Reviews

45 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
6/10
So strange, I do not think you can spoil this movie
11 May 2008
Warning: Spoilers
A strange story of Jesus (Clémenti), before his passion. His mother Marie (Zouzou) cannot get him out of the house to do his proselytizing, but eventually he takes bullhorn in hand and gets rejected at every door. He meets Marie Magdalène (Zouzou) who is happy to spend time with him as long as he gives her stones like her other clients. He spends a lot of time with these two women and occasionally goes out to proselytize in the water, on the rocks and in the swamps, He is ridden off his donkey by some thugs on horses while he gives out drugs to various prostitutes along the way. And he sees horrific suffering when his mother opens Pandora's Box. In the end, he wanders off into the ocean while a very pregnant Marie or perhaps Marie Magdalène lies on her back like a beached whale at the edge of the water. Beautiful stark rocky sets with intense lighting and minimal acting. Except for a few scenes with the thugs and Monty Python like fighting apostles, there is little music. Oddly compelling and intense visuals, that might hold anyone's attention, even if they knew nothing about the Jesus stories.
10 out of 12 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Beautiful, but ineffective Documentary
23 March 2008
A beautiful documentary about the death industry in India. It is presented with vivid sound but no words or subtitles in English. I found the film a bit hypnotic and sleep inducing at the beginning, but as I gradually started to piece together a narrative of what I thought could be happening I started to construct a story from the presented sounds and images. Cows munching on marigold leis, burning bodies, pouring water on the ashes, fighting dogs, hauling wood for the pyres and an ill tempered funeral director haggling over the price of a service. I'm sure that no one else came away with an understanding very much like mine, but the film maker was able to give me vivid images so I could invent my own story.

Unfortunately the director thought he was presenting an essay. For me with no words, it was like trying to understand an essay written in German, for someone who speaks and reads only English. I could pick out a few common ideas around death rituals that I have seen or sat through such as an Irish wake, or sitting shivah, but I missed most of the meaning and details about this set of Hindu cultural practices.

Though it is not what I expect from a good documentary, this very polished film may be more insightful for someone who has spent considerable time in India.
8 out of 13 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
A grim humorous tale of twisted relationships
8 December 2007
Warning: Spoilers
On the tenth anniversary of Japan's WWII surrender, a motley group of five, four men and one woman, gathers in the basement of a butcher shop to dig up a cache of morphine buried during the war. A grimly humorous tale of twisted relationships as one by one each of the group is eliminated. This early gangster film foreshadows similar tangled relationships in Shohei Imamura's later films. I do not have much more to say, but I liked the movie enough to write a comment even though I cannot fill up all of the 10 lines required by IMDb So I do not have much more to say, but I liked the movie enough to write a comment even though I cannot fill up all of the 10 lines required by IMDb
8 out of 19 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Carte ghermez (2006)
5/10
For voyeurs only
17 November 2007
A highly publicized show trial of Shahia Jahed, mistress of soccer star and coach Nasser Mohammad Khani, who confessed to killing her lover's wife in 2002 and then recanted publicly after both Khani and his mother in law asked for Jahed's execution. This highly emotional footage was spiced with home movies taken by Jahed of her and Khani in the apartment they shared as well as a guided tour by Khani of the murder site. Like the OJ trials, this seemed aimed at voyeurs who watch daytime soaps rather than any serious audience. I do not think there is much more to say about this lurid documentary, but I will type until I fill up the full ten lines.
2 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
A subtle study in sales ethics
30 June 2007
Warning: Spoilers
I wonder who is orchestrating the campaign to discredit this movie by voting in a block against it. I suspect that many of those 43 people voting a 2 have never seen it, and are simply responding to a viral effort to kill the film. But I cannot figure out what the puppeteers found objectionable with this movie.

The film itself has the feel of a low intensity Glengarry Glen Ross, without the claustrophobia or the cursing. With the passion and eagerness of aspiring musicians as a backdrop, this is really a story of the salesmen who allow themselves to be duped into believing that they are actually helping others.

Great World of Sound features some nice performances by the leads: Pat Healy as the reticent Martin and Carver Johns as his loquacious and exuberant partner Walter. All in all there is some ethical subtlety here. But that might be hard to detect if you've been a victim of a similar scam.
15 out of 22 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Enthusiasm (1930)
6/10
A tribute with no coherent story.
3 December 2006
The first sound film of Dziga Vertov, this is a tribute to the first Soviet 5 year plan, opening with the forcible transformation of churches to social and political clubs, filming work in the coal mines of the Donbass region in eastern Ukraine, capturing the sights and sounds of steel and locomotive works, and finishing with some scenes of harvests in the Ukraine countryside. Most of the focus is on work and the potential glories of the new Soviet citizens who promise to exceed the quotas of the five year plan. This is a marvel mostly because of Vertov's mastery of the early sound technology which required cameras that weighed over a ton. With speeches and inter-titles shifting between Ukrainian and Russian, there is no narrative, no actors, no script and only some visual references to Eisenstein's fictional works. It is easy to see why this film was more praised outside of the Soviet Union than inside and why so few of the workers filmed had any interest in watching it.
7 out of 18 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Farewell (1983)
6/10
This could have been a lot better.
3 June 2006
Warning: Spoilers
Matyoroy is a small village on a beautiful island with the same name. The party has decreed that the island shall be flooded for a hydro-electric dam. This story focuses on the inhabitants of Matyoroy, who watch the disassembling of their village. Darya (Stanyuta) is a grandmother who does not want to leave her ancestor's graves behind, but she cannot get anyone to help her move them to the mainland. She becomes the center of a group of islanders who do not want to move. Her son, Pinegin (Durov) is tapped to be the foreman of the crew preparing the island for submersion by the local party leader. They are supposed to disinfect the cemetery, cut down all of the tall trees, remove all of the people and livestock then burn all of the dwellings and barns. The residents move reluctantly, slowly harvesting their grain, digging their potatoes, and boarding up their houses. But a few, with Darya at their center dawdle so long that the island is flooded with them on it. They chose remaining with their forbearers to moving to the mainland. This film had some possibilities, but it ended up dark, heavy and leaden. Difficult to follow at first, it became weighted with symbolism, mysticism, fire, fog and overly dramatic music. I would have hoped that it would have been better if Larisa Shepitko had been able to complete the film. At least the shots of her first day of work with the cast shown in the short tribute "Larisa" seemed more interesting than the footage shot by her husband after her death.
7 out of 23 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Krisana (2005)
6/10
This feels a lot like an early Jim Jarmusch movie.
27 January 2006
Warning: Spoilers
Matiss Zelcs (Dombrovskis) is trying to find a woman which he ignored when he passed her and who was about to jump off the bridge last night. He heard her splash followed by cries for help, but never saw her or her body. The police don't want to continue investigation as no body was found. However Matiss starts his own investigation, finding that the woman had been drinking at a café earlier in the night he saw her, and had left her handbag behind along with some crumpled half finished notes to a certain Alexej (Korobov). After pretending he was her lover to get the articles, Matiss sorts through them carefully and takes a receipt in the name of Alina into the photo developers to get some slides she had left to be developed. He sees that she appears to have been a mother with a young son and a husband that she did not seem close to. Matiss further sees that Alina (Dzerve) was very interested in another man of whom the husband seems jealous. He also finds an envelope addressed to Alexej Mesetzkis and visits his flat. There he learns that Alina had been living for several months with Alexej who indeed is the man of the photo, but she has recently disappeared after several days of fighting. Without letting on that he has the slides or the half finished notes, he asks Alexej to consider if he has driven Alina to desperate measures.

This is a very slow movie with little conversation, much of it in Russian rather than Latvian. Long slow black and white shots mirror the depressed mood of the main character in a movie that feels a lot like Jim Jarmusch's Stranger Than Paradise. But as with Stranger Than Paradise, I had a hard time staying awake through the first half of Krisana.
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Le silence (2004)
8/10
Intense, uncomfortable and real
8 July 2005
Warning: Spoilers
Oliver (Demy) and Marianne (Régnier), his pregnant French fiancée have come to vacation in Corsica, where she swims while he joins his cousin Vincent (de Peretti) and other locals in the daily boar hunts. Though Oliver grew up on the Island, he is returning to Corsica from Paris, and is accepted in the hunting party only because he is with Vincent. Many of the older women in the village know his mother or grandmother, but they are skeptical of his Parisian girl friend. His vacation is turned upside down when he stops to get air for his tire at the local convenience store and witnesses a murder of the cashier by one of the more volatile men of the hunting party. But he does not go to the police right away, trying to figure out weather to tell anyone. And of course, his aunt tells him that in Corsica that people cannot get hurt if they mind their own business. But his silence takes its toll, straining his relationship with his fiancée and making him even more quiet on the hunt and with Vincent. Well developed realistic hunting scenes and subtle male female dynamics. This is intense, uncomfortable and real with a constant low level tension developed by the tight music and effective black and white dream sequences.
7 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Beautiful visuals, but jumbled, dreamlike story
17 April 2004
Warning: Spoilers
In Chasing the Birds, Farukh (Dzhanik Faiziyev), a young boy gets a brutal education in medieval Uzbekistan. The boy wakes the town shouting that the almond trees are in bloom, and gets a sound beating for rousing the towns folk from their sleep. Farukh is pursued by Amandyra (Dilorom Kambarova) a young woman who has a crush on him, and wants to elope with him, but when she is forced to marry after he does not come for her, she is unwilling to leave her wealthy new husband for him. Much of the film happens in open fields and streams, with Farukh's flashbacks to the village and his mother who died at his birth. This is all too jumbled to follow any chronology, or even know when the boy is dreaming, daydreaming or remembering an actual event. The boy also lost his father to drink, and then the town folk take all of Farukh's remaining possessions to satisfy his father's debts. After leaving the village with only the clothes on their backs and their ingenuity, Farukh and his childhood pal Khabib find a young orphaned girl Gultcha, who tags along with them until she and Khabib fall in love. When Farukh is away, a member of nobility who has taken a fancy to the girl, has his hunters invade their camp and then he rapes her. The Bey then kills Khabib in an underwater knife fight, before battling with Farukh. Lots of color and flashbacks & dreams make it hard to follow this non linear mystical story of lost loves and abuse by bandits or landlords. The acting is pastoral, even simplistic and the subtitles are hard to read against the light background; but the visuals are spectacular, so the 87 minutes are not a total loss.
0 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
A cross between Chaplin and Fellini
7 March 2004
Warning: Spoilers
After losing his job in a layoff, Pedro (Gomez) cannot tell his family or the others in their happy but poor shared household. Instead he has a dream of finding a suitcase with an inexhaustible supply of money and using that to give his wife Margarette (Kaplan) an unforgettable birthday feast. Through the dream he always has to watch out for the petty police officers and is embraced by the poor who are happy to see him when he hands out money. At the end of the feast he has only the bill from the grocer and no money to pay.

This is an odd cross between Chaplin and Fellini, with subtle expressions of emotion, clear social commentary, Nino Rota like music and a bittersweet ending.

Well made.
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
L'isola (2003)
7/10
Beautiful, slow and captivating
16 December 2003
The slow naturalistic pace, beautiful photography, a sense of the local customs & values, and a captivating performance by Veronica Guarrasi as Teresa make this well worth seeing. The director seem to have captured the end of childhood and the start of adolescence.
2 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
L'isola (2003)
7/10
Beautiful, slow and captivating
16 December 2003
The slow naturalistic pace, beautiful photography, a sense of the local customs & values, and a captivating performance by Veronica Guarrasi as Teresa make this well worth seeing. The director seems to have captured the end of childhood and the start of adolescence in her first narrative feature.
4 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
A lot is lost in translation
25 October 2003
This movie focuses on Santu, a young low level clerk in a small town government office who is trying to maintain his social standing, resisting efforts of his boss, landlord and landlord's wife to make him into a servant. He is a bit of a dweeb and his wife and he do a lot of verbal sparring. Nice portrayal by the wife who, though exasperated with him, maintains the marriage and provides some good common sense for the partnership. There is a lot of witty wordplay among the numerous characters that is hard to follow in the subtitles. I found it less funny and less compelling than the Indians in the audience.
1 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Devdas (1955)
7/10
Not a pretty picture of pre-independence Bengal
20 May 2003
Like "Gone With The Wind" and Wuthering Heights, Devdas is based on a literary classic and is a landmark in cinema. Pre-independence Bengal and Calcutta come alive in this movie but it is not a pretty picture. The story itself verges on bathos, with a young man, Devdas (Kumar), drinking himself to death after his childhood chum and beloved Paro (Sen) marries another (older) wealthy man. That marriage happens only because Devdas' wealthy father and older brother refused to allow him to marry Paro, the middle caste girl next door. The pain is, she loves Devdas too, but cannot act on it.

The parallel story has Chandramukhi (Vyjayanthimala), a dancer & call girl from Calcutta, falling in love with Devdas as well while he is drinking away his sorrows. But he is so focused on Paro and so negatively judges Chandramukhi's profession, he cannot notice her. When Devdas finally appreciates Chandramukhi's devotion, for her own safety he dare not take her home.

This is a sorrowful classic, but with the overwrought pain, it plays more like "Wuthering Heights" than like "Gone With the Wind".
2 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Easier to follow, but boring
18 May 2003
Slick but not very interesting special effects, nonexistent acting and boring repetitive fight scenes allow lots of time for bathroom breaks, but at least this time the plot is easier to follow. This may be a teen aged boy's idea of a complex plot, but only if they have seen too many Saturday morning cartoons.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Ndeysaan (2001)
7/10
Who can forgive murder?
9 February 2003
Warning: Spoilers
In a mythical pre-colonial village fishing village on the south coast of Senegal, a strange ocean mist hangs over the waters for weeks and the local fishermen fear to go out to sea. One son of a wise elder, after his father's death decides to take his boat onto the waters and returns when the mists lift with a full catch. He has become a hero, and has won the heart of the prettiest girl in the village, but has also won the envy of his best friend, who also covets the girl. When the friend murders the hero, and drags the body to sea, no one in the village explicitly accuses him. But within months the girl agrees to marry him. Immediately after the marriage tells him that she is pregnant, that she wants no sexual relationship and that he will raise his victim's son as his own as the price of forgiveness. Painful as her price for forgiveness turns out to be, that is not enough for the ghost of the victim.

The pace, the magic, and music of this movie remind me of "Daughters of the Dust" by Julie Dash.
2 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Bronx-Barbès (2000)
7/10
Well made, insightful movie
8 February 2003
A good slice of street mores and violence in West African cities and a window onto the cultural influence of US Street gangs in African slums. Sensitive direction for the first commercial effort by this director and solid acting make this worth a special effort to see. But because of the realism, it is not a "feel good" movie.
1 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
The Hours (2002)
7/10
The music diminishes a fine film.
31 January 2003
This was a fine story, well structured and very well acted by a great cast. Occasionally I found it a little confusing when the early cuts were made to new characters in 1921 England, 1949 and contemporary New York.

But the music was a monumental distraction: a repetitive, intrusive overlay that tried to shape the viewers emotions and interfered with the unfolding stories. The only story appropriate music, was the full volume Opera that was blasting in the background as Clarissa Vaughn was preparing for her party. While I am no fan of Opera, and was relieved when Clarissa turned it off to talk with her visitor, it was the only non manipulative music in the film. Even over the closing credits the music was manipulating.
0 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
A game attempt to show the human impact of occupation.
25 January 2003
A fair depiction of the hardships under occupation, and the customs of the middle class Muslim Palestinians in Jerusalem. Perhaps because it was filmed in Jerusalem streets under such adversity, this film is a bit amateurish with mismatched music substituting for compelling acting.
6 out of 12 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Inspired by an item on the back page of a newspaper
15 November 2002
Shot in 16 mm in Paris & its suburbs and co-produced by French television on a very low budget. This was inspired by an item on the back page of a newspaper. The essence of the film is captured by its first person voice-over commentary, and was considered "one of the few genuine masterpieces in the entire history of cinema" by film theorist Noel Burch. The film is not available in English translation, either dubbed or subtitled. But it works very well in simultaneous translation, if prepared in advance.
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
To Stay Alive (2002)
6/10
Dariush Mehrjui is capable of better, less manipulative work.
15 November 2002
A young woman tries to escape from the much older man she was forced to marry, by burning herself. She is following the practice of a friend who immolates herself after she is forcibly removed from medical school by her traditional father (who does not want her to work in the evil, tempting environment of a hospital). Another friend, a rug maker, had been beheaded by her brothers when they suspected her of having an affaire with a young soldier. Though I find the plight of the women as portrayed heartrending, this is a bit disjointed and too melodramatic for comfort. Dariush Mehrjui is capable of better, less manipulative work.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Zan Boko (1988)
7/10
What do we lose when European progress comes to the ancient village?
26 October 2002
Kaboré raises the question of what "progress" does to established peoples and what is lost when villages are urbanized or when money driven relationships supplant bonds of mutual favors and obligations. He is heavy handed, but not inaccurate is his portrayal of westernized Africans who no longer value the folkways of their parents and grandparents. Though he portrays them as kind caring parents and spouses, he also notes their corruption and their willingness to crush anything that might jeopardize their social and economic position.

But this is a timeless story of "progress" that could be played out without corruption or greed, whenever modern and ancient cultures collide. Kaboré asks the questions, shapes our sympathies, and does not or cannot give answers.
4 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Wend Kuuni (1982)
7/10
This is a story of belonging and memory.
26 October 2002
Warning: Spoilers
The film opens with a confrontation: a woman, whose husband has disappeared in the bush, is being forced by her husbands family to marry another brother so the husbands infant son will be raised in the family. She runs away to a remote village where the family cannot find her and raises her son in poverty as an outsider. Several years later, when the outsider is blamed for bringing bad luck in the form of an infant's death, she and her son are run out of the remote village.

Most of the story is told from the point of view of the young son, after he is found mute in the savanna and has been given the name Wend Kuuni by his adopting family. Only when his speech returns after several more years do we learn of his mother's flight from her ancestral village and their flight from the mob at the second village. But it is important to understand this history as a contrast to the Wend Kuuni's adoption into a family and sense of belonging in the third village.
4 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Still do not know Emily Dickinson
4 October 2002
Made for PBS, this is a self-conscious attempt to understand the person behind Emily Dickinson's poetry. The directors use voice over commentary to explain how they come to make this movie and their dissatisfactions with their initial attempts. Trying to get historians, biographers, psychologists, off-the-wall academics, and eventually auditioning actresses who read Dickinson's lines and improvise on four trick questions, the directors get conflicting interpretations, but never present a convincing portrayal of the person.

Still, the poetry seems more accessible with several readings, especially when recited by Julie Harris.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
An error has occured. Please try again.

Recently Viewed