Change Your Image
octaviodelser
Reviews
Star Trek: Discovery: Kobayashi Maru (2021)
This should not be called star trek
There is not a single good thing about this episode other than the special effects. I feel bad for the SFX team.
Writring is bad and I mean bad bad. Cringy, unrealistic, predicatable feels like they hired an inexperienced child.
E.g.:
"are you sure you should be leaving the ship during a red alert?"
...
"Madame president are you questioning my decision?"
"A question doesn't imply questioning"
A question DOES imply questioning, and in the army you would be reprementded for that. Such lines are very common and destroy the startrek universe, it feels like they are acting on giant toys going pew pew pew rather than managing a multi billion FTL spacecraft with thousands of crew. I mean come on.
Chikyûgai-shônen-shôjo (2022)
A wasted opportunity
Great setting but thats it.
Issues:
way way way to much branding I get the idea but constantly mentioning it for no reason it felt like i was watching a perpetual ad, this killed any and all setting i mean filler for ads??? Come on!
Very very lazy research:
1.
Ask any child you ger than 12 or so to pretend like they are talking on a phone they dont use the same gesture as us. Pur gesture would not work in this setting.
2. miss use of ai. Systems in this setting would have much more autonomy than what you present, I think even just talking with someone in the industry will have made a huge difference.
Tldr: this is a visually ok flop.