Reviews

3 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
Monte Cristo (1929)
9/10
Restaured wonder with palpable silver-screen magic
21 July 2008
Last night, I incidentally tuned on Arte, and the first part was on (pre-intermission I guess). It was late and I thought a silent black & white flick would drown me into sleep in a gently manner, as usual.

Well, let's just say that sleep was simply not to come about soon...

Oddly, the long expected slide down the dozing-off slope was perversely disrupted by the interest I began to gradually feel sipping through the thick walls of my legitimate exhaustion.

For sure I can't comment on the whole movie until I watch the second part which will be aired next Monday (July 28th), but I wouldn't miss it for the world.

Although the restoration could not be complete as a couple of visual bugs persist on the odd instant (probably remnants of unfixable damages), the work accomplished allows the viewer to "touch" the picture : the characteristic make-up used in black & white movies, along with the slight overacting de rigueur in mute movies confer a kind of 3rd dimension in conjunction with the brilliant setting of the lights, and after this laudable & technically optimal restoration.

I guess we can get here an idea of the magic felt by non-blasé early 20th century movie-goers as they couldn't help but let the movie lead them to another sphere peopled by characters that look extremely human & close to us, yet somewhat otherworldly...

A scene in particular struck me as brilliant and reminds me of the main gimmick in "24 hours" some 75 years later : as Julie Morrel is returning home with her dowry as well as the receipt that saves her father from going bankrupt & imminent suicide, the scene is sliced with many shots at a clock to enhance the suspense... except that the shots were made in such a way that I still have to re-watch it to determine whether the same clock was used or not, even though I had a dozen opportunities to verify that after I'd noticed the trick !!!

I just can't wait for next Monday !!!
7 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
light-hearted & "light-hearting"
15 December 2007
When I tuned accidentally into this movie as it was broadcasted on french sat-TV , I ended up watching it through even though it was available only in dubbed version (which I consistently zap in a NY minute...)

When I realized that afterwards, I found several reasons for that :

* While the plot is so simple that the one displayed on the top of this movie's page suffices, and when one doesn't expect a "masterpiece", one can still enjoy a comedy where the characters are almost as caricatural as in cartoons (the good guy, the princess, the dictator, his cunnin'& plottin' assistant, the silly groom etc).

* Of course, in order to achieve that, characters had to be exaggerated as well as stretched to the limits - often beyond !!! - of all kind of realism (still think cartoons).

* When not taken seriously - as it's not supposed to be - this movie can have an effect on people that is not without reminding that of an old Chaplin or Marx Brothers (all things kept in their respective leagues, in a more policed & modest way) for the occurrences of "the absurd" or rather "the very unlikely in such a situation" help take the viewer to other spheres.

* Hence, and since the cast fulfills its comic assignment with honors, and even if this could be said about many similar movies, I can in my heart and soul prescribe a decent dose of this one to the temporarily - at least - depressed !!!

Broadcasted on french TV as : Amour sous les tropiques
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Girl Overboard (2005 TV Movie)
6/10
2 young women end up working on a cruise-ship for fare
30 May 2006
funny & fresh like many German romantic comedies... the redhead comes to tell her blonde girlfriend that her married boyfriend won't join her on a cruise-ship & that he dumped her...the messenger wakes up on the ship at sea...both women end up working on the cruise to pay the fare... as u guessed, funny situations occur involving crew & passengers, especially the cruise's physician which whom the red head messenger had a hectic bar encounter before boarding to warn her friend... fate being facetious, misunderstandings keep occurring, where an Asian crew member fills in for the psychic reader, full of (not so traditional) wisdom, & while the cruise roams the western Mediterranean Sea... As in most German movies, sunny beaches & locations are filmed with undeniable touch & rendered in a somewhat poetic manner... Ensues a light comedy far from non-entertaining...

aka L'amour au grand large (France)
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

Recently Viewed