Here's my thoughts on Dune. But first and foremost, I must apologize if I put in spoilers in which I might not realize it or unintentionally. So sorry about that.
So with that said...
Wow! What can I say!
Villeneuve's Dune is definitely way way different from the Lynch's version. It's not as weird or boring as that. Nor was it as wooden or overly-dramatic as the 2000s ScyFy series.
The whole experience of it was somewhat, I would say, poetic yet serious in the likes of Christopher Nolan's "The Dark Knight" trilogy especially when it's augmented with Hans Zimmer's score.
I would also like to highlight that there was a tinge of the 2015 Justin Kurzel's "Macbeth" where the atmosphere at times felt grim and gloomy. But that's not a bad thing. It just adds to the seriousness of the movie. Speaking of Macbeth, the movie does give off that Shakespearean quality about it which I very much appreciate it; hence why I thought this Villenueve's Dune is rather 'poetic'.
Before going into the movie, I was afraid that it be a snooze-fest just as Villeneuve's take on his "Blade Runner 2049" despite it being visually stunning. But as a fan of the books, I'm certainly glad that it was far from boring. I don't feel like it is in any way a slow burn as what some reviewers described it. The pacing was just right like it was right out the book. Yet I couldn't say the same for those who are unfamiliar with the story. They might, I worry, get very impatient with it.
And not to give anything away or spoilers, there were definitely changes from the source material. In particular, that dining room scene from the book where disagreements were expressed out among the characters was not in the movie. Another point to take note was the use of spoken languages among the various groups which I don't ever recall Herbert used in the book. Such that, they actually took the effort in creating languages to distinguish which group of characters they're from. It was interesting take that Dr Yueh was speaking in Mandarin while conversing with Paul and the latter responded with the same. I mean 'Yueh' is, after all, a Chinese name so I think it's kinda appropriate. I also picked up some Arabic in some of the scenes especially when the Fremens were talking to themselves.
As for performances, it is definitely Timothee Chalamet's shining achievement. This is his movie. Rebecca Furgeson also gave her possibly emotionally wrenching performance. There were scenes whereby I could empathize with her pain, not as a Bene Gesserit, but as Paul's mother. Oscar Isaac, too, was compelling and had me convinced that he was good enough to be Paul's father. Collectively, both Isaac and Furgeson played it excellently well as Paul's parents to give him enough care yet with firm sternness to protect their son.
The scope of the movie was indeed epic in terms of the scale. For example, the sizes of the heighliners in comparisons to the smaller ships. Those were massive. Think those individual alien attacker crafts in "Independence Day" compared to the main mothership, except that the latter was three to four times larger. And those Ornithopters were perfectly made to mimic dragonflies yet upon closer look they do resemble helicopters. The costumes were stunning. So much so that I'd described them as being "lyrical", if that makes sense.
Hans Zimmer's score is also worth mentioning. It fits the movie perfectly but it does not overpower the feel of any scenes. Although I did find his use of bagpipes to be out of place. And sadly, we did not get to see Gurney Halleck strum his baliset. It'd be interesting to see how Josh Brolin would sound like if he were to sing.
For me, personally, the only thing that was amiss was the exclusion of the Emperor since he was mentioned many times throughout the movie but with no physical representation of himself on screen. And as many of us already knew, Feyd was not included in the movie and it did give the strange feeling that the main Harkonnen players were around except for him. Or Count Fenring, for that matter.
Yet, all in all, they did capture the gist of the book so I'm not disappointed at all. Dune was a beautifully made film that I wouldn't mind going for a second viewing. And I could certainly see that it would garner quite a substantial amount of nominations especially in the technical categories.
59 out of 97 found this helpful.
Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Tell Your Friends