at the drop of a hat. I mean c'mon that just really lazy writing. Also none of the other stories don't make sense either.

The only saving grace is the cast, esp. Odenkirk but there is so much an actor can do when given such weak material to work with. Screenplay was quite terrible too. Also like previous episodes everything is stretched out without rhyme or reason just to fill the air-time.

This was such a good show. But without a story it jumped the shark this season.
18 out of 125 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Couldn't of Ended This Season on a more Perfect Note
cmstewart-111519 October 2018
Wow. I am not going to go through the episode point-by-point. I just want to say, as a whole... this was an incredible wrap to a unique season from this series. It has given us pretty much everything we could have wanted... and the last scene sticks the landing and then some.

One thing I love about the season finale's of this show is they are never cheesy cliff-hangers. It sends you off with great anticipation of what's gonna come next year in a very straightforward, organic way. But the send-off in this episode had some extra sauce on it. All your typical, unexpected turns were there (as usual) and you can see the story advancing to that inevitable collision with the BB storyline. Mike, Jimmy, Kim, Lalo, Gus... all of them advanced a great deal in this 85 minute bookend.

What a season.
95 out of 113 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
It'S a(u)ll Good man
and_mikkelsen1 May 2022
This episode was a great way to wrap up season 4, as well as being the best episode since Chicanery! Mike tracks down Werner and their scene together was very emotional! Lalo is a great edition to the cast and you really feel hos presence on screen! Jimmys character development was the best this season! In the end, we knew, along with Kim, that Jimmy McGill was gone! Better Call Saul.
18 out of 19 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Perfect episode
johansoderlund9 October 2018
There isn't much to say about this episode. Just perfectly executed with perfect amount suspense, drama and heartbreaking emotions. The whole season built up to the last few seconds of this episode and it delivered. It's all good, man.
44 out of 53 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Saul Takes It All
greggwager9 October 2018
Warning: Spoilers
An ABBA song gives us the biggest piece of the Saul puzzle yet. Otherwise, a two-part counterpoint of suspenseful procedure closes season four of Better Call Saul: 1) Saul's preparation for his appeal by "sincerely" honoring his brother; and 2) Mike's manhunt for Werner with Lalo on his tail.

The teaser of "Winner" flashes back to Jimmy first getting sworn in, Chuck by his side, and the celebration afterward at a Karaoke bar. Jimmy coaxes Chuck to sing with him "The Winner Takes It All." Chuck sings wonderfully, while Jimmy can barely hold a tune.

Chuck takes his drunk brother home and sleeps beside him. Still, the song they sang together was so perfect, they can't resist singing it again.

ABBA's song's title comes up again when Saul gives a pep talk to Christy Esposito. Christy applied for the scholarship in Chuck's name, but as a former shoplifter trying to turn her life around, can't compete with the other overachieving candidates. Saul's was her only vote, and he chases her out to the bus stop to vicariously cheer himself up, telling her to ignore the others and simply win-"because the winner takes it all." Later, when he goes to start up his clunker of a car and can't, Saul breaks down and cries real tears.

This in a nutshell is how Gilligan/Gould want to leave us with the twisted character Saul for season five. By facing Chuck's hate for him one last time and in such a big way, even donating $23K to the local college for a reading room in Chuck's name, Saul pushes himself over the line into something bad. Chuck's abilities (including singing in tune) don't matter, because in the end, Saul takes it all by outliving his brother and surviving the hate. He's a lawyer again, DBA " 's all good, man."

Kim watches in tears as Saul begins reading Chuck's posthumous letter to the appeal board, but dramatically finishes his thoughts off the cuff. Has Saul fooled Kim and the others once again or was he sincere this time? When Kim is in disbelief, she has a way of quickly blurting out, "okay." Maybe Saul was sincere, but now pretends to Kim he was faking it. Just the same, Kim is again confused with the cold heart of her man who is out to "take it all."

Gale makes another cameo. Yes, Gus built that secret lab for him, paid for with the life of Werner Ziegler.

Television gives us Perry Mason, Matlock, and a host of other unconventional, slick lawyers doing their best for their imperfect clients. Still, Better Call Saul is different. The pursuit of winning and taking it all creates a monster, Saul Goodman. When does competing with each other build character and when does it make us simply cold-hearted and indifferent to cruelty and crime?

Thanks to Howard, Jimmy shared the nickname "Charlie Hustle" with Pete Rose. By any other name, including "Saul Goodman," it would now smell...well, just smell.
38 out of 47 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Raw emotion
Leofwine_draca7 December 2021
Warning: Spoilers
I was expecting this to be a fine episode and it didn't disappoint me. No huge or surprising events here, just scene after scene of raw and intense emotion conveyed in a subtle and realistic way. Really looking forward to season five of this show which is becoming a good rival to BREAKING BAD in terms of sheer consistent quality.
17 out of 20 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Arguably the best episode of the series!!
odderr24 July 2022
Warning: Spoilers
The writing is just top class.

The opening with brothers is beautiful.

Jimmy talking to her and breaking down in car - heart breaking.

Mike killing werner.. man.

Jimmy reading letter and fooling all..perfect.

It's all good man - perfect ending to the season and beginning of saul.

Such a flawless series with great writing and cinematography.
10 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
One of The Best Episodes in the show
Ammn9 October 2018
Warning: Spoilers
This is what I have been waiting for this season as much as we hate Chuck I think he is missed this season. Perfect pace episode directed by Adam Bernstein who directed Five-O. Well written, and Great acting especially Bob Odenkirk. Damn! the speech at the end he had me I believed him I didn't expect he was acting it but I should've seen it I mean it's Saul Goodman! Even Kim is shocked oh man the look in her face is sad to see you know she gave up on Jimmy the last shot where the camera fad away from her says it all. These shots is why I love BB and BCS so much. one shot says a lot it speaks by it self. This probably why some people hate on the show because the don't get it and they aren't paying attention to the details

Mike and Werner part is sad an cold. I can't believe I'm saying this but The kill shot is so beautiful.

There is a lot to hype for next season. Lalo Salamanca is badass going to make a lot of trouble good actor too maybe because him will see Hank?

We will probably see Kim end her relationship with Jimmy and the show I think. We will finally see Saul Goodman officially maybe will know about Cinnabon story? Can't wait..I hope for no delay.
32 out of 42 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Saul Goodman is born
gedikreverdi1 November 2021
Warning: Spoilers
That scene where Mike shoots Werner up in the hills under the stars when we only get to see their silhouettes from afar, well that's what makes this show amazing. And he's a lawyer again but he's not gonna use the name McGill. Kim is disappointed by his lack of emotion towards his late brother as she was the one who wept in court while he's speaking about Chuck. Gustavo already found his man to cook meth. I'm curious what will happen to the excavation workers.
4 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Season Four
zkonedog4 July 2019
Warning: Spoilers
After the second season of "Better Call Saul" aired, I criticized it a bit for being too slow (even for Vince Gilligan's standards). A tremendous third season put that worry out of my mind. With this fourth season, however, the show again treads the line (and I'd argue crosses it considerably) of being far too slow and ponderous.

I realize that Gilligan and Co. have a really tough job to do here in crafting a prequel to a show ("Breaking Bad") that many consider to be the greatest of all-time. So, they are going to get some criticism no matter which choices they make. However, I wonder if the renewal of the show by AMC for TWO more seasons (this one and a fifth) turned this one into somewhat of a "treading water" campaign as the writers/producers position all the pieces towards the endgame.

There are two main plot lines this season examines:

First, and probably most importantly, is Jimmy's (Bob Odenkirk) "grief" (or lack thereof) over brother Chuck's (Michael McKean) death. Though Kim (Rhea Seehorn) tries to get Jimmy to open up during his one-year suspension from the law, Jimmy isn't having it, content to completely shut Chuck out from his thoughts and continue to "hustle" (now mucking around in the cell phone business) until he can get his law license back.

Simultaneously, Gus (Giancarlo Esposito) is starting construction on his underground super meth lab, and Mike (Jonathan Banks) is overseeing the process. Of course, things don't quite go as planned (when do they ever in the criminal underworld?!) and hard choices must be made. At the same time, Gus continuously deals with intrusions from the Salamanca family, which puts Nacho (Michael Mando) in some really tough positions.

Here are the two main problems I had with this installment of episodes:

1. The meth lab construction plot feels reallllllly drawn out and, even worse, never does resolve itself fittingly. Gus (and Mike, by associate) were used in much better capacities in season three. Even Nacho is set up with a great angle at the beginning of this season, and then just sort of fizzles out as it goes along. Perhaps BCS isn't as good of a match for the "deep cartel stuff" as BB was.

2. For most of this show, it seems to be set up that the conflict between Kim and Jimmy will always come down to her wanting to be a serious lawyer and him content with being more of a huckster. They turn those characterizations on their heads in S4, and not to a great result, as it feels like kind of a bait-and-switch. As a character, Kim does/says things in the final few episodes here that seem completely out of place considering everything we've seen of her previously.

The bottom line for S4 of BCS is this: The heart of this show will always be Jimmy/Saul, and they play the long game with that here. This entire season, fans are looking for him to reconcile Chuck's death, and Vince Gilligan stubbornly refuses to trod that path until the finale, where even then viewers are thrown for a bit of a loop. I'd argue that this long approach makes the show feel bloated and not nearly as on-point as S1-3. Couple this with the auxiliary angles (Gus, Nacho, Mike) falling extremely flat, and that's not a great recipe for success.

Now, by no means am I ready to give up on BCS. Even at its worst (this season) it is still very watchable (hence the 3-star rating). I'm hoping that the upcoming fifth season (almost surely the last) will once again find that sense of urgency in rounding Jimmy/Saul's story full circle.
19 out of 48 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Way way way overrated!
hpcmakeup4 September 2021
BCS is slow! The characters are fine. This show is not a 10! It's not even a 9 or an 8...maybe at best a 7! If Breaking Bad is a 10 this show is So slow and filled with boring courtroom scenes it's more what your grandma would like. Fake paid reviews giving constant 10s.
5 out of 61 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
An error has occured. Please try again.

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed