This is a very long review - but given The Little Mermaid was my favorite animated movie as a kid, I think it is worth the read. :)
As a 1998 dude, I grew up on the Little Mermaid 1 and the Little Mermaid 2. Ariel is my favourite Disney Princess, and a big reason for that was her casting, Jodi Benson. So when I heard that it was the next film to get a Live Action Movie, I was a bit worried at how it would be handled. I wasn't too sold on Halle's casting at first, but I have to admit as the promos kept being released, and as she posted her attachment to the character, she grew on me. I then decided I would give this movie a go, to see what it is like, and if it is better than the original. And I have to say - I was not disappointed. The movie is not perfect by any means, but it was a very pleasant experience. I still prefer the original movie, but this movie is an okay live action adaptation.
For the cast, it was hit and miss. Melissa McCarthy was not a good Ursula to me. She felt like a cheap imitation. The original one had charm and sass, and a very eerie/commanding presence that made her entertaining. Melissa just did not deliver that. She was the best in the ending scene right before she died, and tbh her emotions were lacking there too. Daveed was not a good Sebastian. The accent sounds inauthentic and he seemed more like a nag than someone who was basically another Father figure to Ariel. Flounder and Scuttle were voiced well - but they had far too few scenes, especially Flounder. Triton was hit and miss - you don't feel the love he has for his daughter in this version, and sometimes his delivery was very monotonous. Some scenes he did deliver well though, and I loved his design. Eric was okay, the actor was a good choice, and I enjoyed his scenes. His mom was great too, and Grimsby was spectacular. He is one of my favourites in the cast.
For the CGI, the underwater scenes are beautiful. The trailers did not do the film justice in that department. The sea looked like a wonderful place to be, which is something I thought about the original as well. I was always fascinated by the undersea world, and it is still here. The only aspect of the CGI that I did not like was Triton's trident - it looked kinda dull compared to how elegant and powerful the trident looked in the animated original. The scenes on land were all beautiful too, and IMO the CGI in the movie as a whole was handled well enough. I do think the eels could have been handled a bit better though, and Sebastian could have looked better. Flounder was uncanny valley at first, but I got used to him.
Most of the original is still intact script wise, however, there are some scenes that are dragged out, and more scenes added to fill in the gaps. It is quite good, but the movie felt like it had weird pacing, since the main story is still intact, it's just the scenes took a far longer time to happen, haha. I did like the townspeople having a bigger role. Eric's Kingdom feels very much alive, and his mom and Grimsby were great. Loved their actors and they acted very well. I loved how Grimsby helped them out - he is probably one of the top 3 best members of the cast for me. He made the character feel real. Jodi's cameo made me very happy, it was heartfelt, even if Halle's hair looks weird being groomed with a fork.
There were a few funny moments, main one being when Ariel saw the coconut on land. Because of what Scuttle told her, she was horrified, lol. I loved that reaction from her. Vanessa was a HUGE pro in this movie. Her performance was spectacular and impactful, in spite of her screentime being short. Ursula is a lot eviller here - Triton died before being revived, and there were merskeletons in her cave too. She don't play around, lol.
Now that the pros are out of the way, it's time for some cons. I'm afraid here I have to mention the music. Some of the songs are okay - I didn't mind Wild Uncharted Waters, or the 2nd Part of your world reprise. I also don't really mind Scuttlebutt, but Under the Sea and Part of Your World were underwhelming to me. They don't hold a candle to the original songs. Part of Your World sounded overproduced and scattered - there was no central theme to the song, and the beautiful simplicity and emotion the original one had is lost here. The original one still makes my heart flutter, as you FEEL Ariel's longing for the human world. Here, it didn't convey the same emotions - Ariel sounded too excited for such a melancholic song. Halle sounds like she is showing/proving she can sing instead of singing how she should. Under the Sea was underwhelming as well - Daveed just doesn't have the energy Samuel Wright had, and it's sad. That song in the original is always gonna make me want to get up and dance and sing along, but here, it just sounds so drab and flat. The accent was also not handled well in the song here. The CGI for the scene was disappointing too - I miss the different animals playing the different roles from the original. It added a lot more life to the scene. Kiss the Girl was not great either - I miss all the leadup that the old version had. The song is just not great here, you don't get the romantic vibe of the original, at least to me.
Now for the scenes. Poor Flounder felt like an afterthought in this movie, and before the 1 hour mark Scuttle had little relevance too. Why did they change her species to a diving bird if she had one underwater scene and was only seen once for the entire first hour? As a fan of the original movie and the series, I really disliked that aspect in the live action. They focused too much on Ariel, leaving out the old context for key scenes. For one, in the original, when she goes to the ship, Scuttle goes with her, and offers good commentary there. The statue was never in focus here, so Ariel reacting to it being crushed in the grotto was nonsensical - she had no attachment to it here! Why is is that on shore, the scene involving Scuttle and Sebastian being on the shore was removed, to make them less in focus? The destruction of the grotto was not great either. In the original, you FEEL for Ariel as she has just had her whole collection destroyed. They even toned down the argument she had with her father - sigh- you don't feel the tension here are all. When she yells, 'Daddy, I love him!' in the original you think, 'Ooh, she's in trouble now!' Here, it's like - stop going to the surface, promise me - and then Ariel says no, and he destroys the grotto. CGI was VERY poor here, lol. Triton zapped like 3 spots with minimal explosions, and then zapped the statue. Ariel's crying here was non-existent. She treated it like it was nothing (which ruins the scene). OG Ariel was sobbing and chased her friends away to grieve, and was sad from that point until she went to Ursula here, it seems like it was brushed off. The wisp for her voice in both scenes should have had a little tail, it just being a glowing ball was poorly handled.
Poor Max had little to no presence here. He was such a better character in the original. From first meeting Ariel, to knowing she was the one who saved Eric - he felt more like the town mutt than the Royal Prince's dog. Not giving Flotsam and Jetsam a voice was a very bad choice. It gave them far less character, and they were not entertaining to watch. It also made their attachment to Ursula weaker - her reacting as she did at the end did not feel impactful here as a result of that. They even removed my favourite line from the section! It's been changed from: 'BABIES! My poor little poopsies. ARGH!' to 'Gasp! My Babies!' That was a huge letdown. Her dying was also weird with the CGI too. In the original lightning zaps here, and she thrashes about, then falls over and dies, then bubbles and foam appear as she sinks. Here she gets stabbed, tries to grab Ariel and then she just sinks with a big splash. Very anticlimactic.
ATLANTICA - is sadly not present here at all. We never see the beautiful kingdom of Atlantica here. All we see is Triton sitting on a rock with his trident....with seven seats around it for his daughters. As a kid I wanted to live underwater when I saw Atlantica. The shimmering, golden, beautiful palace, all the merfolk swimming about, all the different sea creature interactions - none of that was present except for Under the Sea. The only time you see additional merfolk that is not the royal family is at the end of the movie - making the underwater realm seem rather flat. Ariel's sisters all have beautiful designs - too bad they are only seen twice, and their scenes are less than 5 minutes. For a 2 and a 1/4 hour movie, that is just sad. The screenwriters from the OG film deserve more credit here, the scene writer they name literally just dragged out their scenes and added in a few new ones.
The Ending - What can I say here? Just disappointing. Ariel and Eric are engaged, after Ariel kills Ursula. Ariel killing Ursula makes NO sense. Triton isn't given a reason here to change how he feels about the humans. Instead he just says whatever and sends her to the surface. Eric killing Ursula, therefore saving Ariel and the ENTIRE sea from Ursula was way more impactful, and it gave Eric more presence and personality. Here it just feels flat. The rest of the ending bothered me so much - this is the only point where we see other mermaids besides Ariel, her sisters and Triton, which is disappointing.
2 out of 15 found this helpful.
Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Tell Your Friends