Reviews

3 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
10/10
A piece of television greatness
17 March 2005
Warning: Spoilers
It's a challenge to recapture the greatness and immediacy that made the theatrical production of Angels In America so incredible. This HBO presentation managed to do that and more. The script was nearly identical, the directing and performances were as good or better, and now HBO could bring in wonderful special effects where they were appropriate (the appearances of the Angel, Prior Walter's hallucinations and Harper's trip to Antarctica). This production of Angels earned its seven Emmy Awards, and could have had more. It's obvious that everyone who was part of this undertaking dedicated themselves to it wholeheartedly. There wasn't a single bad performance, and some scenes, most notably Louis' recitation of the Kaddish prayer with Ethel Rosenberg's assistance at Roy's bedside, made me laugh and cry simultaneously. Being Jewish and knowing the prayer and the culture around it certainly helped, but I'm confident the power of the scene worked no matter what faith or background the viewer came from.

Angels tackles profound and difficult issues such as AIDS, death, fear, persecution, bigotry and homophobia with a sensitive, unflinching seriousness (and more than a bit of humor) that people are often afraid to nowadays. Angels is every bit as relevant now as it was when it first premiered on stage. Tony Kushner's script is timeless, and I think one of the finest examples of writing, not just playwriting or screen writing, to have come along in the past 30 or 40 years. I think this version of Angels in America stands with Ken Burns' Civil War series as one of the highest quality and most important pieces of television programming ever created, by anyone, ever.

Don't just watch it once; buy the DVD and keep it, then watch it again. It's that good.
23 out of 30 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
An infuriatingly bad movie
30 December 2002
I read the book with great pleasure because the author, Seb Junger, was a friend of mine in high school. The book was well-researched and perfectly crafted. I live in Massachusetts so I vividly remember the storm and the tv coverage of the search for the Andrea Gail. The movie could have been so good, but it made me angrier than any movie I've ever seen. It was horrible, almost from the opening credits. Everyone mangled some pathetic semblance of a Gloucester accent, except George Clooney, who didn't even bother to attempt one. The directing was ham-handed. The acting was wooden and one-dimensional from everyone involved. The music was laughably overblown. Even the hi-tech wizardry was utterly wasted, as it depicted impossible scenes like Captain Billy Tyne being thrown around from an outrigger and surviving. Seb didn't even contemplate that happening because the idea of it was ludicrous. No fisherman on earth would try that maneuver in any storm, ever. There is no reason anyone should see this movie, period. It's a horrible insult to the lives and memories of the people who perished in this storm, and a sad legacy to a brilliant piece of writing.
25 out of 52 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Armageddon (1998)
2/10
Bad bad movie.
30 December 2002
Just awful. I was ROOTING for everyone to die at the end. It was a perfect example of a hollywood blockbuster that completely ignored basic concepts like plot, character development, script or even intelligence. Truly an awful movie. I'm sure teenagers loved it, but they don't know enough to care that it was bad.
2 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

Recently Viewed