Speaking from watching the Assembly Cut, I think the film is a masterpiece. Not a "flawed" one either, a straight up one. The characters are amazingly drawn, the dialogue is superb, the acting is incredible (honestly, Possleweight, Dance, McGann, Dutton, Webb, Glover - what a cast! It's a whose who of some of the great British actors), the cinematography bleak and powerful, the directing sharp and dynamic, and my god, is it emotionally impactful. Its the only one, out of the three, to have a central human core to it, a genuine sense of little humans trying to muddle through the universe with all their (decidedly, in this case) flaws. Each character, even those given barely a minute on screen, are instantly memorable. Glover's fussy, absurdly uptight little Captain Mainwring, an overzealous little trumped up burecract who seems to treat the running of essentially a squalid prison/monastery as if he was in charge of a military, played with meticulous perfection by Glover, who seems to be able to spit and squirm every word put of his mouth, like a legal document given a voice. Charles Dance is a beautiful performance, so understated and nuanced it is just agonising to watch, it may be his best. Compare him here to either his great work in Game of Thrones, or even his zanier offerings in that Schwachzenegger film, and its clear his range. He plays it with deft sincerity, while still retaining a sense of real, serious brokenness behind his eyes, its gorgeous. Paul McGann gives a stunning performance, a truly unnerving portrayl of complete and utter psychosis, with a gibbering, sing-song, almost childlike speech pattern containing all manner of dark forebodings, in the end becoming a sort of mad acolyte for the xenomorph. Charles Dutton gives a staggering performance, a badass warrior philosopher monk, who as much as preaches the gospel of this prison spirituality cab spout swear words from the top of his lungs and act as kick ass possible, a brilliant conception, and one of the most memorable characters in the whole franchise. In fact, the entire conceit of the ex-con monks, rapists and murderers and serial killers forming a sort of demented Franscican underworld Church, is brilliant. A particular stroke of genius is in the way it manages to turn the bald heads of prisoners, shaved for lice, into an act of religious denial, much akin to medieval or even more Buddhist monks. It also grounds the plot to believable and concrete goals. A rather obvious issue with a story like this is a) Ripleys a woman in a world of viscous, sex-starved men. This isn't going to end well. And b) if their so viscous and awful, what's their moral rewaon for trying to defeat the xenomorph at all? Making them a caste of warrior-monks solves both issues, as they can't rape Ripley by definition, as it violates their code (not that it stops some of them) a religious vow of total celibacy to avoid going down the path of sin, and also, by giving these bizzare misfits a religious creed, gives them an instigation to kill the beast. In that sense, if Alien was a thriller horror akin to the slasher films of the late 70s/80s, and Aliens are rip roaring action packed spectacular, this is a gothic religious epic. A jacobean tragedy, a descent into hell with the would be atoners defeating a force of unmitigated evil, a religious spiritual quest which turns into a holy war, draped across the bare ruins of a science fiction landscape. What a genius move for Fincher!
Its beautiful. The relationship between Ripley and Clemens is agonisingly beautiful, two lost souls bonding over shared pain, destroyed before it could even get started. And in fact, the agony and heartbreak of the film is precisely what makes it a great Alien film, in fact, its the direct successor to Alien. The bleak cosmic horror, sense of encouraging doom, fatalism, morose, macabre atmosphere and ever increasing desperation is replicated perfectly here, but with an added emotional punch which just isn't in the first.
Cus here's the thing, I don't actually like Aliens as an Alien film. The first film manages to capture a sense of dread, isolation and total and utter helplessness when confronted with something utterly outside our knowledge with pitch perfection. Aliens substitutes the mood of the first, that of a group of terrified apes struggling to stop something evolutionary above them by centuries in its ability to kill, with action packed shoot them up splatter glory. It replaces Ripley's victory in the first film, which is as much luck as it is intuition, a sort of exhausted pyrrhic victory, with a bombastic, almost absurdly melodramatic punch up with the Queen. Its just not a good Alien film. Its undoubtedly a masterpiece in the action genre, but compared to the first, it can barely even stand up. Turning the Aliens from ruthlessly methodical killers that can kill an entire crew in a matter of seconds to just a hoarde of mindless animals robs them off their true power. The real amazing thing about the Alien in Alien is that its just one thing against a whole crew, in the end it leaves only one. They have to destroy the entire ship simply to defeat it, thats how powerful it is. In Alien, the threat is terrifying by just how lethal it is despite its numerical weakness. In Aliens, its never doubted their a threat, cus there's tons of them. So duh, of course they're a threat, but then why is this is any way original or creative? You could replace the xenomorophs in Aliens with any monster and you'd have the same film, you can't do that in the first.
The third then, IMO, manages to recreate the true essence of what the Alien films are all about, isolation, a war of extermination, being hunted, grief, misery and hopelessness, while also providing a genuinely likeable (amazing considering the nature of the characters) bunch of humans, and some moments of humour too.
And the directing, my god, what astounding visuals! Like driving directly into hell itself, red crimson burning red everywhere, a dingy, macabre, subterranean refuge for this group of warrior monks, the offscourings of humanity left to rot and atone for their sins. If nothing else, the visuals that you'll be left with will stun you, the image of the large fan from which one poor Red Shirt is sucked into, the staggering chase sequence around the tunnels, the sight of an xenomoroh Alien breathing and snarling towards Ripley's face; it is a cinematographic triumph, and prefigures Fincer's brand of paradoxical Gothic realism, a simultaneous mix of heightened, aesetic misery and a ruthless griminess which he perfected in Seven.
To me, the whole film is completry vindicated by the end, voluntarily jumping into a pool of molten lava, arms out, crucifix like, saying goodbye to a cruel universe to save it from her own perverted, warped child. In one science, she becomes the Modanna and Christ in a single act, the mother who is destined to produce a seed conceived through foreign impregnation, something reliant on the human to leech off yet above her in abilities and skills, but, crucially also sacrificing herself precisely to defeat said perverted, warped, mutant child. To some, the Xenomorph is the new Christ, something to be worshipped, like Golic, or praised for its aesetic beauty and higher purpose, like the Weyland Corporation. But in one act, the Christian myth is brilliantly warped, an act of anti-childbirth by the chosen mother, who turns her own humanity outwards and allows the christ sacrifice committed to reliquish mankind of its sins to be performed *by* the human mother Mary herself. By not allowing divinity to be produced by humanity, she denies the cruelty of the former and elevates the majesty of the latter. Its a stunning piece of myth making
Its staggeringly heartbreaking, its emotionally devastating. Its such a profound act of humanity, this space trucker gal of no worth or note, with no military background or important status, saves everyone just by her smarts, her resourcefulness, her bravery and her kindness, which in the end is precisely what made her so amazing in the first film any way.
It's a masterful film. I adore it.
3 out of 3 found this helpful.
Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Tell Your Friends