I saw the sneak preview of this the Sunday before the film opened.
The short review: Ray Romano ruins this film.
The long review: Where "Mooseport" shines is in the casting of all but one lead role. That glaring exception is one of the most grating and unfunny TV stars working today: Ray Romano. I find it hard to sit through an entire episode of his show "Everybody Loves Raymond," which have turned into nothing more than 30 minutes of Romano whining. Now, multiply that torture by three. Here, Romano whines for 90 solid minutes. This is one of the two critical flaws with the film -- flaws so severe that it is impossible to suspend even a modicum of disbelief. Romano gains no sympathy, and his neurotic character (very similar to his TV persona) depends on sympathy from the audience to be believable. He is so annoying, he doesn't come close to winning us over.
There is also a fatal story flaw in the last act. I won't spoil it for you, but when they start announcing the final votes, do the math. You'll see there is a mistake that the screenwriters, director, editors and studio completely missed. In its current form, that story flaw actually ground the film to a halt for me as I counted and recounted their math in my head, oblivious to what was happening on the screen. As the characters continued to wind the story down, I wanted to yell, "STOP! You've done the math wrong. The story doesn't make any sense now." Maybe it's just me, but those kinds of things really throw me.
When Romano's bumbling plumber "Handy" isn't wasting our time (will he finally commit to his girlfriend?, will he win the election?), the rest of the film is quite solid. Strong support comes from Marcia Gay Harden, Maura Tierney, Fred Savage, Rip Torn, and even Christine Baranski (who comes off terribly in the trailer). But it is a bit unnerving to watch 74-year-old Hackman woo Tierney, who at age 38 is nearly half his age.
Overall the film is only mildly amusing. That is thanks to the life (and laugh) sucking presence of Ray Romano. There is one genuine laugh-out-loud moment -- it features Hackman, Tierney and a horde of news crews at her front doorstep -- which, thankfully, is not given away in the commercials.
The film would have worked better if Hackman's character was less likable.
The short review: Ray Romano ruins this film.
The long review: Where "Mooseport" shines is in the casting of all but one lead role. That glaring exception is one of the most grating and unfunny TV stars working today: Ray Romano. I find it hard to sit through an entire episode of his show "Everybody Loves Raymond," which have turned into nothing more than 30 minutes of Romano whining. Now, multiply that torture by three. Here, Romano whines for 90 solid minutes. This is one of the two critical flaws with the film -- flaws so severe that it is impossible to suspend even a modicum of disbelief. Romano gains no sympathy, and his neurotic character (very similar to his TV persona) depends on sympathy from the audience to be believable. He is so annoying, he doesn't come close to winning us over.
There is also a fatal story flaw in the last act. I won't spoil it for you, but when they start announcing the final votes, do the math. You'll see there is a mistake that the screenwriters, director, editors and studio completely missed. In its current form, that story flaw actually ground the film to a halt for me as I counted and recounted their math in my head, oblivious to what was happening on the screen. As the characters continued to wind the story down, I wanted to yell, "STOP! You've done the math wrong. The story doesn't make any sense now." Maybe it's just me, but those kinds of things really throw me.
When Romano's bumbling plumber "Handy" isn't wasting our time (will he finally commit to his girlfriend?, will he win the election?), the rest of the film is quite solid. Strong support comes from Marcia Gay Harden, Maura Tierney, Fred Savage, Rip Torn, and even Christine Baranski (who comes off terribly in the trailer). But it is a bit unnerving to watch 74-year-old Hackman woo Tierney, who at age 38 is nearly half his age.
Overall the film is only mildly amusing. That is thanks to the life (and laugh) sucking presence of Ray Romano. There is one genuine laugh-out-loud moment -- it features Hackman, Tierney and a horde of news crews at her front doorstep -- which, thankfully, is not given away in the commercials.
The film would have worked better if Hackman's character was less likable.
Tell Your Friends