The ending of Attack on Titan leaves viewers without much explanation, which is the main reason I read negative reviews among people.
It's only natural that there are these two opposing viewpoints: some people like to be able to reason about what happened and reflect to figure out what the true message of the series was, with their own interpretation, while others want to be guided to the underlying message by the viewing experience itself.
So I decided to illustrate my point of view, constructed by reasoning with multiple people and observing various perspectives:
Eren dies when he kisses Historia's hand in season 3. From that moment, he sees the massacre that will happen, and he asks to himself...how is it possible for me to do such a thing? At the end of season 3 we see him pointing his finger across the sea and wondering if that is the solution. There we already had the clue about the character's evolution, with his gaze lost in the void and the future. When talking to Armin, we see that Eren tries to explain to him how he reasoned about his actions. He tried to change things, but everything converged there, and so he wondered what was the purpose, the reason for everything.
The answer? There isn't one. He didn't do it for his friends because some died, he didn't do it for an everlasting peace because there is no such thing, it is a utopia. He then wonders if he is just a fool with divine power...but that is not the case too.
Since he knew the future, he no longer had any freedom of choice.
This is the cornerstone of the argument! He lost his freedom. And it is not a justification for the atrocities he did, but an indictment of war itself, the cause of all evil. Eren became a puppet of hatred and war.... And all that for a kiss on a hand.
There was never any plan by Eren, because what ruled his actions were not his choices, and this from the very beginning of season 4! The author made us believe in a plan...which was really just fate itself. A "dark fate" we might say.
I find this ending brilliant, a poem of horror and fatalism.
Having finished the reasoning part, I would like to mention the wonderful animation, music and dubbing of the characters (original version). There were some truly breathtaking and tremendously emotional scenes: Armin scolding himself by looking at his motionless body, the baby in the crowd, the team-up of Levi and Mikasa, all the scenes in the credits, ...
If you have read this far, I would like to thank you for your time and hope that this review helped you to better understand one of the perspectives of this complex and colossal episode.
It's only natural that there are these two opposing viewpoints: some people like to be able to reason about what happened and reflect to figure out what the true message of the series was, with their own interpretation, while others want to be guided to the underlying message by the viewing experience itself.
So I decided to illustrate my point of view, constructed by reasoning with multiple people and observing various perspectives:
Eren dies when he kisses Historia's hand in season 3. From that moment, he sees the massacre that will happen, and he asks to himself...how is it possible for me to do such a thing? At the end of season 3 we see him pointing his finger across the sea and wondering if that is the solution. There we already had the clue about the character's evolution, with his gaze lost in the void and the future. When talking to Armin, we see that Eren tries to explain to him how he reasoned about his actions. He tried to change things, but everything converged there, and so he wondered what was the purpose, the reason for everything.
The answer? There isn't one. He didn't do it for his friends because some died, he didn't do it for an everlasting peace because there is no such thing, it is a utopia. He then wonders if he is just a fool with divine power...but that is not the case too.
Since he knew the future, he no longer had any freedom of choice.
This is the cornerstone of the argument! He lost his freedom. And it is not a justification for the atrocities he did, but an indictment of war itself, the cause of all evil. Eren became a puppet of hatred and war.... And all that for a kiss on a hand.
There was never any plan by Eren, because what ruled his actions were not his choices, and this from the very beginning of season 4! The author made us believe in a plan...which was really just fate itself. A "dark fate" we might say.
I find this ending brilliant, a poem of horror and fatalism.
Having finished the reasoning part, I would like to mention the wonderful animation, music and dubbing of the characters (original version). There were some truly breathtaking and tremendously emotional scenes: Armin scolding himself by looking at his motionless body, the baby in the crowd, the team-up of Levi and Mikasa, all the scenes in the credits, ...
If you have read this far, I would like to thank you for your time and hope that this review helped you to better understand one of the perspectives of this complex and colossal episode.
Tell Your Friends