A good enough plot (a little different than the book) and some excellent visuals, but that is not enough to not deliver good storytelling by itself.
The most obvious limitation of any screenplay, whether for movies, tv or streaming, is to have a well-written script, and in this respect, the script fails. If I were to close my eyes, and imagine what year/age/dimension/universe this was written in, I would say 21st century America, so mediocre is the writing. It almost appears that the demographic is 15 years old, with a 5th grade reading level. It is disappointing when a fantasy story does not move the viewer to another time and place (a la Lord of The Rings). Netflix seems determined to "dumb down" its writing for the least sophisticated audience it can attract. I can almost hear them telling the writers "Don't make the audience have to think at all." In this they succeeded.
And, compounding the writing is a cast that, while likeable enough, cannot act their way out of the proverbial "paper bag." No nuance in the acting for anyone except Iroh, Appa and Gyotsa. Commander Zhao is a one-note actor in this series. Sokka, Zuko, Azula and Katara may eventually hone their craft, but, in this, they appear to be reading their lines as though it was a rehearsal. No facial expressions of any depth cross their faces at any point.
I'm hoping there'll be another season where the writing and acting are better, but for now, it's kiddie fare.
Now, my husband likes it and he's a college professor, so don't go by me. Any movie has to reach the viewer and it appears to have reached others in a way it did not do for me. To each his own.
The most obvious limitation of any screenplay, whether for movies, tv or streaming, is to have a well-written script, and in this respect, the script fails. If I were to close my eyes, and imagine what year/age/dimension/universe this was written in, I would say 21st century America, so mediocre is the writing. It almost appears that the demographic is 15 years old, with a 5th grade reading level. It is disappointing when a fantasy story does not move the viewer to another time and place (a la Lord of The Rings). Netflix seems determined to "dumb down" its writing for the least sophisticated audience it can attract. I can almost hear them telling the writers "Don't make the audience have to think at all." In this they succeeded.
And, compounding the writing is a cast that, while likeable enough, cannot act their way out of the proverbial "paper bag." No nuance in the acting for anyone except Iroh, Appa and Gyotsa. Commander Zhao is a one-note actor in this series. Sokka, Zuko, Azula and Katara may eventually hone their craft, but, in this, they appear to be reading their lines as though it was a rehearsal. No facial expressions of any depth cross their faces at any point.
I'm hoping there'll be another season where the writing and acting are better, but for now, it's kiddie fare.
Now, my husband likes it and he's a college professor, so don't go by me. Any movie has to reach the viewer and it appears to have reached others in a way it did not do for me. To each his own.
Tell Your Friends