User Reviews

This episode is really hard. More than I expected.. it is interesting to see where the series is going. I love it!

Following Shane's accident, Karen agonises over the unenviable decision whether to tell Ed, isolated and alone on the moon. Another fabulous performance by Shantel VanSanten as Karen who flips from stiff upper lip to weeping to organising busy-work.

A heartrending episode.

The personal and the professional are forever linked, as they are both driving factors for the future. For both to become so compromised by reality, so hurt by factors completely out of one's control, leaves this sense of weight that previous episodes only hinted at, but finally it comes in full force now. Shane's deteriorating health, and pairing it against the deterioration of the Jamestown base as the Russians start to slowly infiltrate the edges, is that previously mentioned link. It's the hardened world on those edges starting to seep into the idealism that For All Mankind wears proudly, where goodness doesn't always prevail. Shantel VanSanten is exceptional throughout, managing to hold back the influx of emotion and saying so much with Karen from that mask she puts over her feelings, over her own well-being, to keep everything on the level. Even after the second opinion, Karen refuses to let her emotions get the better of her, only breaking down when telling Ed the truth. The way she goes through the paperwork, already planning Shane's funeral, is another coping mechanism, this idea of keeping busy and refusing to stay still and allow her thoughts to get in her way.

Another powerhouse of the episode is Sarah Jones, Tracy becoming the rock for Karen under such trying times. There's a quiet ferocity to the way Tracy protects Karen, and how she's willing to be the softer touch while Karen goes through the phases of grief before our eyes. It's a moment that comes as a choice for emotion over practical, when the rest of the episode is directly in the opposite mode. Perhaps her father will be a push in the right direction, as his watchful eye takes in more than he lets on.

I love that this show focuses on several strong female characters. We need more shows like this.

This show has felt mostly hollow to this point. Most Apple TV series, for some reason, take quite a while to grab you with something to care about.

While I don't particularly care for Ed or Karen or really anyone else on the show, this episode really brings home the practical drama and pain of distance when it comes to loved ones. The feeling of helplessness and the guilt of pursuing one's own ambitions at the expense of everything else.

The show had more superficial examples of these dichotomies, but it needed something somber and shattering to really drive it home. This episode reminds me of the movie First Man, which is, in my opinion, one of the greatest astronaut biopics ever made.

Another great episode this one is a total heartbreaker. A bit too long however. If they could edit all of these down to 45 minutes it would be excellent.

But It's sad that don't feel one drop of sympathy for that disgusting woman. For Ed? Yes.

I understand people handle grief differently.

But she's like that ALL THE TIME.

Ick, if only she could have died, (she's a fictional character) instead of her son.

Here's to hoping mom/Karen hops on a bicycle soon.

Fantastic series marred by a storyline that lays on the maudlin misery thick and fast, and then lays on more of the same. You could distil this one down to five minutes for the key points that move the plot along. A real let-down.

The writers got bored with their own premise. The writers can't find enough legitimate drama in the space premise, so they start inventing this absurd melodrama all over the place. This is little better than a daytime soap. Hey! What if an astronaut has a long lost twin? And that twin was raised in RUSSIA and he's a COSMONAUT. Oh, and then we can do an amnesia plot, everyone loves those.

The premise is solid, and they just fowl it up with this bad and overworn melodrama. It's like if Mad Men lost half it's IQ. If not more.