Change Your Image
Timothy_Walton
Reviews
Republic of Doyle: One Angry Jake (2012)
1/10 Is Too High
My girlfriend and I both love this show. We can go through two or three episodes in a row on DVD and look forward to more whenever we have time to watch it.
But this episode was so bad we gave up and went to the next episode.
My girlfriend has been an ESL teacher for RCMP officers and has served on a jury, so she knows something about how the Canadian justice system works. She was almost screaming at the TV for how many glaring inaccuracies there were.
I just found the writing lazier than the typical partisan pundit's research.
Fudging details for the purpose of drama is common, and all police or court-based shows do it from time to time; the better shows try to find ways to tell the story within the constraints of the actual legal system.
This episode should never have been made. It should never have made it to first draft. If 10% of the procedural details in the first twenty minutes were right it was mere serendipity.
There is suspension of disbelief, and then there is suspension of higher brain function. If you haven't figured out by now which is necessary to watch this episode to its finish, you might be able to finish watching it.
We weren't.
ECW Hardcore TV (1993)
Watch It Grow
Eastern Championship Wrestling made the move to SportsChannel Philadelphia in April 1993, having been broadcast on a local UHF station before that. From its new home on SportsChannel, the show would gain syndication in many more markets throughout the United States.
This series is for the dedicated ECW fan. The early episodes were standard local promotion wrestling for its day - a few has-been veterans working the indy circuit with a group of local guys wrestling for the love (and beer money) of it. Within a couple months the changes begin, first with the arrival of Paul Heyman playing his Paul E. Dangerously character while becoming an associate producer behind the scenes.
Eddie Gilbert is the booker when the series begins, so much of the show is focused on the stable he builds, Hotstuff International; yes, he spelt it Hotstuff.
Several of ECW's long-term personnel are there from the start - refs John Finegan and Jim Molineaux, ring announcer Bob Artese, and wrestlers J.T. Smith and The Sandman, thought The Sandman has a surfer gimmick and J.T. Smith hasn't yet become The Italian Stallion.
The main enjoyment I found in these early shows is watching the debut of the hallmarks for which ECW became famous - chairshots, drink containers as weapons, action outside the ring that sometimes spills into the crowd, high-flying moves from the ring to ringside, balcony dives, and fan signs. And that's just in the first dozen episodes.
I'm working my way through the episodes from the start, and the quality improves as it goes, so it's hard to give an overall rating. I expect it will be up to 7/10 within the first three months, having started at 2/10.