Reviews

10 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
Marco Polo (2014–2016)
10/10
Original and addictive!
9 February 2017
Warning: Spoilers
"Marco Polo" offers a fascinating view of a historical episode that has received comparatively little attention on western TV. Visually, the production is gorgeous: the scenery, costumes, and architecture look beautiful and convincing, while imaginative camera work presents each scene and action in the most intelligible and appropriate way.

What really holds my interest, however, is the characters. Every one of them (and there are lots!) has a distinctive personality and point of view. The excellent script and brilliant performances make each character—even the minor ones—vivid and compelling. Kublai Khan in particular comes to life as a complex man with a surprisingly dry sense of humor. The scheming, ambitious Chinese courtier Jia Sidao, with his cool demeanor and mantis-obsession, makes a superb villain. Although the series is named after Marco Polo, and focuses on him frequently, the story has a grand scale that makes Polo at times seem small and somewhat insignificant. This is not a flaw.

I can't believe the hostile commentary this show has attracted, much of it seemingly motivated by political correctness. I see nothing stereotypical or condescending about "Marco Polo"'s treatment of martial arts, concubines, etc. Some people are never satisfied!
1 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Frontier (2016–2018)
2/10
Disappointing!
31 January 2017
Derivative slop: stereotypical, 2D characters; threadbare tropes; blah acting; and a flat script without originality, insight, or wit. Our hero is a scrappy Irish kid with a winsome colleen back home. The innkeeper at Hudson Bay is a slim redheaded gal who wears trousers and carries a knife. All the English are greedy, corrupt pigs. The "priest" is a slimy con-man, because all TV priests are required by law to be villains. The Indians include a warrior gal who looks like someone from Burning Man. Despite slick production and lots of facile color and conflict, not one of the characters seems appealing or even convincingly human. Who cares what happens to them or their projects?
92 out of 166 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Gripping, moving, authentic
11 April 2012
Warning: Spoilers
Gripping, moving, and authentic, Gibson's "Passion" is the best Jesus movie ever. Unlike earlier, more "tasteful" versions, which unfold so slowly they make their subject matter boring, "Passion" gets right to the point. The crucifixion is the heart of Jesus's mission, without which our redemption could not happen. Gibson focuses on that. The horrifying violence and rivers of blood are hard to look at, but that, too, is the point, and the way these things are presented--the colors, the camera angles, the flashbacks--find beauty and meaning amid the gore.

Besides bringing the New Testament's heroes to life, Gibson does a great job of presenting its villains. Judas comes off believably as someone who immediately repents of betraying Jesus. He throws his blood money of silver coins back at the priests and runs away from them, but things spiral downhill from there. Soon Judas has attracted a crowd of nasty urchins who chase him through the desert, tormenting him. When they finally disappear he finds himself sitting on the dirt next to a dead donkey swarming with maggots. His ensuing suicide feels completely inevitable. The devil keeps popping up all through the film, represented by a skulking, shrouded figure in the background. Near the end we see the devil revealed in his true element--a parched, cracked wasteland littered with bones. He's sitting on that ground, raging, and the camera looks down at him and rises away as fast as possible, just as we would do given the chance.

All the characters are portrayed by little-known actors who look just right. Surprisingly, the subtitled dialog in Latin and Aramaic isn't distracting at all--the spoken lines are short and familiar anyway.
1 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Portlandia: Farm (2011)
Season 1, Episode 1
10/10
Brilliant!
8 February 2011
Ostensibly about Portland, OR, this show is really a delightful skewering of all the pretensions of contemporary hipsters, eco-freaks, and other counter-cultural elements. I love the opening skit, a paean to Portland's weirdness, with an ever-growing parade of oddballs marching down the street singing "The dream of the 90s is alive in Portland." Even better is the skit about an ultra-feminist bookstore called Women and Women First, with a grim, touchy, defensive staff and a totally impractical approach to retailing. Then there's the couple who want to order chicken in a restaurant. They relentlessly interrogate their waitress about how it was raised, and the waitress gives them the chicken's complete, full-color dossier. A few people play all the roles, often cross-dressed. The humor's deadpan but wicked. Portlandia's a breath of fresh air.
11 out of 13 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Brilliant! Don't miss this!
6 February 2010
You don't have to be a fan of Lovecraft or Cthulhu to love this movie. I knew little or nothing about the writings upon which it was based, but was utterly blown away by the accurate period style of the film itself. From the first moment, the music and visuals were so evocative of the silent era, I could hardly believe this film was made in 2005. The starkly lit, artificially scratched black and white film had all the right dramatic angles, the right velvety black shadows and harshly burnt highlights. Tremendous trouble was taken with costumes, furniture, and props, right down to the flawless old-style penmanship on the handwritten documents. The acting had that funny combination of wild exaggeration and offhand naturalism so typical of silent films...and the dialogue titles were marvelously succinct, and printed in period-perfect fonts. The music deserves special mention, suiting the film at every turn and conjuring up a whole style and time. Some of the footage--e.g., that featuring old cars--must have been created long ago, but has been seamlessly integrated into the new, lending a real sense of authenticity. The total effect was not just impressive but moody and beautiful. I LOVED this movie. It made me want to rush right out and imitate it (a sure sign of artistic success). Do yourself a favor and check it out. Pure pleasure!
3 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Breaking Bad (2008–2013)
10/10
Dark, cynical, depressing, GREAT!
19 May 2009
"Breaking Bad" is the darkest show on TV, and possibly the best. The main character, Walt White, is a high school chemistry teacher with cancer, a pregnant wife, a disabled son, and no savings. Hoping to leave a nest egg when he dies, he teams up with a young lowlife and begins cooking crystal meth. Walt and his accomplice are in way over their heads, and get into one harrowing scrape after another, from stranding themselves in the desert to being kidnapped by a psycho drug lord.

Deep ironies abound. Walt's double life entangles him in so many lies he can't keep track of them all. This damages his relationship with his family (who were the reason he started cooking meth in the first place). Unforeseen complications keep sabotaging Walt's drug operation and eating into the money he makes. As he puts it, everything is "one step forward, two steps back."

"Breaking Bad" approaches its characters with a penetrating sense of human frailty and zero sentimentality. Though Walt's a sympathetic character, he does many unsympathetic things. His wife, loyal and moral almost to a fault, nurses a secret crush on a former boss. Walt's young accomplice has an inconvenient streak of decency, but not enough to overcome his own essential weakness and stupidity.

The hypocrisy and "quiet desperation" of middle-class suburban life have been worked to death in books, movies, and TV. "Breaking Bad" gives these themes new life with clear-eyed, pitiless characterizations, brilliant acting, gripping plot twists, imaginative visual style, and grim black humor. The nearest analogy I can think of is to Flaubert's "Madame Bovary." "Breaking Bad" is a masterpiece.
21 out of 34 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Brilliant!
26 December 2003
Despite some tinkering with the storyline, this is the best-ever film adaptation of Dickens's classic tale about a hard-hearted old miser who rediscovers his capacity for love and kindness one Christmas Eve when ghosts force him to re-examine his life.

The poignant ghost of Christmas past dredges up Scrooge's memories, good and bad, reminding him of his early idealism and the bad choices that destroyed it. The jolly ghost of Christmas present shows Scrooge a vision of joy and abundance and the goodwill in most people's hearts--and ends with a chilling reminder of need in the midst of plenty. The terrifying Ghost of Christmas Yet to Come forces Scrooge to confront his own mortality and to see the meaninglessness of his selfish life in the starkest possible terms. Sobbing with penitence, Scrooge vows to change his ways, and when he awakens on Christmas morning his joy produces film's most delirious fit of glee.

The film is perfectly true to the spirit and even the language of the original book, and drives its moral home with powerful, unforgettable performances. Alistair Sim is magnificent as Scrooge.
4 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Whale Rider (2002)
Predictable
22 June 2003
I wanted to like this film because of its themes of nature-worship and self-empowerment. But geez, was it slow! Flat characters and a totally predictable storyline didn't help. (If you've seen the trailer, you've seen the film.)
0 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
The Majestic (2001)
A trite, saccharine disappointment!
6 June 2003
Jim Carrey is a comic genius. But this film wastes his enormous talent in a straight role that any competent actor could have done equally well. The Majestic is a big, sloppy Valentine to small-town America, the magic of movies, the importance of integrity and patriotism, blah blah blah, zzzzz. I actually dozed off a couple of times while watching.

(Note to Jim Carrey: you're a good actor and all, but could you please go back to the funny faces and slapstick...pretty please?)
0 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Amusing
8 March 2001
This light-as-a-bubble comedy annoyed me at first with its giddy farcicality but slowly won me over with the gentle wisdom at its core. Polyamory may not be for everybody, but in this story it transforms life for the three main characters: a lonely housewife, her businessman husband, and her underachieving lover. The story moves right along and takes some clever, unexpected turns before arriving at an enormous final irony. All the performances are good.

(Special note to "Zulu" fans: "Blossom" contains a few sly allusions to that great film, including scenes where James Booth shows up in a red tunic. The effect is somewhat incongruous, though, because Tuttle's voice and manner are completely unlike Hookie's.)
6 out of 12 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

Recently Viewed