"Vanity Fair" Miss Sharp in the Presence of the Enemy (TV Episode 2018) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
3 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
The Story of a Survivor: Miss Rebecca Sharp
lavatch26 December 2018
Warning: Spoilers
The opening episode of this film version of William Makepeace Thackeray's beloved novel "Vanity Fair" portrays Miss Rebecca "Becky" Sharp more as a survivor of the rigid British class system than as a greedy social climber.

The feisty and strong-willed Miss Sharp stands up to the stuffy headmistress of her school and loses her job as a French instructor. As the unfortunate orphan and daughter of an art instructor and a French danseuse, Miss Sharp is determined to defy the odds against social class in an unforgiving classist world. She is then shunted off to the thankless job of governess at the Queen's estate of Sir Pit Crawley.

This episode focuses on an important interlude for Miss Sharp when she spends a week at the home of her dear schoolmate Amelia "Emmy" Sedley. It is there that Miss Sharp encounters a coterie of young, eligible bachelors. The young men include Emmy's beau George Osborne, to whom she has an instant attraction, despite his utter contempt for her. Then, there is Emmy's brother Jos Sedly, whom his father describes as a "lazy loafer" with a thankless administrative post in India. Finally, there is the dashing soldier Dobbin, the true gentleman with an earnest attraction to and admiration for Miss Sharp. During Miss Sharp's stay, her daring is apparent with her willingness to sample the hot curry dish and to embark on a ride in a hot air balloon.

In the long scene at the Vauxhall Pleasure Gardens, Jos is about to propose to Miss Sharp. But he becomes inebriated on "rack punch" and embarrasses himself in what nearly becomes a drunken brawl. After sleeping off his stupor, he decides not to propose. The cruelest line of the episode is that of George Osborne, who give a brutal sendoff to Miss Sharp as she is leaving the Sedley home: "Better luck in the next life."

The strength of the opening program is the nuanced performance of the actress playing Miss Sharp. This is not a one-dimensional character, but someone with strength of character and the virtues recognized by her friend Emmy. Miss Sharp has been drilled in knowing her station in life. But she refuses to accept any social limitations.

The episode closes with the arrival of Miss Sharp at the Queen's Estate of Sir Pit Crawley. She is assigned a cold room in the foreboding manor house. Her only comfort is the arrival of a dashing soldier the following morning. Sir Pit and his formidable dog Gorper reflect an aura of menace.

The indomitable spirit of Miss Sharp is apparent in her memorable line to Becky, "I just want to make sure that tomorrow is better than today...every day." But the real "enemy" of the title of this episode is the strict class system of Great Britain.
6 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
Miss Sharp in the Presence of the Enemy
Prismark107 October 2018
Some people mistake Vanity Fair as one of these chocolate box Victorian classic romances. It is in fact a long, satirical dark edged story with no heroine and an unreliable narrator.

It is ripe for a modernist remake. The only problem is, I kept thinking that we just had a television adaptation recently. In fact the BBC serialised the novel both in the 1980s and 1990s. There was a film version in 2004 with Reese Witherspoon.

Olivia Cooke is spiky from the get go as the amoral social climber Becky Sharpe. In the first episode she has no desire to be a lowly nanny. She hooks up with friend Amelia, Becky stays in Amelai's family's house and desires her brother who is visiting from India. She plans to woo him because he is wealthy. Certainly not for his looks or brains as he is deficient in both those departments.

However others see through Becky's intentions and want to get rid of this upstart.

Michael Palin plays the author Thackeray. I presume he is the jovial but unreliable narrator.

ITV had high hopes that Vanity Fair would bring in the Downton Abbey audience was enjoy a period drama. It was pulverised by the BBC's Bodyguard in the ratings.

It is not bad, it did look a bit cheap in places with the green screen. It was also sluggish in its pacing. That is because it is an eight part series and I did feel the opening episode slowed down somewhat.
5 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
Dreadful adaptation
jameslinham5 September 2018
This whole production simply looks cheap. From the oversaturated colours to the haphazard editing this made me feel I had mistakenly watched an 80's video adaptation. Very poor indeed.
0 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed