Rebecca is about to go on the three dates individually with Josh, Nathaniel and Greg, the three men vying for her ultimate affections, she promising to make her choice between the three after the dates by next Thursday, Valentine's Day. An exasperated Dr. Akopian gives her okay to the idea within certain parameters. Acting as the mediator, White Josh sets some ground rules for the dates, so as not to give any of the three an unfair inherent advantage. Within the rules, Greg feels the most lost in not being good at anything he feels is contrived. But guessing that his competitors will be going all out, Greg gets sucked into trying to find his advantage within the situation. Meanwhile, the rest of their mutual friends, led by the girl group, end up having a stake in what happens in Rebecca's love life and thus how each of the three dates goes. Meanwhile, Paula, settled into life in her new job, still feels that she can excel in being both a lawyer and a mom and wife. She needing to sign up for a duty among those listed for Tommy's baseball banquet may demonstrate if Paula can be all things to all people, which in turn potentially affects one of the dates.
—Huggo