Reviews

2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
10/10
Unsurpassed plot contrast. Touching, tragic and complete.
4 January 2007
What begins as a would be cliché fantasy immediately shows it means business as much, much more.

I would think twice about letting a very young child watch this film, it can be horrifically brutal while heartwarming at the same time.

The characters are well developed, you care for them. The performances are solid all around.

The fantasy elements are as clever as they are good looking CGI-wise.

After flipping through a few pages of these reviews most people with negative responses were expecting Disney type plot convenience, and cut aways rather then actually showing the violence.

The entire film acts as a metaphor for growing up, it has messages about relationships, courage, honor, fear, and most of all the harshness of life.

The stark contrast of the young girl's fantasy to her real world surroundings will keep you glued to the screen.

You can't compare this to a harry potter or lord of the ring, it shines in its own way.

Don't miss this one.
2 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Thank god this is on the 250 list.
22 October 2006
I am 23 years old and am rapidly becoming extremely bored with modern Hollywood.

I am not a film student, I only came across this because I was going through the top 250 on here and was amazed at the year of this one, so I picked up the DVD.

I would love a time machine to see something like this being made.

It transcends time, and one could argue it has been "borrowed" from throughout this past century.

Well worth a few slow moments, the plot style is years ahead of its time. Its quite graphic in some areas too, this also came as a huge surprise to me.

I can't even explain the feeling you get watching this, its like the deep dark secret of Alfred Hitchcock, John Carpenter and Tim Burton all rolled into one. As directors they've all made history in their own right, but this movie just reminds me of them in some way, its tough to explain.

My version featured colorization of certain scenes, but it was done with a semi transparent color tint frame I am not sure the original featured this...

Reguardless, if you have some patience and are in the mood for something a little different, try this. You will not soon forget it.

10/10 without question.
22 out of 32 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

Recently Viewed