Reviews

1 Review
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
10/10
Gentle, humorous look at a simple (and probably vanished) lifestyle
2 February 2002
A whimsical and thoroughly enjoyable film that only the British could have made and then, only in the 1950s. The gentle giant hero; the stereotypical and yet reassuring secondary characters; and the most beautiful scenery combine to make this charming film well worth the look.

No blood; no special effects; no nudity (we do get a glimpse of a woman changing at the beach which was probably pretty racy in 1950s Britain); and no improbable explosions. Just a peculiar reliance on something called 'story'. There aren't any real baddies in the film just a crowd of Englishmen and some incompetent but well meaning policemen.

Well written and very funny. Most of the gags still work very well. Even my teenage son sat through this film and laughed.

Heart-warming, comforting and, in the end, highly moral film that depicts Island life with it's minor prejudices (Catholics and Campbells) with a beautiful understanding and deeply affectionate approach. Nigel Tranter, the author of the original book, wrote many great stories about Scotland and I can recommend both this film and his books wholeheartedly.
8 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

Recently Viewed