... now I know, what is so different in this show, compared to the old Star Trek series:
It's a show for teenagers!
Although there are a lot of grown ups in this show, they mostly behave like 14-17 year old teenagers. There's only a few people (Pike, Saru) who function as a kind of "teacher" and "play" adults behaviour.
The crew members meanwhile are like hormon steered teenagers, always ready to break into tears, to talk like pupils in the classroom (and definetely not like grown up professionals) and to do something really stupid "off the book". A lot of talk is invested in fealings.
Yes, it is a science fiction series. Sometimes. But most of the time it's like "Buffy the Vampire Slayer meets Star Wars".
There's no connection to Star Trek as we know it, except for the outfit and some storyline borrowed by older series. But don't let them fool you, you won't have fun with this if you're much older than 20 or if you're even a fan of the older series.
Well, maybe it's time for the kids now, but I doubt it. This show is much too bad to be a success. And since Star Trek Picard is even worse, I fear this is the end of the idea of Star Trek itself.
Edit: it also breaks a fundamental rule of all Star Trek Series: They all get better with the time - here it's the opposite. I'm not sure whether I'm able to watch season 3 till the end or even watch the upcoming season 4. Well, sometimes it's like watching an accident in slow motion, so I guess I'll do it while feeling like an idiot. After that I have to binge watch TNG, DS9 and STE in a row, to erase all that lousy scenes from my head.
There's no connection to Star Trek as we know it, except for the outfit and some storyline borrowed by older series. But don't let them fool you, you won't have fun with this if you're much older than 20 or if you're even a fan of the older series.
Well, maybe it's time for the kids now, but I doubt it. This show is much too bad to be a success. And since Star Trek Picard is even worse, I fear this is the end of the idea of Star Trek itself.
Edit: it also breaks a fundamental rule of all Star Trek Series: They all get better with the time - here it's the opposite. I'm not sure whether I'm able to watch season 3 till the end or even watch the upcoming season 4. Well, sometimes it's like watching an accident in slow motion, so I guess I'll do it while feeling like an idiot. After that I have to binge watch TNG, DS9 and STE in a row, to erase all that lousy scenes from my head.
Tell Your Friends