Reviews

2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
6/10
Pretty okay
26 May 2014
Warning: Spoilers
As far as Marvel animation goes, this movie generally looks good. It allows us to visit two characters sadly left behind in Marvel's cinematic success, and it does them some justice in a reasonably interesting plot.

There are some problems of execution though.

Black Widow's voice doesn't seem to fit, and is somewhat jarring from the very start. Either the actress didn't quite get it or she wasn't effectively directed, but it just doesn't seem to connect appropriately. Really, the voice acting for her character shines most during the tragic romance plot, which is unfortunately very trite and grating. Her part in it may be fine, but the villain's motivation is highly questionable as he sought to be "strong enough to be worthy of her."

That might be fine in a simpler story with more innocent characters, but when it's a story involving Black Widow and Punisher, both dark characters who should be well steeped in matters of betrayal and cynicism, it feels like a stretch.

Where the movie shines is in its portrayal of the Punisher, who stays consistent to his code throughout the course of the story. Black Widow has some character development for the purposes of the story, but Punisher stays a solid rock throughout.

So it's definitely watchable. The action and animation are fun and well done, accentuating the particular skills of the two protagonists. The story beats hit their marks, but just happen to be ones that are more out-of-character for Black Widow.

So if you have a couple of hours to spare, it's reasonably entertaining. You also don't necessarily need it in your life.
2 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Transformers (2007)
1/10
The focus of the movie was just plain lost.
11 December 2008
I should say now that I wasn't a huge Transformers fan growing up. Where I lived I couldn't easily get the cartoons and so on, so I only had a smattering of it now and then.

But even then this movie was terrible.

I'm not going to comment at length as others had on the focus on lame human characters in a movie essentially about giant robots. It might even be considered aside the point that these robots have had 20 years of refined character but in the movie were sidelined for horny teenagers.

But what bothered me (though didn't surprise me, considering it's Michael Bay) was the simple extensive focus on American things.

I understand, and it's okay, that the focus is on America. Most movies are. But the movie tried to pretend that an invasion from hostile alien robots only happened to Americans. This is quite silly.

What really got to me though, was that in a movie with, again, giant cool robots with alien technology and so on... Michael Bay was showcasing American military hardware. This could be fine in any of his other random summer action flicks, but in a movie with, I repeat, giant robots, it's stupid at best. We don't need to know, with Tom Clancy detail, about the weapons on American fighter jets. We don't care, or at least we shouldn't, when there are, again, Giant Robots to fill the screen regarding technology and action. It just seems like he doesn't know how else to make a movie if it doesn't zoom in on a fighter and tell you its schematics.

This, among the other points that other commenters have said with frequency, makes Transformers not just disappointing to fans, but just a nonsensical movie which, at its very best, is just bad and not to be taken seriously. Or hilarious, because it takes itself too seriously for the (lack of) quality in the plot.
5 out of 17 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

Recently Viewed