3 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
Rome (2005–2007)
10/10
Outstanding! Makes Gladiator and Troy look fake
27 August 2006
This series almost defies belief with its masterful attention to cultural detail combined with a level of accuracy that is simply astonishing for popular series or movies. One could almost believe that someone laid hands on a time machine and took the whole crew back to 52 BC for filming. Clearly, no expense was spared in the making of this series, which has all the polish and flair of a big-budget movie, combined with an archeologist's critical eye for accuracy and detail.

For the look and feel of being there, this film is miles above "Augustus", "Nero", and "Empire", which have a too-clean low budget look to them, and while having the same grittiness as "Gladiator", there are no grossly over-enlarged computer generated buildings. Instead, the real closeness of the cement insulae (multi-story apartments) that real Romans lived in are marvelously depicted, complete with the kinds of graffiti that really existed. There is trash in the streets, there is no "segmentata" armour (incorrect for this period, chain mail only!), cleansing oil is used in the baths (no soap then!) and then scraped off, the jewelry looks like it was stolen right out of a museum, the list goes on and on…

As for cultural immersion, this series once again raises the bar. The Romans were a different culture and their attitudes to life and death, propriety and impropriety, and their spiritual lives were very different than our own. This series takes on the challenge, and unashamedly depicts life as it must have been in those times. If there was no fig leaf, then there IS no fig leaf. (I should mention that the 18A rating is there for very good reasons). In this show, a dead person looks like a dead person (blue etc.), sex looks like sex, etc., so be prepared for no punches to be pulled.

The lives of the rich, the poor, and the slaves, and their relationships to each other and the gods are all shown honestly.

The story. Ah, the story. Nicely done. O.K., it's a soap opera, but I'm pretty sure that the Romans invented them (didn't they?)… The story is not overly convoluted and it does not have the annoying "point A" to "point B" direct line plot of sooo many Hollywood productions these days. There are two main plot lines. The first concerns two Roman soldiers and their life amongst the plebeians. The second follows the fortunes of Gaius Julius (the man who would be Caesar), along with his family and other such famous personages as Pompey, Cato, Cicero, Mark Antony, Brutus, etc. Of course, you KNOW that these two plot lines will frequently cross… The amazing thing is that it makes Caesar's rise to power seem like less than a sure thing. (And if THAT was a spoiler, you need to read a book. Seriously.)

All in all, marvelous, simply marvelous. Go BUY it. There absolutely HAS to be more seasons! (If this goes the way of Firefly (i.e. gets cancelled) there's no justice. Sex, violence, accurate historical setting, eye candy— what's not to like?
12 out of 17 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Crummy title - Great movie about human beings!
11 February 2002
A Japanese naval officer and an American pilot find themselves stranded alone on a desert island during WWII. How would you react to being marooned with a dangerous enemy? This film is an obscure treasure that should be better known. I suspect that people are put off by the cheesy and unsuitable title. The film explores the evolving relationship of two men from different cultures as they each struggle to find the best way to survive. Their collective fate is an exploration of the human condition.

One outstanding feature of this film is that it is in both Japanese and English, intentionally without sub-titles. An American or Japanese audience could watch this film and appreciate its message. This duality serves to heighten the cultural differences between the two men, and it is cultural bias that is the true enemy.

Buy it, it's a keeper!
41 out of 48 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Das Boot (1981)
10/10
Experience the Battle of the Atlantic in an Iron Coffin...
10 February 2002
Everyone should see this film. Everyone should read "Iron Coffins", U-Boat commander Herbert Werner's personal account of the U-Boat war. There is nothing in this movie that did not actually happen to one U-Boat crew or another. The set design is amazing, it IS a type VII U-Boat tossing in the North Atlantic, and you are there. It is impossible not to imagine that you will share in the fate of the crew, and the idea is terrifying. One can not help but wonder how men could endure such conditions knowing that they faced almost certain death.

This film can not be taken lightly-- it will, and should, provoke reflection on the terrible waste that is war. At the height of the "happy time" the Grey Wolves were sinking more tonnage than could be produced by the United States and Canada. It wasn't until the construction of Liberty ships reached its peak that we began to break even. Do not forget the terrible toll on the brave crews of the Merchant Marine and Navy who faced dangers and terrors every bit as horrible as the ones faced by the U-Boat crew. Winston Churchill said that the Battle of Britain was a difficult time, but that winning the Battle of the Atlantic made the difference between life and death for the United Kingdom.
4 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

Recently Viewed