Reviews

Hansal Mehta is a craftsman. Pratik Gandhi is sensational and deserves all the praise for his performance.

Friends i should say i was one of those people who were anxiously waiting for the release of this film. But after watching this film i came out to be disappointed. 1st half movie rocks as much as 2nd half of movie sucks. All the director is wanted to show in this movie is a Journey of a Rockstar and a love story. But, quite clearly he failed at both. But i should say this movie is still good in its bits and pieces and also a "great camera work has been done". Talking about performance... Ranbir Kapoor has proved it again, seriously a flawless outstanding performance by him. On the other hand, Nargis Fakhri is bad ...but she is very beautiful throughout the film. Music of A.R. Rehman is breathtaking (still, not better then Rock on ). So, at the end i should say that there are moments in the film where you will feel yourself connected to the movie but then again several continuity flaws and a not so good ending of the movie doesn't works out. It is a one time watchable movie and also the movie made in a non-chronological order(Not quite effectively) but you can still watch it because of superb acting done by Ranbir Kapoor.

If you are a Die hard fan of John. Then, maybe you will find it useful. But for other those who are watching it just for having a great time...Then NO ...Because there are several Flaws and weaknesses in the film ...sorry not several......actually many. First, Cinematography of this film sucks Big time. Secondly, story hasn't been well thought out. Thirdly,camera positioning is quite awkward. Fourthly, Odd locations has been chosen for filming and ....So on. But about performance part, .... I should say John has done some good Workout and also acting. Genelia, is also quite good in her performance but her character hasn't been written well. So, not a worthy film to watch. Summary : No. of times i looked upon my watch(while watching the movie) - 9 Story - 6/10 (For Indians).(**This movie could have been much better) Performances - 8/10. Direction and other departments - 4/10