- Dr. Joshua Hensley: I gave both those women exactly what they wanted.
- Olivia Benson: No, you conned them into believing that... that's what they wanted. And like any good con man, you've convinced yourself that your victims got what they deserved. You are done, Doctor. You're done.
- Olivia Benson: [to Kitty] We spoke with Dr. Hensley's receptionist and there's no record of any appointment.
- Kitty Bennett: What are you saying, that I made this up?
- Olivia Benson: I'm just trying to understand what really happened.
- Kitty Bennett: I mean, look, I'm not like some choir girl. I've made some bad decisions in my life, but that is why he thought he could get away with this. And you know something? You're proving him right.
- Olivia Benson: So, Kitty, I know that it doesn't feel like it, but you're strong, and you're gonna get through this.
- Kitty Bennett: Well, a judge can't make me keep it.
- Olivia Benson: No, of course not.
- Kitty Bennett: Good, 'cause if Dr. Hensley tries to stop me from getting an abortion...
- Olivia Benson: Listen, even if he is the father, he has no right to do that.
- Kitty Bennett: Good, 'cause I could never love a baby who was conceived by a monster. You don't think I should keep it?
- Olivia Benson: You know, whatever whatever you decide.
- Kitty Bennett: What would you do?
- Olivia Benson: If it was me... you know, I'm... I'm... um, It's hard for me to be objective. But I think that you're raw right now, and with some distance, you'll realize that that this baby is half yours. And no matter what happened to you, he or she, it's not their fault.
- Kitty Bennett: All right, and if I wait and it's too late to do anything...
- Olivia Benson: Yeah, but that's why maybe, maybe you should talk to someone.
- Kitty Bennett: Another psychologist? No, thank you. I mean, as soon as these labs come back, I'm going right to the clinic. I'm getting rid of this thing.
- Lana Stallworth: [to Kitty] Go ahead and kill him! I know you're telling the truth! I know that Josh raped you!
- Kitty Bennett: Oh, God, how dare you?
- Lana Stallworth: No, please! Listen to me. You said those exact same words to me! Remember, Josh? The first time we had sex after you raped me.
- Amanda Rollins: [to Kitty about Dr. Hensley] How did you know he was getting married today?
- Kitty Bennett: Instagram. I started to look at his photos. I know that it's crazy, right?
- Olivia Benson: Well, it's normal to be curious after something like this happens.
- Kitty Bennett: I mean, I never thought that the police would be getting involved.
- Olivia Benson: But you did want people to know that he had raped you.
- Kitty Bennett: I guess I wanted him to be punished. You know, to be humiliated like I was.
- Kitty Bennett: I had this doll when I was five, Penelope. She came with a bottle and a diaper. My imaginary husband was this handsome prince named Sebastian. I never thought that my baby's father would be a man who raped me.
- Kitty Bennett: [as she holds a piece of broken glass to Dr. Hensley's neck] Listen, you come any closer to me and I'm just gonna do it.
- Amanda Rollins: And then I'll have to shoot you.
- Olivia Benson: [to Lana] When did you and Josh first meet?
- Lana Stallworth: Josh was my therapist, but it wasn't like that. We didn't start seeing each other until after I stopped seeing him professionally. I'm a real estate broker. Josh reached out to me when he started looking for a loft in Manhattan.
- Olivia Benson: Uh-huh. And that's when you two started spending time together?
- Lana Stallworth: I was going out with another guy at the time and he convinced me to break it off.
- Olivia Benson: Is that what you wanted?
- Lana Stallworth: Josh has always been really good to me. Josh taught me about classical music, and Russian novels. He took me to art galleries and museums.
- Olivia Benson: Are those things that you like to do?
- Lana Stallworth: Josh makes all the decisions.
- Olivia Benson: Like... like what?
- Lana Stallworth: Like, in the bedroom. He likes to be dominant.
- Olivia Benson: Is that is that what you like?
- Lana Stallworth: Sure
- Dr. Joshua Hensley: I cannot believe that I am here with a detective on my wedding day. What's this woman's name?
- Dominick Carisi: Kitty Bennett.
- Dr. Joshua Hensley: I have no idea who that is.
- Dominick Carisi: So this is a case of mistaken identity?
- Dr. Joshua Hensley: I don't know, but I sure as hell didn't rape her.
- Olivia Benson: I mean, Kitty is exhibiting all the guilt and the self-loathing typical of rape victims.
- Dominick Carisi: Yeah, and Hensley swears that he never saw her in his life.
- Olivia Benson: Do you believe him, Carisi?
- Dominick Carisi: I mean, he's adamant, I'll give him that.
- Amanda Rollins: Well, so far, Kitty's story checks out. Dr. Hensley did post a photo of his rehearsal dinner on his Instagram page.
- Olivia Benson: So, can we confirm this therapy appointment in December?
- Dominick Carisi: Chelsea Medical opens up at 7:00 a.m. on Monday.
- Olivia Benson: Perfect.
- Amanda Rollins: Was Dr. Hensley ever inappropriate with you?
- Hannah Berkowitz: Inappropriate how?
- Amanda Rollins: Like, did he come onto you?
- Hannah Berkowitz: I'm gay. I came out two years ago. Dr. Hensley was the one who helped me feel comfortable with my sexuality. Is he in some kind of trouble?
- Dominick Carisi: Um, one of his female patients may have had some issues.
- Hannah Berkowitz: Wait a minute. Is her name Kitty Bennett?
- Amanda Rollins: You know her?
- Hannah Berkowitz: Not in real life, but she stalked me on Instagram. I left a comment on one of Dr. Hensley's photos, and she followed me after that. Then came the private messages.
- Amanda Rollins: And what were those messages about?
- Hannah Berkowitz: She kept insisting that we get coffee to talk trash about Dr. Hensley.
- Dominick Carisi: But you never met up with her?
- Hannah Berkowitz: I don't even talk to my best friend about my therapy. I'm not about to spill my guts to some rando, especially about someone who pretty much saved my life.
- Dominick Carisi: So that's the only contact you had with Kitty?
- Hannah Berkowitz: Well, I made the mistake of replying to her first message. She took that as an invitation to write me every day for, like, a month. I finally had to block her. That chick is straight-up psycho.
- Amanda Rollins: [trying to verify Kitty's story] Did you catch the name of Hensley's next appointment that day?
- Dominick Carisi: Hannah Berkowitz. Clocked the phone number, too.
- Amanda Rollins: Okay, good. So if Kitty was here, maybe Hannah saw her leave.
- Dr. Joshua Hensley: Ugh, what now?
- Dominick Carisi: Bad news, Doc. Paternity test came back, and you're it.
- Lana Stallworth: God.
- Dr. Joshua Hensley: There must be some mistake here.
- Amanda Rollins: DNA doesn't lie.
- Dr. Joshua Hensley: Lana, listen to me. I did not rape that woman.
- Lana Stallworth: Shut up! Just shut up! For once in your life, just shut up!
- Dominick Carisi: [handcuffing him] I'm with Lana on this one. Put your hands behind your back.
- Dr. Joshua Hensley: I didn't rape Kitty.
- Olivia Benson: So how else do you explain her being pregnant with your unborn child?
- Dr. Joshua Hensley: I lied about one thing.
- Olivia Benson: Oh, only one.
- Dr. Joshua Hensley: Okay, more than one. But Kitty and I, we had consensual sex three times before I ended it. I couldn't admit it before...
- Olivia Benson: Only after the DNA came back.
- Dr. Joshua Hensley: She accused me of rape in front of my entire family.
- Olivia Benson: You are very convincing. And I don't believe a word that comes out of your mouth.
- Dr. Joshua Hensley: Will you at least just hear me out?
- Olivia Benson: [shrugging] What do you got?
- Dr. Joshua Hensley: Kitty was never my patient, okay? We met at a bar around the corner from where she lives.
- Olivia Benson: Okay, does this bar have a name?
- Dr. Joshua Hensley: Yeah, it's the Empty Room. It's on 20th between Ninth and Tenth. It's a block from Kitty's apartment.
- Amanda Rollins: [watching with Carisi] So much for not cheating on Lana.
- Dominick Carisi: Yeah, I'll give him an "A" for creativity.
- Amanda Rollins: Hey, how'd it go with Lana today?
- Olivia Benson: Oh, she is a mess. This Josh Hensley guy is really doing a number on her.
- Amanda Rollins: She's still defending him?
- Olivia Benson: Oh, it gets better. You ready for this? He was her therapist.
- Amanda Rollins: What?
- Olivia Benson: Yes. I mean, she says that they didn't start dating until after she stopped seeing him.
- Amanda Rollins: But by then he knows exactly what makes her tick.
- Olivia Benson: And how to manipulate her.
- Amanda Rollins: Right.
- Olivia Benson: His power over her is almost pathological. I'm starting to think that Kitty actually told us the truth about what happened in that office.
- Amanda Rollins: Go back and sleep with your rapist. We've seen it before.
- Bo Albrecht: Kitty Bennett? She's accusing me of something? Because you know she's looney tunes, right?
- Dominick Carisi: Uh, you were going out with her?
- Bo Albrecht: I met her one time at a cooking class. I mentioned I liked her soufflé. Next thing I know, she's blowing up my Facebook Messenger.
- Amanda Rollins: Okay, but was there some flirtation going on between you two?
- Bo Albrecht: I was just trying to be nice. Then she found out I was a trainer, started sending me daily exercise videos of herself in these sexy gym outfits. Well, that's when I told her I had a girlfriend.
- Dominick Carisi: I'm guessing that didn't go too well.
- Bo Albrecht: She accused me of leading her on, so I blocked her. That only added fuel to the fire.
- Amanda Rollins: She didn't stop harasssing you?
- Bo Albrecht: Not me, my girlfriend. Kitty found out that Megan waited tables at the Red Cat. She showed up during one of Megan's shifts, told her I was hitting on her. That's when I took her to court and got a restraining order.
- Kitty Bennett: Did you arrest Dr. Hensley yet?
- Olivia Benson: Well, there are a few things that we need to clear up first.
- Kitty Bennett: Like what?
- Olivia Benson: Well, we spoke to a few people that you've been in contact with. Uh, virtual strangers, really. And from what I understand, you've engaged in some behavior that might be considered stalking.
- Priest: Marriage is to be entered into reverently, deliberately, in accordance with the purpose for which it was instituted by God. If anyone assembled has just cause why this man and this woman should not be joined together, speak now or forever hold your peace.
- Kitty Bennett: [standing up] I do. And I have a good reason.
- Lana Stallworth: Josh, who is that?
- Kitty Bennett: Dr. Hensley raped me.
- Dominick Carisi: Excuse me, Father.
- Priest: I-I didn't know what else to do.
- Olivia Benson: Well, you did the right thing by calling us.
- Priest: Everyone's inside. But I have to tell you, it's not pretty.
- Amanda Rollins: [to Olivia] You okay?
- Olivia Benson: Sure.
- Amanda Rollins: Kitty is not your mom.
- Olivia Benson: Well, she might as well be. When I was 15 years old, I overheard her on the phone talking to someone. And I heard her say, "How could I love someone that was conceived by a monster?" That's exactly what what Kitty said to me.
- Kitty Bennett: [to Olivia] Yeah, I mean, I've been seeing the therapist you recommended. She's really helping me already.
- Olivia Benson: Very glad to hear that. You know, you've been through a lot.
- Kitty Bennett: I mean, I still have a lot of work to do. I haven't decided what I'm gonna do about this baby. I mean, I thought for sure I was gonna get an abortion.
- Olivia Benson: And now?
- Kitty Bennett: I felt the baby kick this morning. It really reminded me of what you said, you know, what happened to me is not this baby's fault.
- Olivia Benson: That doesn't mean that it's not gonna be hard. You know, I've known women in your exact position who have decided to raise their daughter or their son. And some days, they don't even think about it, and other days... you know, even though your baby was conceived in an act of violence, your baby is innocent and deserves to be unconditionally loved. Promise me that if you decide to become a mother that you'll remember that.
- Kitty Bennett: I will.
- Amanda Rollins: I tracked down three of Dr. Hensley's other female patients. They had nothing but nice things to say about him.
- Dominick Carisi: Well, meanwhile, Kitty Bennett's got more than her fair share of run-ins with the law. Got disorderly conduct, a few shoplifting arrests, and my personal favorite: restraining order.