Reviews

2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
Pirates of Silicon Valley (1999 TV Movie)
9/10
Fantastic - They absolutely nailed it
19 February 2010
The other reviews already provided a synopsis of the movie so I won't recap again. This film focuses on the rise and rise of Micro$oft and Apple and the personalities that drove these 2 companies.

The film is an extraordinary achievement. It's a little movie that few would know about and even fewer would remember and that's a shame. I was fortunate enough to find a VCD of it in Asia around 10 years ago and then bought a DVD of it just recently also in Asia (yes all legitimate...these do exist in Asia) Apart form a compelling story, what appeals about this film is the atmosphere they created. It's a nostalgia piece without intending to be and is designed for a very specific audience: those of us that were either part of the industry in the 70s and 80s or (as in my case) grew up with an Apple II in their life and vividly remember the times. But it will appeal to the uninitiated also who will unfortunately not enjoy or understand the layers of detail and history in it.

The film carries some very specific references that are really spot on (I can imagine the uninitiated wondering what the heck is this Apple II vs. Mac thing all about for example?). They perfectly capture the excitement of those early days. From references to phone phreaking, to the Apple I, to home brew computer clubs (remember those?), those early PC shows with black and white handouts, and on it goes. If you lived through those times and were in the scene, fond memories will come flooding back. You can just about feel the excitement that was around this mysterious, ultimate status symbol that the Apple II was in it's day.

The performances are spot on. Everything I've read and seen of Gates and Jobs in that time is absolutely nailed by Wyle and Hall.

But most of all this was clearly a project made by a group of people with a true love of the subject matter. Clearly, no one involved got paid the big bucks and thankfully it's not a movie that was written by a committee. And this comes through from the 1st minute to the ending.

And ultimately, why do i rate this movie so highly? Because every single time i've put it on (now up to the 5th time or so i've seen it), and plan to watch a few minutes of it, I end up watching the whole thing without a break. A triumph within it's subject matter...there's nothing else like it out there...don't miss it!
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Cute, but oh so embarrassing. Bekmambetov - what were you thinking??
12 February 2010
Warning: Spoilers
Let's pretend for a moment that it's 1999. There is no Spiderman. The last Batman movie with Mr Freeze is a recent but quickly fading memory and we have not even heard of Chris Nolan...well outside of Australia at least, and the only thing we know of the transformers is that it's a plastic robot toy from the 80s that used to...hang on, that's right, turn into a truck or something... I'd also be 11 years younger and perhaps a little less cynical and forgiving of schmaltzy, clichéd stuff. So, in this imaginary world where we have a time traveling De Lorean or equivalent, I would have walked out of Black Lightning and thought "Man, what a cool movie. Those Russians really are breakthrough...how awesome was that!". "Yes it's a bit back to the future, but who cares...that was FUN!!"...

Except it's not 1999, and I am 11 years older. I've seen Spiderman where he discovers his gee whiz powers, where his gr amps gets killed, with great power comes great responsibility, etc. I've seen transformers where a beat up old car becomes something awesome. And i've heard the brooding music from Nolan's Batman. I've seen Iron Man take his enemy up in the sky until they both froze up and he ran out of fuel and dropped back to earth...should i go on?

So why the heck did they make this movie? Did they just assume that no one in Russia watched all of the above and they could put together a greatest hits compilation of some of the better super hero American fare? Probably. But for those of us who have seen these movies, Black Lightning (the name makes me cringe!) is a Frankenstein cut and paste, in many cases scene by scene steal of far better movies. It's b grade schlock made for an uneducated audience.

Yes, I'm being harsh. I enjoyed the movie for the first 30 or so Min's. It seemed fresh and interesting. Then at about the point where the car first takes off I felt this sense of dread. Oh oh...that bit looks like America's Greatest Hero...and that bit is Transformers...and that bit is Spiderman (why am I watching this again?...never mind...it'll get better)...and that bit is just like (well you get the idea)...And the flying Volga is actually more ridiculous than a flying De Lorean...

I should say some kind things about the film...let's give this a go. The heavy metal Russian soundtrack is pretty cool. The girl in the movie is rather lovely, but her flipping between the boys got old real quick. The special effects are not too bad considering it's a low budget film (although they are cheesy) and the surround mix is typically over the top for a 5.1 modern Russian film.

At the end of the movie I felt disappointed and embarrassed for all concerned with this production. And Bekmambetov really should have known better!

So if all the above disclaimers don't concern you, go ahead and watch it. But, you have been warned...
13 out of 20 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

Recently Viewed