When there is a lot of material and work on the story and the script, it seems that the use of the film has not been fully decided. Sometimes in a hurry, sometimes slow. Despite everything, Ali Atay should be watched for cinema and dark comedy.
60 Reviews
A different movie for Turkey
Braveheart6711 November 2019
Another Ali Atay Movie
karakus29 October 2019
I didnt expect this movie to top previous Ali Atay movie, "Ölümlü Dünya" but it exceeded all my expectations. No forced jokes, no unrealistic characters, everthing feels so real. Ali Atay proves that the first movie was no coincidence. The message at the end was also pretty neat.
Splendid job but...
Lilyum_6 November 2019
Brilliantly funny movie like the previous movie of the director, if only there was a little less sexual talking... It felt really awkward watching some scenes with my family together. Accept that, i hope we see more of his humor in theaters.
Fun-time cops forever
albertriera25 October 2019
Open your mind
fethiyesilver-220664 November 2019
I have seen like really serious comments for this really funny movie. Guys please calm down and chill. It's as you can see just a comedy. Do comedies always follow the real life and perfect mentality? I don't think so. I love it especially Cengiz Bozkurt is -in a word l-amazing. I cried when I was laughing. Soundtrack also amazing! Go on Ali Atay and every single person who support or contribute this. I might be a little bit emotional because of this negative comments but only reason is I really like this movie and couldn't believe all those comments
Too Uneven
waigo75 November 2019
Warning: Spoilers
Ölümlü Dünya was an ambitious work and worked very well despite some wrong turns because mainly it has so much energy in it. It is probably due to actors' performances and action part.
Now considering this movie, it is still an unusual piece for Turkish cinema but i don't think it works well as Ali Atay's previous film. We can definitely feel his ambition regarding cinematography, score, sense of realism. However, all those parts should be supplementary to the script and characters so the film would be great which cannot be said for this movie. Comparing with Ölümlü Dünya again, there are less striking characters in this movie and some pacing problems really dragged me off from the film's ambience. Script had a simple but effective premise, serial killer in Turkey. It is sometimes a conversation matter because the issue is so alien to Turkey and it would be am interesting thing to think on just like Turks in space, however the serious aspects of this script and highly verbal humour of the writing crew had trouble balancing each other at the first half of the film and realism gave its seat to comedy completely at the second half. The on the nose resolutiom of the film tried to help balance again and summatize the whole mess but its execution was a little bit flat.
I want to be supportive and dwell on the good notes but the director and his new writing buddies need to do more to get a better developed script. Dialogues are superb, charachters work most of the time but events need some work.
Now considering this movie, it is still an unusual piece for Turkish cinema but i don't think it works well as Ali Atay's previous film. We can definitely feel his ambition regarding cinematography, score, sense of realism. However, all those parts should be supplementary to the script and characters so the film would be great which cannot be said for this movie. Comparing with Ölümlü Dünya again, there are less striking characters in this movie and some pacing problems really dragged me off from the film's ambience. Script had a simple but effective premise, serial killer in Turkey. It is sometimes a conversation matter because the issue is so alien to Turkey and it would be am interesting thing to think on just like Turks in space, however the serious aspects of this script and highly verbal humour of the writing crew had trouble balancing each other at the first half of the film and realism gave its seat to comedy completely at the second half. The on the nose resolutiom of the film tried to help balance again and summatize the whole mess but its execution was a little bit flat.
I want to be supportive and dwell on the good notes but the director and his new writing buddies need to do more to get a better developed script. Dialogues are superb, charachters work most of the time but events need some work.
Good work excellent comedy
zorzobit26 October 2019
After the "Ölumlu Dünya" my expectations was prety high before i saw this movie. Now Ali Atay raised this level up. He has directed story on the base of popular crime movies but most of the scenes has a refer to absurd detective stories except the message at the end . Cengiz Bozkurt aka "Erdal Bakkal" was perfect as tired detective who leads the humour all the way. Billingsgate seems like the bad part but be sure it is not stilted at all. Besides it completes the spirit of Atay's sense of humor like "Kutu Kola". Feyyaz Yigit and Binnur Kaya was a great couple and wierd lovers. I can't wait the next job of Atay.
NOT SO MUCH FUN
KeremUlucay21 January 2020
Cinayet Susu is worse than Ali Atay's previous film: Olumlu Dunya. I want to compare them because they are both made by same people, they both are crime-comedies, they both are about a group of people. This ones cinematography and production design is better. But that's it. There is no such developed characters. There are just some guys who are trying to be funny, making humor and leaving the curtain. Story has something to tell, there is an idea behind all that comedy but that idea just comes at the finale and until that sequence you see nothing valuable. On the other hand, there is a scene which is incredibly funny: Chat sequence. It is on YouTube and I watched it like a hundred times after I saw the movie. It is awesome.
There's a problem with the storytelling of the film
Hugnettin30 October 2019
When you first look at the cast, you keep your expectations high. However, the scenario is not successful. They tried to build the film through the dialogue of several actors. Too much swearing. Most of them are unnecessary.
There is no striking effect in the final because the scenario of the flow is weak. You cut the expectation of the final.
I think the interrogation scene is the best in the movie. A double-sided mirror joke was also very good.
It was under mediocre when it could be better...
An excellent movie
ahmetdundaredu10 May 2020
Yes, it's not the best movie but
mehtap_neside6 May 2020
Warning: Spoilers
It's so damn funny ! Didn't you see ? Yeah maybe swearing little too much but its acceptable. The characters are not really deep maybe acting could be more better but it's a comedy movie. It's all about the situation.There are serial killings and there are cops who ruined the job. They couldn't solve really anything, they couldn't catch him. They screwed. And the screwing is the funny part but in the final is actually a sad part. It's a good writing and it's really promising. It'a good comedy. Take easy on it.
Disappointment :(:( (for me)
meliherdogan-6021711 November 2019
Unfortunately I expect more than that. Clearly it was not sure what about to tell us all.
Seems classical saying "overrated" for me! so I watched first cinema film by this team I expect more and more. But you can enjoy without expectation. ///Please don't swearing a lot like that . It make you seems camply. And it wasn't funny too this time
Great comedy
bcan-4489919 June 2021
Very funny and fun
Orhan_Akdeniz15 November 2019
Best comedy of YEAR
juramentalo2 November 2019
A fun movie to watch but something is missing
arhanandic10 May 2021
I don't know why but I feel like something is missing with this movie. It's an entartaining movie overall, but... I tink the right word to use here is anticlimactic, but I'm just not sure.
At least I laughed and that's what I expect from a good comedy movie. That is definitely not a family movie, I want to warn you about that.
At least I laughed and that's what I expect from a good comedy movie. That is definitely not a family movie, I want to warn you about that.
Way more funnier than I expected
morrgoth-7086325 October 2019
I saw a trailer for this movie on Youtube and decided to watch it. This movie is way more funnier than a similar movie by the same director " Ölümlü Dünya". I think that the director has really improved himself. Acting and visual comedy elements were great. Everyone watching the film at the cinema laughed a good amount of times.
not boring but could be better
puren_kilinc-893299 May 2020
After Ölümlü Dünya, of course expectations are getting higher. There are so much swearing and absurd sexual jokes but it gets a laugh anyway. Final was so powerful that it causes to forget the rest of the movie. Feyyaz Yigit and Cengiz Bozkurt's role are as same as their other roles, it's kinda boring.
Waste of time
berkkurtel10 June 2020
Turkish homour
halukyalman3 May 2020
Terrible
hantirboy29 October 2019
The movie is a big joke itself. Didn't go to see it with extraordinary expectations yet it wasn't capable to fulfill anything at all. Awkward conversations were supposed to be funny unfortunately they were not even close to trigger a giggle. Ali Atay tries to make absurd comedy movies but he can only catch the absurd side of it. Big local stars are wasted in this garbage, especially Ugur Yücel couldn't get any chance to show his acting skills. Waste of money and time. Plot would be interesting if it was processed better with creative dialogues.
You will laugh like crazy
Nebosh26 October 2019
The movie is exactly like how a comedy movie supposed to be. Without a doubt it is funny. The ending is so satisfying. The scenario is very well-written in terms of misery and crime solving but it also manages to be extremely funny. I highly recommend
Love it.
ssprsstar-912-94055028 January 2020
its boring as hell
wasleJohn9 November 2019
See also
Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews
